# Brad Dispute.mbox
# 90 messages, sorted chronologically

================================================================================
#1  2025-04-03T01:57:09+00:00
From:    Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>
To:      "asaf@shamir.com.au" <asaf@shamir.com.au>, "brad@bradgish.com"
	<brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Alia
 Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Dear Asaf & Bradley,

We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via DocuSign for your review and signing.

Documents that require 'pen to paper' signatures that were unable to be sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these documents to our office.

We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability of $14,616.75 must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than 15 May 2025.

Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.

Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.

Yours sincerely,

Karen Monohan I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:karen@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>



Reference Number: 780620_1
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer ------------------

Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.

================================================================================
#2  2025-04-27T11:06:23+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      "asaf@shamir.com.au" <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>, 
	Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Everyone

I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I
would like to sign off on the
financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.

   1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir
   Holdings. Is that correct?

   2. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount
   determined as income for Asaf)
   - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility -
   is that correct?

   3. Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this
   is also for the software,
   owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a
   developer employed
   by Shamir Holdings?

   4. Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS
   messages paid for by Raw Mobility
   and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue
   corresponding to those messages.
   Is this correct?

   5. The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?

   6. Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really
   acting as an agent between
   Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?

I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to
understand some expenses so
please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.

Looking forward to hearing from you

Kind regards

Brad

On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Dear Asaf & Bradley,
>
>
>
> We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw
> Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via
> DocuSign for your review and signing.
>
>
>
> Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be
> sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these
> documents to our office.
>
>
>
> We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability
> of *$14,616.75* must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than *15 May
> 2025.*
>
>
>
> Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also
> been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.
>
>
>
> Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any
> further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.
>
>
>
> Yours sincerely,
>
>
>
> *Karen Monohan *I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
> karen@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> *Reference Number: 780620_1*
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards
> Legislation
>
>
> ---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer
> ------------------
>
>
> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail.
> If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use,
> reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and
> unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender
> by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of
> the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to
> be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do
> not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this
> communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses,
> interception or interference.
>

================================================================================
#3  2025-04-27T23:24:08+00:00
From:    Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
To:      bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>, Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>,
	"asaf@shamir.com.au" <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Hi Brad,

Thanks for your email. @asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au> Asaf, I believe that you are the best person to answer those queries from Brad as they mainly relate to the arrangement between your entity and Brad’s entity (i.e. Mobivate), and remuneration agreement in the Raw Mobility. If you would like us to contribute on any part, please let us know.

Should you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Yours sincerely,
Vincent Cai CPA  I  Associate
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:vincent@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Sent: Sunday, 27 April 2025 8:06 PM
To: Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>
Cc: asaf@shamir.com.au; Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Everyone

I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I would like to sign off on the
financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.

  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
  2.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
- assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
  3.  Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
by Shamir Holdings?
  4.  Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility
and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
Is this correct?
  5.  The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
  6.  Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to understand some expenses so
please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.

Looking forward to hearing from you

Kind regards

Brad

On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Dear Asaf & Bradley,

We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via DocuSign for your review and signing.

Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these documents to our office.

We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability of $14,616.75 must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than 15 May 2025.

Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.

Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.

Yours sincerely,

Karen Monohan I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:karen@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87t1Aa4f6yBkAqcahN?h=BRGbfrz699IkJ9FisnqPlTit_nfDTp2zDBw5ooqAjsI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>



Reference Number: 780620_1
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer ------------------

Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer ------------------

Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.

================================================================================
#4  2025-04-28T08:11:09+03:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>
Subject: Fwd: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Good morning Jeremy,

I hope you had a nice passover.
This is a bit urgent, so I hope you’d be able to provide a response as soon as possible.

I’m currently in Cyprus on holiday, and have received the email below from my co-director and (majority) shareholder in Raw Mobility - Brad Gishen.

I haven’t responded to him yet, and would appreciate it if you could review my suggested response below and provide some guidance and/or suggestions as to how I should respond.
> It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
As per our prior discussions and agreement, I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
> Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
> - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
That is incorrect. 
> Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
> owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
> by Shamir Holdings?
R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.
> Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility 
> and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
> Is this correct?
Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.
> The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it charges license fees from Raw Mobility. 
> Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
> Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?

That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in this context.



Thanks in advance,
Asaf


> Begin forwarded message:
> 
> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
> Date: 27 April 2025 at 1:06:23 pm GMT+3
> To: Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>
> Cc: "asaf@shamir.com.au" <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
> 
> Hi Everyone
> 
> I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I would like to sign off on the
> financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.
> It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
> 
> Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
> - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
> 
> Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
> owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
> by Shamir Holdings?
> 
> Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility 
> and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
> Is this correct?
> 
> The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
> 
> Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
> Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
> I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to understand some expenses so 
> please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.
> 
> Looking forward to hearing from you
> 
> Kind regards
> 
> Brad
> 
> On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> Dear Asaf & Bradley,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via DocuSign for your review and signing.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these documents to our office.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability of $14,616.75 must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than 15 May 2025.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Yours sincerely,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Karen Monohan I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> 
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
>> karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:karen@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>>  
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Reference Number: 780620_1
>> 
>> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation
>> 
>> ---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer ------------------
>> 
>> 
>> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
>>

================================================================================
#5  2025-04-30T10:31:13+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com>
Cc:      Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>, "asaf@shamir.com.au" <asaf@shamir.com.au>, 
	Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi everyone

I hope all is well. I have added Asaf's Raw Mobility email in case he never
received the previous email.

Asaf, please can you revert as soon as possible as the shareholders of the
various companies
need to understand how you have set this up and who the actual supplier to
Mobivate is.

There is also an invoice outstanding to Raw Mobility but if the real owner
of the code and supplier
is Shamir Holdings, then Mobivate needs to pay Shamir Holdings.

Please revert ASAP so we can clean up the financials and understand what is
going on because
right now things seem incorrectly allocated and inaccurately recorded.

Thanks

Brd

On Mon, Apr 28, 2025 at 12:24 AM Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Hi Brad,
>
>
>
> Thanks for your email. @asaf@shamir.com.au <asaf@shamir.com.au> Asaf, I
> believe that you are the best person to answer those queries from Brad as
> they mainly relate to the arrangement between your entity and Brad’s entity
> (i.e. Mobivate), and remuneration agreement in the Raw Mobility. If you
> would like us to contribute on any part, please let us know.
>
>
>
> Should you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact me.
>
> Yours sincerely,
>
> *Vincent Cai CPA*  I  Associate
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
> vincent@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Sunday, 27 April 2025 8:06 PM
> *To:* Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* asaf@shamir.com.au; Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>; Vincent Cai <
> Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Everyone
>
>
>
> I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I
> would like to sign off on the
> financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.
>
>    1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of
>    Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>    2. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount
>    determined as income for Asaf)
>    - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility
>    - is that correct?
>    3. Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming
>    this is also for the software,
>    owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for
>    a developer employed
>    by Shamir Holdings?
>    4. Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS
>    messages paid for by Raw Mobility
>    and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue
>    corresponding to those messages.
>    Is this correct?
>    5. The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
>    6. Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is
>    really acting as an agent between
>    Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
>
> I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to
> understand some expenses so
> please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.
>
>
>
> Looking forward to hearing from you
>
>
>
> Kind regards
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Dear Asaf & Bradley,
>
>
>
> We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw
> Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via
> DocuSign for your review and signing.
>
>
>
> Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be
> sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these
> documents to our office.
>
>
>
> We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability
> of *$14,616.75* must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than *15 May
> 2025.*
>
>
>
> Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also
> been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.
>
>
>
> Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any
> further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.
>
>
>
> Yours sincerely,
>
>
>
> *Karen Monohan *I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
> karen@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87t1Aa4f6yBkAqcahN?h=BRGbfrz699IkJ9FisnqPlTit_nfDTp2zDBw5ooqAjsI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> *Reference Number: 780620_1*
>
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards
> Legislation
>
>
> ---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer
> ------------------
>
>
> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail.
> If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use,
> reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and
> unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender
> by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of
> the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to
> be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do
> not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this
> communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses,
> interception or interference.
>
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards
> Legislation
>
>
> ---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer
> ------------------
>
>
> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail.
> If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use,
> reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and
> unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender
> by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of
> the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to
> be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do
> not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this
> communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses,
> interception or interference.
>

================================================================================
#6  2025-05-01T09:04:00+03:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>,
 Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>,
 Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>,
 Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad,

> It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
> Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
> - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
That is incorrect. 
> Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
> owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
> by Shamir Holdings?
R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.
> Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility 
> and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
> Is this correct?
Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.
> The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it charges license fees from Raw Mobility. 
> Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
> Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?

That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in this context.


As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday. 
If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.

Asaf


> On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Everyone
> 
> I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I would like to sign off on the
> financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.
> It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
> 
> Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
> - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
> 
> Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
> owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
> by Shamir Holdings?
> 
> Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility 
> and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
> Is this correct?
> 
> The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
> 
> Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
> Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
> I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to understand some expenses so 
> please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.
> 
> Looking forward to hearing from you
> 
> Kind regards
> 
> Brad
> 
> On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> Dear Asaf & Bradley,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via DocuSign for your review and signing.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these documents to our office.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability of $14,616.75 must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than 15 May 2025.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Yours sincerely,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Karen Monohan I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> 
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
>> karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:karen@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>>  
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Reference Number: 780620_1
>> 
>> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation
>> 
>> ---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer ------------------
>> 
>> 
>> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
>>

================================================================================
#7  2025-05-01T19:11:28+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>, 
	Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Asaf and team GSCA

I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to
me that the
financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and
lack integrity.

Eli, do you agree with me?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:

> Brad,
>
>
>    1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of
>    Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>
> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount
>    determined as income for Asaf)
>    - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility
>    - is that correct?
>
> That is incorrect.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming
>    this is also for the software,
>    owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for
>    a developer employed
>    by Shamir Holdings?
>
> R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.
>
>
>    1. Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS
>    messages paid for by Raw Mobility
>    and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue
>    corresponding to those messages.
>    Is this correct?
>
> Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost
> price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.
>
>
>    1. The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
>
> Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it
> charges license fees from Raw Mobility.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is
>    really acting as an agent between
>    Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
>
> That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in
> this context.
>
>
> As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday.
> If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule
> a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.
>
> Asaf
>
>
> On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Everyone
>
> I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I
> would like to sign off on the
> financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.
>
>    1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of
>    Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>
>    2. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount
>    determined as income for Asaf)
>    - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility
>    - is that correct?
>
>    3. Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming
>    this is also for the software,
>    owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for
>    a developer employed
>    by Shamir Holdings?
>
>    4. Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS
>    messages paid for by Raw Mobility
>    and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue
>    corresponding to those messages.
>    Is this correct?
>
>    5. The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
>
>    6. Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is
>    really acting as an agent between
>    Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
>
> I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to
> understand some expenses so
> please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.
>
> Looking forward to hearing from you
>
> Kind regards
>
> Brad
>
> On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Dear Asaf & Bradley,
>>
>>
>>
>> We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via
>> DocuSign for your review and signing.
>>
>>
>>
>> Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be
>> sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these
>> documents to our office.
>>
>>
>>
>> We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability
>> of *$14,616.75* must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than *15
>> May 2025.*
>>
>>
>>
>> Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also
>> been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.
>>
>>
>>
>> Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any
>> further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.
>>
>>
>>
>> Yours sincerely,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Karen Monohan *I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
>> karen@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> *Reference Number: 780620_1*
>> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards
>> Legislation
>>
>>
>> ---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer
>> ------------------
>>
>>
>> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail.
>> If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use,
>> reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and
>> unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender
>> by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of
>> the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to
>> be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do
>> not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this
>> communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses,
>> interception or interference.
>>
>
>

================================================================================
#8  2025-05-02T06:53:42+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>,
	Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad

I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week and will advise accordingly.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144<x-apple-data-detectors://0/1>
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146<x-apple-data-detectors://1/0>
T: + 61 3 9527 5041<tel:+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297<tel:+%2061%203%209527%202297>
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>


Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:

﻿
Hi Asaf and team GSCA

I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to me that the
financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.

Eli, do you agree with me?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,


  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?

As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.

  1.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
- assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?

That is incorrect.

  1.  Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
by Shamir Holdings?

R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.

  1.  Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility
and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
Is this correct?

Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.

  1.  The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?

Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it charges license fees from Raw Mobility.

  1.  Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?

That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in this context.


As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday.
If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.

Asaf


On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:

Hi Everyone

I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I would like to sign off on the
financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.

  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?

  2.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
- assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?

  3.  Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
by Shamir Holdings?

  4.  Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility
and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
Is this correct?

  5.  The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?

  6.  Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?

I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to understand some expenses so
please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.

Looking forward to hearing from you

Kind regards

Brad

On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Dear Asaf & Bradley,

We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via DocuSign for your review and signing.

Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these documents to our office.

We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability of $14,616.75 must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than 15 May 2025.

Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.

Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.

Yours sincerely,

Karen Monohan I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:karen@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKdskbQXRfDYwwnQm?h=V-7J90Y03uZQ5136KWoLh5jU59YWtCaOBnw86WAoUu0=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>



Reference Number: 780620_1
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer ------------------

Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer ------------------

Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#9  2025-05-02T13:01:03+03:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Hi Eli, 

I’m back in Melbourne on Tuesday night, will be available from Wednesday any time.

> On 2 May 2025, at 9:53 am, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
> 
> Brad
> 
> I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week and will advise accordingly.
> 
> Regards,
>  
> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144 <x-apple-data-detectors://0/1>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146 <x-apple-data-detectors://1/0>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041 <tel:+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297 <tel:+%2061%203%209527%202297>
> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
> 
> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
> 
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation
> 
>> On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>> 
>> ﻿
>> Hi Asaf and team GSCA
>> 
>> I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to me that the
>> financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.
>> 
>> Eli, do you agree with me?
>> 
>> Thanks
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>> On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>>> Brad,
>>> 
>>>> It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>>> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
>>>> Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
>>>> - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
>>> That is incorrect. 
>>>> Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
>>>> owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
>>>> by Shamir Holdings?
>>> R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.
>>>> Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility 
>>>> and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
>>>> Is this correct?
>>> Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.
>>>> The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
>>> Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it charges license fees from Raw Mobility. 
>>>> Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
>>>> Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
>>> 
>>> That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in this context.
>>> 
>>> 
>>> As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday. 
>>> If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.
>>> 
>>> Asaf
>>> 
>>> 
>>>> On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>> 
>>>> Hi Everyone
>>>> 
>>>> I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I would like to sign off on the
>>>> financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.
>>>> It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>>>> 
>>>> Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
>>>> - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
>>>> 
>>>> Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
>>>> owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
>>>> by Shamir Holdings?
>>>> 
>>>> Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility 
>>>> and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
>>>> Is this correct?
>>>> 
>>>> The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
>>>> 
>>>> Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
>>>> Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
>>>> I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to understand some expenses so 
>>>> please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.
>>>> 
>>>> Looking forward to hearing from you
>>>> 
>>>> Kind regards
>>>> 
>>>> Brad
>>>> 
>>>> On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>>>>> Dear Asaf & Bradley,
>>>>> 
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>> We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via DocuSign for your review and signing.
>>>>> 
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>> Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these documents to our office.
>>>>> 
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>> We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability of $14,616.75 must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than 15 May 2025.
>>>>> 
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>> Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.
>>>>> 
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>> Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.
>>>>> 
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>> Yours sincerely,
>>>>> 
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>> Karen Monohan I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
>>>>> 
>>>>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>>>>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>>>> 
>>>>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>>>> 
>>>>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
>>>>> karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:karen@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKdskbQXRfDYwwnQm?h=V-7J90Y03uZQ5136KWoLh5jU59YWtCaOBnw86WAoUu0=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>>  
>>>>> 
>>>>> Reference Number: 780620_1
>>>>> 
>>>>> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation
>>>>> 
>>>>> ---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer ------------------
>>>>> 
>>>>> 
>>>>> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#10  2025-05-03T10:51:05+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Asaf

I’m travelling to Singapore on Monday night and arrive back on Friday morning.  I should be in a position to zoom/teams while I’m away.  Otherwise, we can meet on Friday (early) afternoon.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Sent: Friday, 2 May 2025 8:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli,

I’m back in Melbourne on Tuesday night, will be available from Wednesday any time.


On 2 May 2025, at 9:53 am, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:

Brad

I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week and will advise accordingly.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144<x-apple-data-detectors://0/1>
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146<x-apple-data-detectors://1/0>
T: + 61 3 9527 5041<tel:+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297<tel:+%2061%203%209527%202297>
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKe6Fo5BrZKeAXQmj?h=5uKXytmnE-jXmRL2PZPZEJdNWEzhMoZubCJqmdy5kq8=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>


Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation


On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
﻿
Hi Asaf and team GSCA

I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to me that the
financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.

Eli, do you agree with me?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,


  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.

  1.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
- assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
That is incorrect.

  1.  Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
by Shamir Holdings?
R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.


  1.  Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility
and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
Is this correct?
Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.

  1.  The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it charges license fees from Raw Mobility.

  1.  Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in this context.


As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday.
If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.

Asaf



On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:

Hi Everyone

I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I would like to sign off on the
financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.

  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
  2.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
- assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
  3.  Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
by Shamir Holdings?
  4.  Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility
and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
Is this correct?
  5.  The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
  6.  Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to understand some expenses so
please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.

Looking forward to hearing from you

Kind regards

Brad

On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Dear Asaf & Bradley,

We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via DocuSign for your review and signing.

Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these documents to our office.

We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability of $14,616.75 must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than 15 May 2025.

Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.

Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.

Yours sincerely,

Karen Monohan I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:karen@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKdskbQXRfDYwwnQm?h=V-7J90Y03uZQ5136KWoLh5jU59YWtCaOBnw86WAoUu0=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>



Reference Number: 780620_1
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer ------------------

Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#11  2025-05-03T14:35:16+03:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Eli,

Can you explain to me why Brad believes the reports do not reflect Raw Mobility’s position? 
Safe flight to Singapore, let me know if you’d like to have a call while you’re away. Otherwise - Friday afternoon works for me.

Have a nice weekend,
Asaf

> On 3 May 2025, at 1:51 pm, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
> 
> Asaf
>  
> I’m travelling to Singapore on Monday night and arrive back on Friday morning.  I should be in a position to zoom/teams while I’m away.  Otherwise, we can meet on Friday (early) afternoon.
>  
> Regards,
>  
> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>  
> From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> Sent: Friday, 2 May 2025 8:01 PM
> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>  
> Hi Eli, 
>  
> I’m back in Melbourne on Tuesday night, will be available from Wednesday any time.
> 
> 
> On 2 May 2025, at 9:53 am, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>  
> Brad 
>  
> I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week and will advise accordingly.
>  
> Regards,
>  
> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144 <x-apple-data-detectors://0/1>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146 <x-apple-data-detectors://1/0>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041 <tel:+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297 <tel:+%2061%203%209527%202297>
> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKe6Fo5BrZKeAXQmj?h=5uKXytmnE-jXmRL2PZPZEJdNWEzhMoZubCJqmdy5kq8=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>  
> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
> 
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation
> 
> 
> On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
> 
> ﻿
> Hi Asaf and team GSCA 
>  
> I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to me that the
> financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.
> 
> Eli, do you agree with me?
>  
> Thanks
>  
> Brad
>  
> On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
> Brad, 
>  
> It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
> Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
> - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
> That is incorrect. 
> Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
> owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
> by Shamir Holdings?
> R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.
> 
> Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility 
> and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
> Is this correct?
> Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.
> The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
> Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it charges license fees from Raw Mobility. 
> Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
> Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
> That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in this context.
>  
>  
> As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday. 
> If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.
>  
> Asaf
>  
> 
> 
> On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>  
> Hi Everyone 
>  
> I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I would like to sign off on the
> financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.
> It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
> Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
> - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
> Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
> owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
> by Shamir Holdings?
> Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility 
> and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
> Is this correct?
> The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
> Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
> Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
> I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to understand some expenses so 
> please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.
>  
> Looking forward to hearing from you
>  
> Kind regards
>  
> Brad
>  
> On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
> Dear Asaf & Bradley,
>  
> We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via DocuSign for your review and signing.
>  
> Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these documents to our office.
>  
> We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability of $14,616.75 must be paid directly to the ATO by no later than 15 May 2025.
>  
> Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.
>  
> Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.
>  
> Yours sincerely,
>  
> Karen Monohan I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
> karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:karen@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKdskbQXRfDYwwnQm?h=V-7J90Y03uZQ5136KWoLh5jU59YWtCaOBnw86WAoUu0=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>  
>  
>  
> R

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#12  2025-05-03T12:05:34+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Asaf

I think we need to work through each of his questions, one by one.

His main issues are as following:

  1.  RM is paying SDT a licence fee.  What is this licence fee for?
  2.  Who owns the IP which Brad is concerned about?

If you are in a position to do so, I can zoom tomorrow afternoon and we can work this out together.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Sent: Saturday, 3 May 2025 9:35 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

Can you explain to me why Brad believes the reports do not reflect Raw Mobility’s position?
Safe flight to Singapore, let me know if you’d like to have a call while you’re away. Otherwise - Friday afternoon works for me.

Have a nice weekend,
Asaf


On 3 May 2025, at 1:51 pm, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:

Asaf

I’m travelling to Singapore on Monday night and arrive back on Friday morning.  I should be in a position to zoom/teams while I’m away.  Otherwise, we can meet on Friday (early) afternoon.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKeSTVBoC4uy7CzR5?h=thb6cbJPpwpVJ2PaMaT2f-feSis0vIEJ9CB_YgjKEFs=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Sent: Friday, 2 May 2025 8:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli,

I’m back in Melbourne on Tuesday night, will be available from Wednesday any time.



On 2 May 2025, at 9:53 am, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:

Brad

I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week and will advise accordingly.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144<x-apple-data-detectors://0/1>
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146<x-apple-data-detectors://1/0>
T: + 61 3 9527 5041<tel:+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297<tel:+%2061%203%209527%202297>
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKe6Fo5BrZKeAXQmj?h=5uKXytmnE-jXmRL2PZPZEJdNWEzhMoZubCJqmdy5kq8=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>


Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation



On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
﻿
Hi Asaf and team GSCA

I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to me that the
financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.

Eli, do you agree with me?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,


  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.

  1.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
- assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
That is incorrect.

  1.  Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
by Shamir Holdings?
R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.



  1.  Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility
and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
Is this correct?
Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.

  1.  The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it charges license fees from Raw Mobility.

  1.  Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in this context.


As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday.
If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.

Asaf




On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:

Hi Everyone

I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I would like to sign off on the
financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.

  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
  2.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
- assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
  3.  Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
by Shamir Holdings?
  4.  Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility
and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
Is this correct?
  5.  The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
  6.  Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to understand some expenses so
please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.

Looking forward to hearing from you

Kind regards

Brad

On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Dear Asaf & Bradley,

We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via DocuSign for your review and signing.

Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these documents to our office.

We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax liability of 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#13  2025-05-03T15:20:10+03:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

RM is paying SDT a licence fee.  What is this licence fee for?


As I mentioned in my emails (multiple times), it is for a software called
OpenModel.

https://openmodel.shamir.com.au

That software is NOT the software Raw Mobility develops and resells.

Who owns the IP which Brad is concerned about?


My understanding is that Brad is concerned about software called Blender,
hosted here:

https://apps.rawmobility.com/bulksms/

As far as i can tell, the IP for that software is owned by Raw Mobility.

If you are in a position to do so, I can zoom tomorrow afternoon and we can
> work this out together.


I'm currently in Greece, so taking into account timezones - i'm
available from 7am-10am, and later from around 2pm.
In Melbourne time, i'll be available from 14:00 - 17:00.

Let me know what works for you and i'll adjust accordingly as I want to get
this resolved asap.

*Location*

*Local Time*

*Time Zone*

*UTC Offset*

*Athens (Greece)*

Sunday, 4 May 2025, 07:00:00

EEST

UTC+3 hours

*Melbourne (Australia – Victoria)*

Sunday, 4 May 2025, 14:00:00

AEST

UTC+10 hours


On Sat, May 3, 2025 at 3:05 PM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Asaf
>
>
>
> I think we need to work through each of his questions, one by one.
>
>
>
> His main issues are as following:
>
>    1. RM is paying SDT a licence fee.  What is this licence fee for?
>    2. Who owns the IP which Brad is concerned about?
>
>
>
> If you are in a position to do so, I can zoom tomorrow afternoon and we
> can work this out together.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> *Sent:* Saturday, 3 May 2025 9:35 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Eli,
>
>
>
> Can you explain to me why Brad believes the reports do not reflect Raw
> Mobility’s position?
>
> Safe flight to Singapore, let me know if you’d like to have a call while
> you’re away. Otherwise - Friday afternoon works for me.
>
>
>
> Have a nice weekend,
>
> Asaf
>
>
>
> On 3 May 2025, at 1:51 pm, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>
>
> Asaf
>
>
>
> I’m travelling to Singapore on Monday night and arrive back on Friday
> morning.  I should be in a position to zoom/teams while I’m away.
> Otherwise, we can meet on Friday (early) afternoon.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKeSTVBoC4uy7CzR5?h=thb6cbJPpwpVJ2PaMaT2f-feSis0vIEJ9CB_YgjKEFs=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> *Sent:* Friday, 2 May 2025 8:01 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli,
>
>
>
> I’m back in Melbourne on Tuesday night, will be available from Wednesday
> any time.
>
>
>
>
> On 2 May 2025, at 9:53 am, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week
> and will advise accordingly.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041 <+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
> <+%2061%203%209527%202297>
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKe6Fo5BrZKeAXQmj?h=5uKXytmnE-jXmRL2PZPZEJdNWEzhMoZubCJqmdy5kq8=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail.
> If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use,
> reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and
> unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender
> by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of
> the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to
> be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do
> not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this
> communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses,
> interception or interference.
>
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards
> Legislation
>
>
>
>
> On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> ﻿
>
> Hi Asaf and team GSCA
>
>
>
> I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to
> me that the
> financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and
> lack integrity.
>
>
> Eli, do you agree with me?
>
>
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad,
>
>
>
>
>    1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of
>    Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>
> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount
>    determined as income for Asaf)
>    - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility
>    - is that correct?
>
> That is incorrect.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming
>    this is also for the software,
>    owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for
>    a developer employed
>    by Shamir Holdings?
>
> R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.
>
>
>
>    1. Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS
>    messages paid for by Raw Mobility
>    and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue
>    corresponding to those messages.
>    Is this correct?
>
> Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost
> price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.
>
>
>    1. The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
>
> Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it
> charges license fees from Raw Mobility.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is
>    really acting as an agent between
>    Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
>
> That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in
> this context.
>
>
>
>
>
> As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday.
>
> If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule
> a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.
>
>
>
> Asaf
>
>
>
>
>
>
> On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
>
>
> Hi Everyone
>
>
>
> I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I
> would like to sign off on the
> financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.
>
>    1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of
>    Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>    2. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a Lice

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#14  2025-05-03T12:28:22+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Asaf

Let’s please zoom at 16:00 tomorrow.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Sent: Saturday, 3 May 2025 10:20 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

RM is paying SDT a licence fee.  What is this licence fee for?

As I mentioned in my emails (multiple times), it is for a software called OpenModel.

https://openmodel.shamir.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVcGENVTVTK8J6fK5hu?h=6Nm6x41t58ltaDfE79eErKl7xoHmByHWefIbC2IGyhE=&u=https://openmodel.shamir.com.au>

That software is NOT the software Raw Mobility develops and resells.

Who owns the IP which Brad is concerned about?

My understanding is that Brad is concerned about software called Blender, hosted here:

https://apps.rawmobility.com/bulksms/<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVXS362qoruBUB7kgZH?h=6cVNGJb0RyU7Cj7ckWC_DDfBVDAaM9KVPqFwXOyDrIE=&u=https://apps.rawmobility.com/bulksms/>

As far as i can tell, the IP for that software is owned by Raw Mobility.

If you are in a position to do so, I can zoom tomorrow afternoon and we can work this out together.

I'm currently in Greece, so taking into account timezones - i'm available from 7am-10am, and later from around 2pm.
In Melbourne time, i'll be available from 14:00 - 17:00.

Let me know what works for you and i'll adjust accordingly as I want to get this resolved asap.


Location

Local Time

Time Zone

UTC Offset

Athens (Greece)

Sunday, 4 May 2025, 07:00:00

EEST

UTC+3 hours

Melbourne (Australia – Victoria)

Sunday, 4 May 2025, 14:00:00

AEST

UTC+10 hours


On Sat, May 3, 2025 at 3:05 PM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Asaf

I think we need to work through each of his questions, one by one.

His main issues are as following:

  1.  RM is paying SDT a licence fee.  What is this licence fee for?
  2.  Who owns the IP which Brad is concerned about?

If you are in a position to do so, I can zoom tomorrow afternoon and we can work this out together.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSbqoaE8GVEeFaCHQf?h=5KX75R7nzNk4qjDL537GxkWfItZ_KC9wfOvsRpLZSxY=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Sent: Saturday, 3 May 2025 9:35 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

Can you explain to me why Brad believes the reports do not reflect Raw Mobility’s position?
Safe flight to Singapore, let me know if you’d like to have a call while you’re away. Otherwise - Friday afternoon works for me.

Have a nice weekend,
Asaf

On 3 May 2025, at 1:51 pm, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:

Asaf

I’m travelling to Singapore on Monday night and arrive back on Friday morning.  I should be in a position to zoom/teams while I’m away.  Otherwise, we can meet on Friday (early) afternoon.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKeSTVBoC4uy7CzR5?h=thb6cbJPpwpVJ2PaMaT2f-feSis0vIEJ9CB_YgjKEFs=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Sent: Friday, 2 May 2025 8:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli,

I’m back in Melbourne on Tuesday night, will be available from Wednesday any time.


On 2 May 2025, at 9:53 am, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:

Brad

I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week and will advise accordingly.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041<tel:+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297<tel:+%2061%203%209527%202297>
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKe6Fo5BrZKeAXQmj?h=5uKXytmnE-jXmRL2PZPZEJdNWEzhMoZubCJqmdy5kq8=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>


Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation


On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
﻿
Hi Asaf and team GSCA

I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to me that the
financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.

Eli, do you agree with me?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,


  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.

  1.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
- assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
That is incorrect.

  1.  Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
by Shamir Holdings?
R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.


  1.  Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility
and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
Is this correct?
Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.

  1.  The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it charges license fees from Raw Mobility.

  1.  Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in this context.


As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday.

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#15  2025-05-03T15:37:25+03:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

If it's just the two of us, Whatsapp would be easier for me.
Zoom will be fine too if it's a requirement on your end.

I've sent you an invite, but just in case here are the details:

Join Zoom Meeting
https://us04web.zoom.us/j/79014096912?pwd=I4DJK10JRxN53tlS9mZbab62iHQMJH.1

Meeting ID: 790 1409 6912
Passcode: 2hjKh3

On Sat, May 3, 2025 at 3:28 PM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Asaf
>
>
>
> Let’s please zoom at 16:00 tomorrow.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> *Sent:* Saturday, 3 May 2025 10:20 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Eli,
>
>
>
> RM is paying SDT a licence fee.  What is this licence fee for?
>
>
>
> As I mentioned in my emails (multiple times), it is for a software called
> OpenModel.
>
>
>
> https://openmodel.shamir.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVcGENVTVTK8J6fK5hu?h=6Nm6x41t58ltaDfE79eErKl7xoHmByHWefIbC2IGyhE=&u=https://openmodel.shamir.com.au>
>
>
>
> That software is NOT the software Raw Mobility develops and resells.
>
>
>
> Who owns the IP which Brad is concerned about?
>
>
>
> My understanding is that Brad is concerned about software called Blender,
> hosted here:
>
>
>
> https://apps.rawmobility.com/bulksms/
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVXS362qoruBUB7kgZH?h=6cVNGJb0RyU7Cj7ckWC_DDfBVDAaM9KVPqFwXOyDrIE=&u=https://apps.rawmobility.com/bulksms/>
>
>
>
> As far as i can tell, the IP for that software is owned by Raw Mobility.
>
>
>
> If you are in a position to do so, I can zoom tomorrow afternoon and we
> can work this out together.
>
>
>
> I'm currently in Greece, so taking into account timezones - i'm
> available from 7am-10am, and later from around 2pm.
>
> In Melbourne time, i'll be available from 14:00 - 17:00.
>
>
>
> Let me know what works for you and i'll adjust accordingly as I want to
> get this resolved asap.
>
>
>
> *Location*
>
> *Local Time*
>
> *Time Zone*
>
> *UTC Offset*
>
> *Athens (Greece)*
>
> Sunday, 4 May 2025, 07:00:00
>
> EEST
>
> UTC+3 hours
>
> *Melbourne (Australia – Victoria)*
>
> Sunday, 4 May 2025, 14:00:00
>
> AEST
>
> UTC+10 hours
>
>
>
>
>
> On Sat, May 3, 2025 at 3:05 PM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Asaf
>
>
>
> I think we need to work through each of his questions, one by one.
>
>
>
> His main issues are as following:
>
>    1. RM is paying SDT a licence fee.  What is this licence fee for?
>    2. Who owns the IP which Brad is concerned about?
>
>
>
> If you are in a position to do so, I can zoom tomorrow afternoon and we
> can work this out together.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSbqoaE8GVEeFaCHQf?h=5KX75R7nzNk4qjDL537GxkWfItZ_KC9wfOvsRpLZSxY=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> *Sent:* Saturday, 3 May 2025 9:35 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Eli,
>
>
>
> Can you explain to me why Brad believes the reports do not reflect Raw
> Mobility’s position?
>
> Safe flight to Singapore, let me know if you’d like to have a call while
> you’re away. Otherwise - Friday afternoon works for me.
>
>
>
> Have a nice weekend,
>
> Asaf
>
>
>
> On 3 May 2025, at 1:51 pm, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>
>
> Asaf
>
>
>
> I’m travelling to Singapore on Monday night and arrive back on Friday
> morning.  I should be in a position to zoom/teams while I’m away.
> Otherwise, we can meet on Friday (early) afternoon.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKeSTVBoC4uy7CzR5?h=thb6cbJPpwpVJ2PaMaT2f-feSis0vIEJ9CB_YgjKEFs=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> *Sent:* Friday, 2 May 2025 8:01 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli,
>
>
>
> I’m back in Melbourne on Tuesday night, will be available from Wednesday
> any time.
>
>
>
> On 2 May 2025, at 9:53 am, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week
> and will advise accordingly.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041 <+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
> <+%2061%203%209527%202297>
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKe6Fo5BrZKeAXQmj?h=5uKXytmnE-jXmRL2PZPZEJdNWEzhMoZubCJqmdy5kq8=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail.
> If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use,
> reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and
> unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender
> by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of
> the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to
> be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do
> not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this
> communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses,
> interception or interference.
>
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards
> Legislation
>
>
>
> On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> ﻿
>
> Hi Asaf and team GSCA
>
>
>
> I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to
> me that the
> financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and
> lack integrity.
>
>
> Eli, do you agree with me?
>
>
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad,
>
>
>
>
>    1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of
>    Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>
> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount
>    determined as income for Asaf)
>    - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility
>    - is that correct?
>
> That is incorrect.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming
>    this is also for the software,
>    owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for
>    a developer employed
>    by Shamir Holdings?
>

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#16  2025-05-03T12:40:10+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Whatsapp is fine.  pls send me a calendar invite

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Sent: Saturday, 3 May 2025 10:37 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

If it's just the two of us, Whatsapp would be easier for me.
Zoom will be fine too if it's a requirement on your end.

I've sent you an invite, but just in case here are the details:

Join Zoom Meeting
https://us04web.zoom.us/j/79014096912?pwd=I4DJK10JRxN53tlS9mZbab62iHQMJH.1<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrr9qjjYHLh4x7Hgpsg?h=bCxyAnqF_8lY84v4Je-c9Gm6VTMKuktCpYSnc9v6GLE=&u=https://us04web.zoom.us/j/79014096912?pwd%3DI4DJK10JRxN53tlS9mZbab62iHQMJH.1>

Meeting ID: 790 1409 6912
Passcode: 2hjKh3

On Sat, May 3, 2025 at 3:28 PM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Asaf

Let’s please zoom at 16:00 tomorrow.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKeTGvbkH88Bk8Rj4?h=CPd9xR7GGtADD_mkyP2YF2bp4l1v9LAGl60EKprmuwo=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Sent: Saturday, 3 May 2025 10:20 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

RM is paying SDT a licence fee.  What is this licence fee for?

As I mentioned in my emails (multiple times), it is for a software called OpenModel.

https://openmodel.shamir.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVcGENVTVTK8J6fK5hu?h=6Nm6x41t58ltaDfE79eErKl7xoHmByHWefIbC2IGyhE=&u=https://openmodel.shamir.com.au>

That software is NOT the software Raw Mobility develops and resells.

Who owns the IP which Brad is concerned about?

My understanding is that Brad is concerned about software called Blender, hosted here:

https://apps.rawmobility.com/bulksms/<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVXS362qoruBUB7kgZH?h=6cVNGJb0RyU7Cj7ckWC_DDfBVDAaM9KVPqFwXOyDrIE=&u=https://apps.rawmobility.com/bulksms/>

As far as i can tell, the IP for that software is owned by Raw Mobility.

If you are in a position to do so, I can zoom tomorrow afternoon and we can work this out together.

I'm currently in Greece, so taking into account timezones - i'm available from 7am-10am, and later from around 2pm.
In Melbourne time, i'll be available from 14:00 - 17:00.

Let me know what works for you and i'll adjust accordingly as I want to get this resolved asap.


Location

Local Time

Time Zone

UTC Offset

Athens (Greece)

Sunday, 4 May 2025, 07:00:00

EEST

UTC+3 hours

Melbourne (Australia – Victoria)

Sunday, 4 May 2025, 14:00:00

AEST

UTC+10 hours


On Sat, May 3, 2025 at 3:05 PM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Asaf

I think we need to work through each of his questions, one by one.

His main issues are as following:

  1.  RM is paying SDT a licence fee.  What is this licence fee for?
  2.  Who owns the IP which Brad is concerned about?

If you are in a position to do so, I can zoom tomorrow afternoon and we can work this out together.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSbqoaE8GVEeFaCHQf?h=5KX75R7nzNk4qjDL537GxkWfItZ_KC9wfOvsRpLZSxY=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Sent: Saturday, 3 May 2025 9:35 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

Can you explain to me why Brad believes the reports do not reflect Raw Mobility’s position?
Safe flight to Singapore, let me know if you’d like to have a call while you’re away. Otherwise - Friday afternoon works for me.

Have a nice weekend,
Asaf

On 3 May 2025, at 1:51 pm, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:

Asaf

I’m travelling to Singapore on Monday night and arrive back on Friday morning.  I should be in a position to zoom/teams while I’m away.  Otherwise, we can meet on Friday (early) afternoon.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKeSTVBoC4uy7CzR5?h=thb6cbJPpwpVJ2PaMaT2f-feSis0vIEJ9CB_YgjKEFs=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Sent: Friday, 2 May 2025 8:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli,

I’m back in Melbourne on Tuesday night, will be available from Wednesday any time.

On 2 May 2025, at 9:53 am, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:

Brad

I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week and will advise accordingly.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041<tel:+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297<tel:+%2061%203%209527%202297>
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKe6Fo5BrZKeAXQmj?h=5uKXytmnE-jXmRL2PZPZEJdNWEzhMoZubCJqmdy5kq8=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>


Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
﻿
Hi Asaf and team GSCA

I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to me that the
financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.

Eli, do you agree with me?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,


  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#17  2025-05-03T19:56:12+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>, 
	Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

Thank you very much.

If you wish to discuss anything, please let me know and we can arrange a
time to speak.

Kind regards

Brad



On Fri, May 2, 2025 at 7:53 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Brad
>
> I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week
> and will advise accordingly.
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041 <+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
> <+%2061%203%209527%202297>
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail.
> If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use,
> reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and
> unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender
> by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of
> the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to
> be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do
> not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this
> communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses,
> interception or interference.
>
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards
> Legislation
>
> On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> ﻿
> Hi Asaf and team GSCA
>
> I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to
> me that the
> financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and
> lack integrity.
>
> Eli, do you agree with me?
>
> Thanks
>
> Brad
>
> On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Brad,
>>
>>
>>    1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of
>>    Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>>
>> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
>> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
>>
>>
>>    1. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount
>>    determined as income for Asaf)
>>    - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility
>>    - is that correct?
>>
>> That is incorrect.
>>
>>
>>    1. Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming
>>    this is also for the software,
>>    owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment
>>    for a developer employed
>>    by Shamir Holdings?
>>
>> R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw
>> Mobility.
>>
>>
>>    1. Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS
>>    messages paid for by Raw Mobility
>>    and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue
>>    corresponding to those messages.
>>    Is this correct?
>>
>> Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost
>> price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.
>>
>>
>>    1. The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
>>
>> Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it
>> charges license fees from Raw Mobility.
>>
>>
>>    1. Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is
>>    really acting as an agent between
>>    Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
>>
>> That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in
>> this context.
>>
>>
>> As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday.
>> If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule
>> a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.
>>
>> Asaf
>>
>>
>> On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Everyone
>>
>> I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as
>> I would like to sign off on the
>> financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.
>>
>>    1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of
>>    Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>>
>>    2. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount
>>    determined as income for Asaf)
>>    - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility
>>    - is that correct?
>>
>>    3. Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming
>>    this is also for the software,
>>    owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment
>>    for a developer employed
>>    by Shamir Holdings?
>>
>>    4. Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS
>>    messages paid for by Raw Mobility
>>    and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue
>>    corresponding to those messages.
>>    Is this correct?
>>
>>    5. The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
>>
>>    6. Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is
>>    really acting as an agent between
>>    Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
>>
>> I will also want to see some invoices to check for completeness and to
>> understand some expenses so
>> please let me know if the above is correct and we can go from there.
>>
>> Looking forward to hearing from you
>>
>> Kind regards
>>
>> Brad
>>
>> On Thu, Apr 3, 2025 at 2:57 AM Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>>
>>> Dear Asaf & Bradley,
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> We have now sent the Income Tax Return and Financial Report for Raw
>>> Mobility Pty Ltd with respect to the year ended 30 June 2024 to you via
>>> DocuSign for your review and signing.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Documents that require ‘pen to paper’ signatures that were unable to be
>>> sent via DocuSign are attached. Would you please sign and return these
>>> documents to our office.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> We also take this opportunity to advise you that the income tax
>>> liability of *$14,616.75* must be paid directly to the ATO by no later
>>> than *15 May 2025.*
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Payment options can be found on the attached Payment Slip that has also
>>> been sent to you via DocuSign with the Income Tax Return.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Should you have any queries in relation to the above or require any
>>> further information, please feel free to contact me at any time.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Yours sincerely,
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> *Karen Monohan *I  Personal Assistant to Eli Lebovits
>>>
>>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>>
>>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>>
>>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
>>> karen@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKdskbQXRfDYwwnQm?h=V-7J90Y03uZQ5136KWoLh5jU59YWtCaOBnw86WAoUu0=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> *Reference Number: 780620_1*
>>> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards
>>> Legislation
>>>
>>>
>>> ---------------------------Email Confidentiality Disclaimer
>>> ------------------
>>>
>>>
>>> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail.
>>> If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use,
>>> reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and
>>> unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender
>>> by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of
>>> the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to
>>> be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do
>>> not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this
>>> communication has been

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#18  2025-05-09T01:16:52+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>,
	Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Hi Brad

I have reviewed Asaf’s responses and understand as follows:

  1.  Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
  2.  Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
  3.  Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @ cost.
  4.  Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate line item for clarity.
  5.  Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code associated with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or patent registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given the email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in this regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a referral.
  6.  Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all been expensed by Raw Mobility.
  7.  Raw Mobility’s largest customer is Mobivate.  From review of the Sassu file, there is another small customer.

Separately, I note the following:

  1.  I understand that your preference is for Raw Mobility to employee the staff member presently employed by Shamir Holdings.  This is a commercial decision for you and Asaf to resolve.
  2.  I understand that you believe that R&D should be capitalised (and amortised) rather than expensed.  I note that the accounting statements prepared are special purpose financial statements and in this regard, they have not been prepared in accordance with AASB 138 ‘Intangible Assets’ which may require a portion to be capitalised.
  3.  Raw Mobility is paying hosting fees, principally to AWS.  I understand that these fees are paid for hosting the Blender Software.  I understand that Raw Mobility does not pay hosting fees for IP owned by Shamir Holdings.
  4.  Raw Mobility pays Twilio on a monthly basis.  Historically, Shamir Holdings has reduced its licence fees invoiced to Raw Mobility as payment for sms’ acquired by Shamir Holdings.  Ideally, to promote transparency, Shamir Holdings should acquire sms’ directly from Twilio.

On this basis, it is not clear to me as to why you are of the view that the financial statements do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.  If you still feel that this is in fact the case, I would encourage you and Asaf to have the a/cs prepared by an independent third party and agree on the accounting policies by which such third party should draft the accounts.

Should you have any queries in relation to the above, please feel free to contact me.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Sent: Sunday, 4 May 2025 4:56 AM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

Thank you very much.

If you wish to discuss anything, please let me know and we can arrange a time to speak.

Kind regards

Brad



On Fri, May 2, 2025 at 7:53 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad

I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week and will advise accordingly.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041<tel:+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297<tel:+%2061%203%209527%202297>
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87t3FKHrH8Vq4ioNnw?h=twa87z9wrXDwjWfJoCUaBQ9jegDabiJ_a9NKihreNtg=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>


Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation


On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
﻿
Hi Asaf and team GSCA

I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to me that the
financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.

Eli, do you agree with me?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,


  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.

  1.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
- assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
That is incorrect.

  1.  Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
by Shamir Holdings?
R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.


  1.  Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS messages paid for by Raw Mobility
and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue corresponding to those messages.
Is this correct?
Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.

  1.  The owner of the code is Shamir Holdings - is that correct?
Shamir holdings is the owner of Open Model, the software for which it charges license fees from Raw Mobility.

  1.  Raw Mobility is a company that has 1 customer, Mobivate and is really acting as an agent between
Mobivate and Shamir Holdings - please confirm?
That is incorrect, and I am not sure what the term ‘agent’ refers to in this context.


As you are aware, I’m currently on holiday.
If there are any matters requiring further clarification, please schedule a Teams meeting for after my return and provide a detailed agenda.

Asaf



On 27 Apr 2025, at 1:06 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:

Hi Everyone

I hope all is well. I have gone through the bank statements in detail as I would like to sign off on the
financial statements but for clarity, I have a couple of questions.

  1.  It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
  2.  Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a Lic

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#19  2025-05-09T08:25:20+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>, 
	Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well. Thank you very much for your detailed response. Much
appreciated.

Asaf, are you 100% in agreement with everything Eli has stated?

Thanks

Brad


On Fri, 9 May 2025 at 02:16, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Hi Brad
>
>
>
> I have reviewed Asaf’s responses and understand as follows:
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>    2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>    software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I
>    understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate
>    and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>    3. Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model
>    Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @
>    cost.
>    4. Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff
>    member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw
>    Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been
>    recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can
>    certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate
>    line item for clarity.
>    5. Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code
>    associated with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or
>    patent registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given
>    the email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in
>    this regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a
>    referral.
>    6. Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all
>    been expensed by Raw Mobility.
>    7. Raw Mobility’s largest customer is Mobivate.  From review of the
>    Sassu file, there is another small customer.
>
>
>
> Separately, I note the following:
>
>    1. I understand that your preference is for Raw Mobility to employee
>    the staff member presently employed by Shamir Holdings.  This is a
>    commercial decision for you and Asaf to resolve.
>    2. I understand that you believe that R&D should be capitalised (and
>    amortised) rather than expensed.  I note that the accounting statements
>    prepared are special purpose financial statements and in this regard, they
>    have not been prepared in accordance with AASB 138 ‘Intangible Assets’
>    which may require a portion to be capitalised.
>    3. Raw Mobility is paying hosting fees, principally to AWS.  I
>    understand that these fees are paid for hosting the Blender Software.  I
>    understand that Raw Mobility does not pay hosting fees for IP owned by
>    Shamir Holdings.
>    4. Raw Mobility pays Twilio on a monthly basis.  Historically, Shamir
>    Holdings has reduced its licence fees invoiced to Raw Mobility as payment
>    for sms’ acquired by Shamir Holdings.  Ideally, to promote transparency,
>    Shamir Holdings should acquire sms’ directly from Twilio.
>
>
>
> On this basis, it is not clear to me as to why you are of the view that
> the financial statements do not reflect the true position of the company
> and lack integrity.  If you still feel that this is in fact the case, I
> would encourage you and Asaf to have the a/cs prepared by an independent
> third party and agree on the accounting policies by which such third party
> should draft the accounts.
>
>
>
> Should you have any queries in relation to the above, please feel free to
> contact me.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Sunday, 4 May 2025 4:56 AM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>;
> Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> Thank you very much.
>
>
>
> If you wish to discuss anything, please let me know and we can arrange a
> time to speak.
>
>
>
> Kind regards
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> On Fri, May 2, 2025 at 7:53 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week
> and will advise accordingly.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041 <+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297
> <+%2061%203%209527%202297>
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87t3FKHrH8Vq4ioNnw?h=twa87z9wrXDwjWfJoCUaBQ9jegDabiJ_a9NKihreNtg=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail.
> If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use,
> reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and
> unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender
> by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of
> the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to
> be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do
> not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this
> communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses,
> interception or interference.
>
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards
> Legislation
>
>
>
> On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> ﻿
>
> Hi Asaf and team GSCA
>
>
>
> I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to
> me that the
> financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and
> lack integrity.
>
>
> Eli, do you agree with me?
>
>
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad,
>
>
>
>
>    1. It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of
>    Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>
> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount
>    determined as income for Asaf)
>    - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility
>    - is that correct?
>
> That is incorrect.
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming
>    this is also for the software,
>    owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for
>    a developer employed
>    by Shamir Holdings?
>
> R&D fees are paid for contractor to work on software owned by Raw Mobility.
>
>
>    1. Shamir Holdings is reducing its license fee for the cost of SMS
>    messages paid for by Raw Mobility
>    and Shamir Holdings is invoicing its customer for the revenue
>    corresponding to those messages.
>    Is this correct?
>
> Per our agreement, I purchase some messages from Raw Mobility at cost
> price and deduct those amounts from the monthly invoice.
>
>
>    1. The owner of the code is Shamir Holdi

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#20  2025-05-09T19:25:11+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>,
 Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>,
 Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>,
 Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad,

I see no factual errors in Eli’s email.

>  Ideally, to promote transparency, Shamir Holdings should acquire sms’ directly from Twilio.


I have already made the necessary changes so those expenses are not charged to Raw Mobility.

> On 9 May 2025, at 5:25 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Eli
> 
> I hope you are well. Thank you very much for your detailed response. Much appreciated.
> 
> Asaf, are you 100% in agreement with everything Eli has stated?
> 
> Thanks
> 
> Brad
> 
> 
> On Fri, 9 May 2025 at 02:16, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> Hi Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I have reviewed Asaf’s responses and understand as follows:
>> 
>> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>> Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>> Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @ cost.
>> Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate line item for clarity. 
>> Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code associated with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or patent registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given the email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in this regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a referral. 
>> Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all been expensed by Raw Mobility.
>> Raw Mobility’s largest customer is Mobivate.  From review of the Sassu file, there is another small customer.
>>  
>> 
>> Separately, I note the following:
>> 
>> I understand that your preference is for Raw Mobility to employee the staff member presently employed by Shamir Holdings.  This is a commercial decision for you and Asaf to resolve.
>> I understand that you believe that R&D should be capitalised (and amortised) rather than expensed.  I note that the accounting statements prepared are special purpose financial statements and in this regard, they have not been prepared in accordance with AASB 138 ‘Intangible Assets’ which may require a portion to be capitalised.
>> Raw Mobility is paying hosting fees, principally to AWS.  I understand that these fees are paid for hosting the Blender Software.  I understand that Raw Mobility does not pay hosting fees for IP owned by Shamir Holdings.
>> Raw Mobility pays Twilio on a monthly basis.  Historically, Shamir Holdings has reduced its licence fees invoiced to Raw Mobility as payment for sms’ acquired by Shamir Holdings.  Ideally, to promote transparency, Shamir Holdings should acquire sms’ directly from Twilio.
>>  
>> 
>> On this basis, it is not clear to me as to why you are of the view that the financial statements do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.  If you still feel that this is in fact the case, I would encourage you and Asaf to have the a/cs prepared by an independent third party and agree on the accounting policies by which such third party should draft the accounts.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Should you have any queries in relation to the above, please feel free to contact me.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Regards,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144 <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>> Sent: Sunday, 4 May 2025 4:56 AM
>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au <mailto:Alia@gsca.com.au>>
>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Hi Eli
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Thank you very much. 
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> If you wish to discuss anything, please let me know and we can arrange a time to speak. 
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Kind regards
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>>  
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> On Fri, May 2, 2025 at 7:53 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I will be in a position to review and consider Asaf’s responses next week and will advise accordingly.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Regards,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144 <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041 <tel:+%2061%203%209527%205041>  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297 <tel:+%2061%203%209527%202297>
>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87t3FKHrH8Vq4ioNnw?h=twa87z9wrXDwjWfJoCUaBQ9jegDabiJ_a9NKihreNtg=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>> Privileged and confidential information may be contained in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, any use, reliance upon it, disclosure or copying of this email is prohibited and unlawful. Please delete and destroy all copies and kindly notify the sender by return e-mail. Any views expressed in this communication are those of the individual sender except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd. Except as required at law, we do not represent, warrant and/or guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained or that it is free of errors, viruses, interception or interference.
>> 
>> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> On 2 May 2025, at 4:11 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>> 
>> ﻿
>> 
>> Hi Asaf and team GSCA
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I confirm receipt of your explanation to my questions. It is very clear to me that the
>> financial statement do not reflect the true position of the company and lack integrity.
>> 
>> 
>> Eli, do you agree with me?
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Thanks
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> On Thu, May 1, 2025 at 7:04 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> 
>> Brad,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> It appears to me that Raw Mobility is set up as a customer of Shamir Holdings. Is that correct?
>> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
>> 
>> Raw Mobility is paying Shamir Holdings a License Fee (the amount determined as income for Asaf)
>> - assuming that is for the use of the software, owned by Raw Mobility - is that correct?
>> That is incorrect. 
>> 
>> Raw Mobility is also paying Shamir Holdings a R&D fee - assuming this is also for the software,
>> owned by Shamir Holdings but the amount corresponds to the payment for a developer employed
>> by Shamir Holdin

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#21  2025-05-11T12:37:46+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>, Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>, 
	Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>, Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)

Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in *RED* below.


   1. Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
   Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me.
   Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited?

   2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
   software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I
   understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate
   and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
   Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement, which
   completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf. Having
   said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to
   $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?

   3. Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model
   Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @
   cost.
   Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer Shamir
   Holdings?
   Surely arms length transactions (usually documented in the rules of
   transfer pricing) are essential when 2 Australian companies have the
   identical Director/UBO's?
   Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me.
   Is it fair to say that Shamir Holdings has one or more customers that
   utilise and pay Shamir Holdings for the delivery of bulk SMS messages?

   4. Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff
   member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw
   Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been
   recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can
   certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate
   line item for clarity.
   Eli, are you happy with the Man Accs / F/S's calling it an Open Model
   License Fee when in fact a part of it has nothing to do with a License of
   software but entirely the cost of an employee of another company?
   Is there an Agreement between RM and Shamir relating to this employee
   cost? If so, please send it to me.
   In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
   ($145,390 ex GST)?

   5. Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code associated
   with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or patent
   registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given the
   email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in this
   regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a referral.
   Thanks Eli - definitely something worth considering, however I think it
   may be very difficult to do.

   6. Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all
   been expensed by Raw Mobility.
   Please can you send me all the invoices for the *HIGHLIGHTED* expenses
   attached to this email?
   Please can you explain what all the other expenses relate to in the
   excel attached?
   Please can you confirm that *ALL* the Raw Mobility Expenses relate *100%
   to Raw Mobility* and not to Shamir Holdings or any other organisation or
   person unrelated to Raw Mobility?
   Is Shamir Holdings using Blender (owned, hosted, managed etc by Raw
   Mobility) to service its SMS customer/s or for any other reason whatsoever?

   7. Raw Mobility’s largest customer is Mobivate.  From review of the
   Sassu file, there is another small customer.
   Noted


Looking forward to your reply

Regards

Brad



On Fri, May 9, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:

> Brad,
>
> I see no factual errors in Eli’s email.
>
>  Ideally, to promote transparency, Shamir Holdings should acquire sms’
> directly from Twilio.
>
>
> I have already made the necessary changes so those expenses are not
> charged to Raw Mobility.
>
> On 9 May 2025, at 5:25 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Eli
>
> I hope you are well. Thank you very much for your detailed response. Much
> appreciated.
>
> Asaf, are you 100% in agreement with everything Eli has stated?
>
> Thanks
>
> Brad
>
>
> On Fri, 9 May 2025 at 02:16, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Hi Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> I have reviewed Asaf’s responses and understand as follows:
>>
>>    1. Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>    2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>>    software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I
>>    understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate
>>    and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>>    3. Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open
>>    Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset
>>    is @ cost.
>>    4. Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff
>>    member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw
>>    Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been
>>    recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can
>>    certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate
>>    line item for clarity.
>>    5. Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code
>>    associated with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or
>>    patent registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given
>>    the email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in
>>    this regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a
>>    referral.
>>    6. Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all
>>    been expensed by Raw Mobility.
>>    7. Raw Mobility’s largest customer is Mobivate.  From review of the
>>    Sassu file, there is another small customer.
>>
>>
>>
>> Separately, I note the following:
>>
>>    1. I understand that your preference is for Raw Mobility to employee
>>    the staff member presently employed by Shamir Holdings.  This is a
>>    commercial decision for you and Asaf to resolve.
>>    2. I understand that you believe that R&D should be capitalised (and
>>    amortised) rather than expensed.  I note that the accounting statements
>>    prepared are special purpose financial statements and in this regard, they
>>    have not been prepared in accordance with AASB 138 ‘Intangible Assets’
>>    which may require a portion to be capitalised.
>>    3. Raw Mobility is paying hosting fees, principally to AWS.  I
>>    understand that these fees are paid for hosting the Blender Software.  I
>>    understand that Raw Mobility does not pay hosting fees for IP owned by
>>    Shamir Holdings.
>>    4. Raw Mobility pays Twilio on a monthly basis.  Historically, Shamir
>>    Holdings has reduced its licence fees invoiced to Raw Mobility as payment
>>    for sms’ acquired by Shamir Holdings.  Ideally, to promote transparency,
>>    Shamir Holdings should acquire sms’ directly from Twilio.
>>
>>
>>
>> On this basis, it is not clear to me as to why you are of the view that
>> the financial statements do not reflect the true position of the company
>> and lack integrity.  If you still feel that this is in fact the case, I
>> would encourage you and Asaf to have the a/cs prepared by an independent
>> third party and agree on the accounting policies by which such third party
>> should draft the accounts.
>>
>>
>>
>> Should you have any queries in relation to the above, please feel free to
>> contact me.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>>

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#22  2025-05-12T08:47:20+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>, Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Sent: Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)

Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in RED below.


  1.  Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
  2.  Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement, which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf. Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf.  Based on my brief review of previous correspondence, I don’t see any contradiction. In any case, my understanding is as per my email of 9/5 which Asaf has subsequently confirmed to be consistent with his understanding.
  3.  Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @ cost.
Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer Shamir Holdings? This is a commercial issue between you and Asaf
Surely arms length transactions (usually documented in the rules of transfer pricing) are essential when 2 Australian companies have the identical Director/UBO's? I don’t see a transfer pricing issue.  Rather, there is a commercial agreement in place which looks to have been in place for quite some time.  If not documented, you and Asaf can agree to do so.  Likewise, the same should hold true for fees Raw Mobility charges Mobivate.
Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm.
Is it fair to say that Shamir Holdings has one or more customers that utilise and pay Shamir Holdings for the delivery of bulk SMS messages? Asaf to confirm
  4.  Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate line item for clarity.
Eli, are you happy with the Man Accs / F/S's calling it an Open Model License Fee when in fact a part of it has nothing to do with a License of software but entirely the cost of an employee of another company? As I noted in my previous email, we can certainly separate as a stand-alone expense line item.  Net effect on P&L is the same.
Is there an Agreement between RM and Shamir relating to this employee cost? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm
In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly

  5.  Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code associated with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or patent registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given the email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in this regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a referral.
Thanks Eli - definitely something worth considering, however I think it may be very difficult to do. Noted
  6.  Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all been expensed by Raw Mobility.
Please can you send me all the invoices for the HIGHLIGHTED expenses attached to this email? Asaf to provide
Please can you explain what all the other expenses relate to in the excel attached? Asaf to advise
Please can you confirm that ALL the Raw Mobility Expenses relate 100% to Raw Mobility and not to Shamir Holdings or any other organisation or person unrelated to Raw Mobility? Asaf to confirm
Is Shamir Holdings using Blender (owned, hosted, managed etc by Raw Mobility) to service its SMS customer/s or for any other reason whatsoever? Asaf to confirm
  7.  Raw Mobility’s largest customer is Mobivate.  From review of the Sassu file, there is another small customer.
Noted

Looking forward to your reply

Regards

Brad



On Fri, May 9, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,

I see no factual errors in Eli’s email.

 Ideally, to promote transparency, Shamir Holdings should acquire sms’ directly from Twilio.

I have already made the necessary changes so those expenses are not charged to Raw Mobility.


On 9 May 2025, at 5:25 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:

Hi Eli

I hope you are well. Thank you very much for your detailed response. Much appreciated.

Asaf, are you 100% in agreement with everything Eli has stated?

Thanks

Brad


On Fri, 9 May 2025 at 02:16, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Hi Brad

I have reviewed Asaf’s responses and understand as follows:

  1.  Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
  2.  Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
  3.  Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @ cost.
  4.  Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate line item for clarity.
  5.  Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code associated with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or patent registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given the email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in this regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a referral.
  6.  Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all been expensed by Raw Mobility.
  7.  Raw Mobility’s largest customer is Mobivate.  From review of the Sassu file, there is another small customer.

Separately, I note the following:

  1.  I understand that your preference is for Raw Mobility to employee the staff member presently employed by Shamir Holdings.  This is a commercial decision for you and Asaf to resolve.
  2.  I understand that you believe that R&D should be capitalised (and amortised) rather than expensed.  I note that the accounting statements prepared are special purpose financial statements and in this regard, they have not been prepared in accordance with AASB 138 ‘Intangible Assets’ which may require a portion to be capitalised.
  3.  Raw Mobility is paying hosting 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#23  2025-05-12T10:00:57+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well.

Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
*Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer
but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?*

2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.

*I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:*

*As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.*

*On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:*

*Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec
2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in
addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for
contractor expenses  incurred.*

Now you are both telling me this is *NOT* Asaf's remuneration but in fact a
License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw
Mobility. *Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?*

*In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:*

How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169
ex GST)?


In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so
that we can consider and respond accordingly.

*I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.*


Thanks


Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
> *To:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> *Cc:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>;
> Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)
>
>
>
> Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in * RED* below.
>
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>    Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf
>    to confirm
>    Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>    2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>    software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I
>    understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate
>    and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>    Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement,
>    which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf.
>    Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to
>    $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments
>    contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf.  Based on my brief
>    review of previous correspondence, I don’t see any contradiction. In any
>    case, my understanding is as per my email of 9/5 which Asaf has
>    subsequently confirmed to be consistent with his understanding.
>    3. Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model
>    Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @
>    cost.
>    Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer
>    Shamir Holdings? This is a commercial issue between you and Asaf
>    Surely arms length transactions (usually documented in the rules of
>    transfer pricing) are essential when 2 Australian companies have the
>    identical Director/UBO's? I don’t see a transfer pricing issue.
>    Rather, there is a commercial agreement in place which looks to have been
>    in place for quite some time.  If not documented, you and Asaf can agree to
>    do so.  Likewise, the same should hold true for fees Raw Mobility charges
>    Mobivate.
>    Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf
>    to confirm.
>    Is it fair to say that Shamir Holdings has one or more customers that
>    utilise and pay Shamir Holdings for the delivery of bulk SMS messages? Asaf
>    to confirm
>    4. Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff
>    member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw
>    Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been
>    recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can
>    certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate
>    line item for clarity.
>    Eli, are you happy with the Man Accs / F/S's calling it an Open Model
>    License Fee when in fact a part of it has nothing to do with a License of
>    software but entirely the cost of an employee of another company? As I
>    noted in my previous email, we can certainly separate as a stand-alone
>    expense line item.  Net effect on P&L is the same.
>    Is there an Agreement between RM and Shamir relating to this employee
>    cost? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm
>    In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to
>    $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you
>    reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly
>
>    5. Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code
>    associated with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or
>    patent registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given
>    the email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in
>    this regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a referral.
>    Thanks Eli - definitely something worth considering, however I think
>    it may be very difficult to do. Noted
>    6. Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all
>    been expensed by Raw Mobility.
>    Please can you send me all the invoices for the *HIGHLIGHTED* expenses
>    attached to this email? Asaf to provide
>    Please can you explain what all the other expenses relate to in the
>    excel attached? Asaf to advise
>    Please can you confirm that *ALL* the Raw Mobility Expenses relate *
>    100% to Raw Mobility* and not to Shamir Holdings or any other
>    organisation or person unrelated to Raw Mobility? Asaf to confirm
>    Is Shamir Holdings using Blender (owned, hosted, managed etc by Raw
>    Mobility) to service its SMS customer/s or for any other reason whatsoever? Asaf
>    to confirm
>    7. Raw Mobility’s largest customer is Mobivate.  From review of the
>    Sassu file, there is another small customer.
>    Noted
>
>
>
> Looking forward to your reply
>
>
>
> Regards
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> On Fri, May 9, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad,
>
>
>
> I see no factual errors in Eli’s email.
>
>
>
>  Ideally, to promote transparency, Shamir Holdings should acquire sms’
> directly from Twilio.
>
>
>
> I have already made the necessary changes so those expenses are not
> charged to Raw Mobility.
>
>
>
> On 9 May 2025, at 5:25 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well. Thank you very much for your detailed response. Much
> appreciated.
>
>
>
> Asaf, are you 100% in agreement with everything Eli has stated?
>
>
>
> Thanks
>

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#24  2025-05-12T09:18:50+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Sent: Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well.

Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?

If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.
2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:
Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for contractor expenses  incurred.
Now you are both telling me this is NOT Asaf's remuneration but in fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw Mobility. Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?
Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor
In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:
How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?
I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will review and come back to you
In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.
Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in Sassu file
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Cc: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au<mailto:Alia@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)

Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in RED below.


  1.  Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
  2.  Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement, which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf. Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf.  Based on my brief review of previous correspondence, I don’t see any contradiction. In any case, my understanding is as per my email of 9/5 which Asaf has subsequently confirmed to be consistent with his understanding.
  3.  Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @ cost.
Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer Shamir Holdings? This is a commercial issue between you and Asaf
Surely arms length transactions (usually documented in the rules of transfer pricing) are essential when 2 Australian companies have the identical Director/UBO's? I don’t see a transfer pricing issue.  Rather, there is a commercial agreement in place which looks to have been in place for quite some time.  If not documented, you and Asaf can agree to do so.  Likewise, the same should hold true for fees Raw Mobility charges Mobivate.
Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm.
Is it fair to say that Shamir Holdings has one or more customers that utilise and pay Shamir Holdings for the delivery of bulk SMS messages? Asaf to confirm
  4.  Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate line item for clarity.
Eli, are you happy with the Man Accs / F/S's calling it an Open Model License Fee when in fact a part of it has nothing to do with a License of software but entirely the cost of an employee of another company? As I noted in my previous email, we can certainly separate as a stand-alone expense line item.  Net effect on P&L is the same.
Is there an Agreement between RM and Shamir relating to this employee cost? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm
In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly

  5.  Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code associated with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or patent registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given the email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in this regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a referral.
Thanks Eli - definitely something worth considering, however I think it may be very difficult to do. Noted
  6.  Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all been expensed by Raw Mobility.
Please can you send me all the invoices for the HIGHLIGHTED expenses attached to this email? Asaf to provide
Please can you explain what all the other expenses relate to in the excel attached? Asaf to advise
Please can you confirm that ALL the Raw Mobility Expenses relate 100% to Raw Mobility and not to Shamir Holdings or any other organisation or person unrelated to Raw Mobilit

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#25  2025-05-12T23:36:07+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>,
 Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>,
 Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>,
 Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad,

See my responses below.
I believe Eli already addressed your other questions.

> 1. Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me.

There is no written agreement. I invoice Raw Mobility parts of the agreed upon remuneration as per our (Brad & Asaf)verbal agreement.

> 2. fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?

My invoices for that month included an agreed upon bonus payment of $90k (ex GST)..

You can find our discussion on the matter in your WhatsApp records dated 19/March/2024.

> 3. Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer Shamir Holdings? 


Because we (Asaf & Brad) agreed, that I can get these messages at cost.
We discussed the fact that I would purchase/send messages at cost, that I have one customer, and you agreed to it. 

If this current commercial arrangement is no longer suitable, please feel free to contact me at your convenience to discuss.

> 3. Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me.

Our agreement was made verbally during a phone conversation.

> Please can you send me all the invoices for the HIGHLIGHTED expenses attached to this email?

I attached a zip file with invoices that were immediately accessible to me and cover the major expenses. The rest have either been provided to our accountant or (if paper) are with the bookkeeper.
If you want, I can ask the bookkeeper to dig through records, but that would take some time.

I might not have receipts for some of the petty cash expenses (e.g. coffee/lunch).

> Please can you explain what all the other expenses relate to in the excel attached?


AWS
 	63,089.10 
Hosting for Raw Mobility
Digitalocean.Com
 	2,045.72 
Hosting for Raw Mobility
Paypal
 	1,687.79 
These expenses include amenities, godaddy, coffee beans..
GoDaddy
 	809.22 
Domains for Raw Mobility
Coffee shop
 	682.84 

Google
 	603.40 
Gmail. Supplied one invoice, multiply 
Amazon
 	452.02 
Amenities, not all have invoices from Amazon. 
Apple
 	448.95 
Christmas present for dev
Cloudflare
 	393.56 
Website security / DNS management
Work cover
 	344.85 
Workers' compensation scheme
Invoice is in paper form with Bookkeeper
Telstra (prepaid)
 	310.00 
Mobile hotspot / data
AA Glen Iris
 	268.60 
Gas purchase for outdoor heating. 
I sometimes work outside in winter when wife works from home.
Not sure I have receipts
Solar Winds
 	262.59 
Pingdom / Monitoring
Belong Melbourne
 	257.00 
Support phone
Officeworks
 	221.10 
Printer ink and assorted office supplies
Dropbox
 	206.80 
Shared/cloud storage
Aus Post
 	174.00 
PO Box
Jetbrains
 	172.97 
IDE (Software dev tool license)
Tonic And Grace
 	65.59 
Coffee/meal with Developer / Consultant
So Pho So Good
 	62.74 
Coffee/meal with Developer / Consultant
Winter Malvern
 	62.63 
Coffee/meal with Developer / Consultant
Moby
 	55.65 
Coffee/meal with Developer / Consultant
Linger Café
 	53.20 
Coffee/meal with Developer / Consultant
EG Group
 	32.00 
Unsure, possibly gas station lunch
Crea Investments
 	11.50 
Coffee shop
Tang @ Zheng
 	10.00 
Unsure.
SMP Winter Melbourne
 	5.20 
Coffe

Apple: $400 is the xmas present. The $49.95 should not have come out of Raw Mobility’s card - it’s a recurring monthly subscription that comes off my personal card, and was erroneously charged to Raw Mobility.
Paypal (examplesl:
$500 USD is payment on behalf of Mobivate to SMS Studio (invoice attached)
$111 USD is payment for Jetbrains (IDE) (Inoice attached)
$153 is payment for PO Box renewal (invoice attached)
$88 is for Belong (support phone)
$170.73 is for Godaddy)
$588.95 is for a desk (invoice attached)

I’ve just gone through some PayPal transactions, so I’m not sure these match your aggregation. If you can show me the breakdown of the sums (PayPal/amazon), I’ll be able to address them more clearly.

> Please can you confirm that ALL the Raw Mobility Expenses relate

I spend money from Raw Mobility’s accounts in the service Raw Mobility.
I also host Raw Mobility's office at my house, and provide it with space, water, electricity, internet, cleaning, security, amenities etc.

> Is Shamir Holdings using Blender (owned, hosted, managed etc by Raw Mobility) to service its SMS customer

I use blender for a single customer of mine, as discussed and agreed with you, verbally, in the past. 
If this current arrangement is no longer suitable, please feel free to contact me at your convenience to discuss.


Regards,
Asaf

￼

> On 11 May 2025, at 9:37 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)
> 
> Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in RED below.
> 
> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
> Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. 
> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited?
> 
> Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
> Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement, which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf. Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?
> 
> Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @ cost.
> Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer Shamir Holdings? 
> Surely arms length transactions (usually documented in the rules of transfer pricing) are essential when 2 Australian companies have the identical Director/UBO's?
> Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me.
> Is it fair to say that Shamir Holdings has one or more customers that utilise and pay Shamir Holdings for the delivery of bulk SMS messages?
> 
> Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate line item for clarity.
> Eli, are you happy with the Man Accs / F/S's calling it an Open Model License Fee when in fact a part of it has nothing to do with a License of software but entirely the cost of an employee of another company?
> Is there an Agreement between RM and Shamir relating to this employee cost? If so, please send it to me.
> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>  
> Raw Mobility is the owner of Blender software and the code associated with the software.  I’m not aware of any legal documentation or patent registrations to support this but I’d recommend, particularly given the email exchanges over the past month, that an IP lawyer be engaged in this regard.  I can refer you to an IP lawyer if you would like a referral. 
> Thanks Eli - definitely something worth considering, however I think it may be very difficult to do.
> 
> Expenses associated with developing the Blender software have all been expensed by Raw Mobility.
> Please can you send me all the invoices for the HIGHLIGHTED expenses attached to this email?
> Please can you explain what all the other expenses relate to in the excel attached?
> Please can you confirm that ALL the Raw Mobility Expenses relate 100% to Raw Mobility and not to Shamir Holdings or any other organisation or person unrelated to Raw Mobility?
> Is Shamir Holdings using Blender (owned, hosted, managed etc by Raw Mobility) to service its SMS customer/s or for any other reason whatsoever?
> 
> Raw Mobility’s largest customer is Mobiva

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#26  2025-05-12T15:20:31+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

   1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you

   2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
   thanks for clarifying that it is a

*License Fee *
   3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*

   July - 12,936.00
   Aug - 12,936.00
   Sep - 12,936.00
   Oct - 12,936.00
   Nov - 12,936.00
   Dec - 13,607.00
   Jan - 13,607.00
   Feb - 13,607.00
   Mar - 13,607.00
   Apr - 13,607.00
   May - 13,607.00
   June - 13,607.00

Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well.
>
>
>
> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>
> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
> *Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a
> lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?*
>
>
>
> *If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.*
>
> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
> software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
>
> *I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:*
>
> *As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.*
>
> *On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:*
>
> *Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec
> 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in
> addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for
> contractor expenses ** incurred.*
>
> Now you are both telling me this is *NOT* Asaf's remuneration but in fact
> a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw
> Mobility. *Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?*
>
> *Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To
> be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and
> reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir
> Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor*
>
> *In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:*
>
> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93
> ($105,169 ex GST)?
>
> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your
> allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will
> review and come back to you
>
> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
> ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number
> so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
>
> *I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.*
>
> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in
> Sassu file
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
> *To:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> *Cc:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>;
> Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)
>
>
>
> Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in *RED* below.
>
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>    Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf
>    to confirm
>    Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>    2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>    software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I
>    understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate
>    and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>    Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement,
>    which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf.
>    Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to
>    $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments
>    contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf.  Based on my brief
>    review of previous correspondence, I don’t see any contradiction. In any
>    case, my understanding is as per my email of 9/5 which Asaf has
>    subsequently confirmed to be consistent with his understanding.
>    3. Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model
>    Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @
>    cost.
>    Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer
>    Shamir Holdings? This is a commercial issue between you and Asaf
>    Surely arms length transactions (usually documented in the rules of
>    transfer pricing) are essential when 2 Australian companies have the
>    identical Director/UBO's? I don’t see a transfer pricing issue.
>    Rather, there is a commercial agreement in place which looks to have been
>    in place for quite some time.  If not documented, you and Asaf can agree to
>    do so.  Likewise, the same should hold true for fees Raw Mobility charges
>    Mobivate.
>    Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf
>    to confirm.
>    Is it fair to say that Shamir Holdings has one or more customers that
>    utilise and pay Shamir Holdings for the delivery of bulk SMS messages? Asaf
>    to confirm
>    4. Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff
>    member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw
>    Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been
>    recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can
>    certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate
>    line item for clarity.
>    Eli, are you happy with the Man Accs / F/S's calling it an Open Model
>    License Fee when in fact a part of it has nothing to do with a License of
>    software but entirely the cost of an employee of another company? As I
>    noted in my previous email, we can certainly separate as a stand-alone
>    expense line item.  Net effect on P&L is the same.
>    Is there an Agreement between RM and Shamir relating to this employee
>    cost? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm
>    In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to
>    $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you
>    reference this number so that we c

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#27  2025-05-13T09:00:45+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Asaf

Thanks for your email. My responses below:

*Asaf:* There is no written agreement. I invoice Raw Mobility parts of the
agreed upon *remuneration* as per our (Brad & Asaf) verbal agreement.
*Brad:* The only agreement we have is that a portion of your *gross
remuneration* would be invoiced from your company. I expected this to show
as a Consulting Fee. I was not aware of any License Fees at all. But again
you refer to remuneration. Eli has repeatedly insisted that this is not
remuneration and you have agreed. Please clarify once again?

*Asaf:* My invoices for that month included an agreed upon bonus payment of
$90k (ex GST).
*Brad:* But a Bonus is remuneration and not a License Fee. I hope we are in
agreement on that?

*Asaf:* We discussed the fact that I would purchase/send messages at cost,
that I have one customer, and you agreed to it.
*Brad:*  Yes but I thought the messages at cost were to maximise the profit
for Raw Mobility. I had no idea you were invoicing via Shamir Holdings for
these messages.

Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 3:20 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:

> Hi Eli
>
>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>
>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>    thanks for clarifying that it is a
>
> *License Fee *
>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>
>    July - 12,936.00
>    Aug - 12,936.00
>    Sep - 12,936.00
>    Oct - 12,936.00
>    Nov - 12,936.00
>    Dec - 13,607.00
>    Jan - 13,607.00
>    Feb - 13,607.00
>    Mar - 13,607.00
>    Apr - 13,607.00
>    May - 13,607.00
>    June - 13,607.00
>
> Thanks
>
> Brad
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli
>>
>>
>>
>> I hope you are well.
>>
>>
>>
>> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>
>> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>> *Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a
>> lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?*
>>
>>
>>
>> *If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.*
>>
>> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>> software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
>>
>> *I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:*
>>
>> *As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
>> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.*
>>
>> *On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:*
>>
>> *Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec
>> 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in
>> addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for
>> contractor expenses ** incurred.*
>>
>> Now you are both telling me this is *NOT* Asaf's remuneration but in
>> fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to
>> Raw Mobility. *Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?*
>>
>> *Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.
>> To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and
>> reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir
>> Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor*
>>
>> *In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:*
>>
>> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93
>> ($105,169 ex GST)?
>>
>> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your
>> allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will
>> review and come back to you
>>
>> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
>> ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number
>> so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
>>
>> *I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June
>> 2024.*
>>
>> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation
>> in Sassu file
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>>
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>>
>> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
>> *To:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>;
>> Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)
>>
>>
>>
>> Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in *RED* below.
>>
>>
>>
>>    1. Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>    Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf
>>    to confirm
>>    Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>>    2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>>    software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I
>>    understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate
>>    and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>>    Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement,
>>    which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf.
>>    Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to
>>    $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments
>>    contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf.  Based on my brief
>>    review of previous correspondence, I don’t see any contradiction. In any
>>    case, my understanding is as per my email of 9/5 which Asaf has
>>    subsequently confirmed to be consistent with his understanding.
>>    3. Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open
>>    Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset
>>    is @ cost.
>>    Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer
>>    Shamir Holdings? This is a commercial issue between you and Asaf
>>    Surely arms length transactions (usually documented in the rules of
>>    transfer pricing) are essential when 2 Australian companies have the
>>    identical Director/UBO's? I don’t see a transfer pricing issue.
>>    Rather, there is a commercial agreement in place which looks to have been
>>    in place for quite some time.  If not documented, you and Asaf can agree to
>>    do so.  Likewise, the same should hold true for fees Raw Mobility charges
>>    Mobiva

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#28  2025-05-13T18:46:51+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eli Lebovits <eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Fwd: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

First - Thanks again for your patience in dealing with Brad.

Hypothetical question - do his recent questions/issues have any impact on
the bottom line of Raw Mobility - E.g whether the invoice shows a line item
of “consulting” vs “license fee”?

   Asaf Shamir
m: 61417188345
s: asaf-shamir


---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Date: Tue, 13 May 2025 at 18:01
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
Ltd
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>


Hi Asaf

Thanks for your email. My responses below:

*Asaf:* There is no written agreement. I invoice Raw Mobility parts of the
agreed upon *remuneration* as per our (Brad & Asaf) verbal agreement.
*Brad:* The only agreement we have is that a portion of your *gross
remuneration* would be invoiced from your company. I expected this to show
as a Consulting Fee. I was not aware of any License Fees at all. But again
you refer to remuneration. Eli has repeatedly insisted that this is not
remuneration and you have agreed. Please clarify once again?

*Asaf:* My invoices for that month included an agreed upon bonus payment of
$90k (ex GST).
*Brad:* But a Bonus is remuneration and not a License Fee. I hope we are in
agreement on that?

*Asaf:* We discussed the fact that I would purchase/send messages at cost,
that I have one customer, and you agreed to it.
*Brad:*  Yes but I thought the messages at cost were to maximise the profit
for Raw Mobility. I had no idea you were invoicing via Shamir Holdings for
these messages.

Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 3:20 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:

> Hi Eli
>
>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>
>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>    thanks for clarifying that it is a
>
> *License Fee *
>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>
>    July - 12,936.00
>    Aug - 12,936.00
>    Sep - 12,936.00
>    Oct - 12,936.00
>    Nov - 12,936.00
>    Dec - 13,607.00
>    Jan - 13,607.00
>    Feb - 13,607.00
>    Mar - 13,607.00
>    Apr - 13,607.00
>    May - 13,607.00
>    June - 13,607.00
>
> Thanks
>
> Brad
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli
>>
>>
>>
>> I hope you are well.
>>
>>
>>
>> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>
>> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>> *Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a
>> lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?*
>>
>>
>>
>> *If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.*
>>
>> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>> software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
>>
>> *I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:*
>>
>> *As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
>> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.*
>>
>> *On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:*
>>
>> *Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec
>> 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in
>> addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for
>> contractor expenses ** incurred.*
>>
>> Now you are both telling me this is *NOT* Asaf's remuneration but in
>> fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to
>> Raw Mobility. *Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?*
>>
>> *Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.
>> To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and
>> reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir
>> Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor*
>>
>> *In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:*
>>
>> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93
>> ($105,169 ex GST)?
>>
>> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your
>> allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will
>> review and come back to you
>>
>> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
>> ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number
>> so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
>>
>> *I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June
>> 2024.*
>>
>> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation
>> in Sassu file
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>>
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>>
>> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
>> *To:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>;
>> Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)
>>
>>
>>
>> Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in *RED* below.
>>
>>
>>
>>    1. Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>    Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf
>>    to confirm
>>    Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>>    2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>>    software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I
>>    understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate
>>    and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>>    Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement,
>>    which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf.
>>    Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to
>>    $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments
>>    contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf.  Based on my brief
>>    review of previous correspondence, I don’t see any contradiction. In any
>>    case, my understanding is as per my email of 9/5 which Asaf has
>>    subsequently confirmed to 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#29  2025-05-13T08:51:03+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

No, they don’t.

Pls ring me when you get a chance.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Sent: Tuesday, 13 May 2025 6:47 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Fwd: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Eli,

First - Thanks again for your patience in dealing with Brad.

Hypothetical question - do his recent questions/issues have any impact on the bottom line of Raw Mobility - E.g whether the invoice shows a line item of “consulting” vs “license fee”?

   Asaf Shamir
m: 61417188345
s: asaf-shamir


---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Date: Tue, 13 May 2025 at 18:01
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>

Hi Asaf

Thanks for your email. My responses below:

Asaf: There is no written agreement. I invoice Raw Mobility parts of the agreed upon remuneration as per our (Brad & Asaf) verbal agreement.
Brad: The only agreement we have is that a portion of your gross remuneration would be invoiced from your company. I expected this to show as a Consulting Fee. I was not aware of any License Fees at all. But again you refer to remuneration. Eli has repeatedly insisted that this is not remuneration and you have agreed. Please clarify once again?

Asaf: My invoices for that month included an agreed upon bonus payment of $90k (ex GST).
Brad: But a Bonus is remuneration and not a License Fee. I hope we are in agreement on that?

Asaf: We discussed the fact that I would purchase/send messages at cost, that I have one customer, and you agreed to it.
Brad:  Yes but I thought the messages at cost were to maximise the profit for Raw Mobility. I had no idea you were invoicing via Shamir Holdings for these messages.

Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 3:20 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
Hi Eli

  1.  Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
  2.  Not sure what is poorly worded about "remunerations to Asaf" but thanks for clarifying that it is a License Fee
  3.  R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:

July - 12,936.00
Aug - 12,936.00
Sep - 12,936.00
Oct - 12,936.00
Nov - 12,936.00
Dec - 13,607.00
Jan - 13,607.00
Feb - 13,607.00
Mar - 13,607.00
Apr - 13,607.00
May - 13,607.00
June - 13,607.00
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrr9txK5vLMUW8Z1ggv?h=8ognv3WQXkifi6Q-ZzdrMuO9jJd1Xn80KgrTZUHpvpo=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhfrUEjwXgD1THYJ?h=iH7Y6vdv7yMtyRdGewx02YfVtkOU0By-sTN_PSk9YsY=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well.

Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?

If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.
2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:
Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for contractor expenses  incurred.
Now you are both telling me this is NOT Asaf's remuneration but in fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw Mobility. Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?
Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor
In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:
How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?
I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will review and come back to you
In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.
Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in Sassu file
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrr9txK5vLMUW8Z1ggv?h=8ognv3WQXkifi6Q-ZzdrMuO9jJd1Xn80KgrTZUHpvpo=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Cc: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au<mailto:Alia@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)

Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in RED below.


  1.  Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
  2.  Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software desig

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#30  2025-05-13T18:52:44+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

I can call you in 30 min if you’d like (7.30pm).

Or we can have a chat in the morning if you’d prefer a quiet evening.

Let me know what works best for you.

   Asaf Shamir
m: 61417188345
s: asaf-shamir


On Tue, 13 May 2025 at 18:51, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> No, they don’t.
>
>
>
> Pls ring me when you get a chance.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> *Sent:* Tuesday, 13 May 2025 6:47 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Fwd: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
> Mobility Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Eli,
>
>
>
> First - Thanks again for your patience in dealing with Brad.
>
>
>
> Hypothetical question - do his recent questions/issues have any impact on
> the bottom line of Raw Mobility - E.g whether the invoice shows a line item
> of “consulting” vs “license fee”?
>
>    Asaf Shamir
>
> m: 61417188345
>
> s: asaf-shamir
>
>
>
>
>
> ---------- Forwarded message ---------
> From: *bradgish* <brad@bradgish.com>
> Date: Tue, 13 May 2025 at 18:01
> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
>
>
>
> Hi Asaf
>
>
>
> Thanks for your email. My responses below:
>
>
>
> *Asaf:* There is no written agreement. I invoice Raw Mobility parts of
> the agreed upon *remuneration* as per our (Brad & Asaf) verbal agreement.
> *Brad:* The only agreement we have is that a portion of your *gross
> remuneration* would be invoiced from your company. I expected this to
> show as a Consulting Fee. I was not aware of any License Fees at all. But
> again you refer to remuneration. Eli has repeatedly insisted that this is
> not remuneration and you have agreed. Please clarify once again?
>
>
>
> *Asaf:* My invoices for that month included an agreed upon bonus payment
> of $90k (ex GST).
>
> *Brad:* But a Bonus is remuneration and not a License Fee. I hope we are
> in agreement on that?
>
>
>
> *Asaf:* We discussed the fact that I would purchase/send messages at
> cost, that I have one customer, and you agreed to it.
> *Brad:*  Yes but I thought the messages at cost were to maximise the
> profit for Raw Mobility. I had no idea you were invoicing via Shamir
> Holdings for these messages.
>
>
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 3:20 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Eli
>
>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>    thanks for clarifying that it is a *License Fee*
>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>
>    July - 12,936.00
>    Aug - 12,936.00
>    Sep - 12,936.00
>    Oct - 12,936.00
>    Nov - 12,936.00
>    Dec - 13,607.00
>    Jan - 13,607.00
>    Feb - 13,607.00
>    Mar - 13,607.00
>    Apr - 13,607.00
>    May - 13,607.00
>    June - 13,607.00
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrr9txK5vLMUW8Z1ggv?h=8ognv3WQXkifi6Q-ZzdrMuO9jJd1Xn80KgrTZUHpvpo=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhfrUEjwXgD1THYJ?h=iH7Y6vdv7yMtyRdGewx02YfVtkOU0By-sTN_PSk9YsY=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well.
>
>
>
> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>
> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
> *Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a
> lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?*
>
>
>
> *If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.*
>
> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
> software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
>
> *I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:*
>
> *As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.*
>
> *On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:*
>
> *Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec
> 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in
> addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for
> contractor expenses ** incurred.*
>
> Now you are both telling me this is *NOT* Asaf's remuneration but in fact
> a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw
> Mobility. *Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?*
>
> *Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To
> be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and
> reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir
> Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor*
>
> *In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:*
>
> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93
> ($105,169 ex GST)?
>
> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your
> allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will
> review and come back to you
>
> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
> ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number
> so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
>
> *I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.*
>
> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in
> Sassu file
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrr9txK5vLMUW8Z1ggv?h=8ognv3WQXkifi6Q-ZzdrMuO9jJd1Xn80KgrTZUHpvpo=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
> *To:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@sh

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#31  2025-05-13T19:28:55+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>
Subject: Fwd: Financial reports / Moving forward

Good evening Jeremy,

I hope all is well on you end.

Please see email below from my business partner.
Could you find some time tomorrow to discuss and dispense some commercial/legal advice?

Thanks in advance,
Asaf

> Begin forwarded message:
> 
> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward
> Date: 13 May 2025 at 7:17:54 PM AEST
> To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com>, Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>
> 
> Hi Asaf
> 
> I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:
> Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
> Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
> Raw Mobility does not own all the code
> Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
> The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but Shamir Holdings
> It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings to enure:
> both get revenue 
> both own code
> both have staff
> both have customers
> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at $500k fee), keeping in 
> mind that:
> Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
> Mobivate pays 8.5%
> Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is has just 1 customer)
> Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
> Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw Mobility, bearing in mind we are
> doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
> of the growth.
> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as you and Shamir Holdings 
> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or use a Mobivate email address.
> 
> See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach 
> (as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).
> 
> Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance:
> 
> Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very difficult to engage in direct
> conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to me, if not the worst. I guess
> you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really urge you to contact a children's
> hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit the kids in the oncology ward.
> 
> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought about them as I am trying desperately
> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to so I can sign off on the financials, 
> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70 hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings). 
> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you would like to pay?
> 
> Thanks and kind regards
> 
> Brad
> 
> 
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our business relationship. 
>> 
>> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well entrenched for years.
>> 
>> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created unnecessary challenges. 
>> 
>> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing the value of Raw Mobility.
>> 
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>> 
>> 
>>> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf,
>>> 
>>> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the arrangement, services, software and staffing provided 
>>> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the representative of both Mobivate and
>>> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on and who owns what and who works 
>>> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out below to ensure current invoices are paid 
>>> by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.
>>> 
>>> For March: (invoice currently $500,668.96)
>>> your Salary $5,000
>>> Shamir Holding fee $18,333 (currently shown as License Fee)
>>> Vadeesh Acharya fee $10,000 (currently shown as R&D)
>>> Raw Mobility expenses $6,000 (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
>>> Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 - $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = $83,043
>>> Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate = $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376
>>> Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility: $18,333+10,000+$83,043 = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
>>> Raw Mobility will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses of $6,000.
>>> 
>>> It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
>>> of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings and the dividends Shamir Holdings would earn,
>>> without having to put all the money into Raw Mobility for absolutely no reason.
>>> 
>>> Thanks
>>> 
>>> Brad
>>> 
>>> On Tue, Apr 15, 2025 at 6:54 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> Please find attached the bank statements for the dates you requested. The password has been sent to your father via text message.
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>>> On 15 Apr 2025, at 8:39 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>> 
>>>>> Good morning Brad,
>>>>> 
>>>>> As I am currently in Israel assisting my father in Israel, I may not have sufficient time to prepare the spreadsheet you requested.
>>>>> 
>>>>> I have sent you an invitation to access Saasu, the accounting software utilised by Raw Mobility. This platform includes direct feeds from the company’s bank account, which you can review at your convenience.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Please let me know if you need any further assistance or additional information.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Regards,
>>>>> Asaf
>>>>> 
>>>>>> On 10 Apr 2025, at 12:10 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Good morning Brad,
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> I’m flying out for my holiday this morning (landing tomorrow), so i'll find some time to sift through bank data next week and get you the information you requested.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> I’ll quickly address a couple of items which you seem concerned with:
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> “Coffee Shop” - I have reduced Raw Mobility’s expenses by $15,000-$30,000 a year by giving up office space and amenities since 2020. I occasionally have meetings with dev or work from a coffee shop, and expense those to Raw Mobility per my discretion.
>>>>>> “Twil

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#32  2025-05-13T22:52:09+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eli Lebovits <eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Fwd: Financial reports / Moving forward

Hi Eli,

Thanks for the call this evening, appreciated.

See the email below from Brad - he’s still pushing for restructuring the payment structure to avoid what he considers $100k monthly loss, which is effectively Raw Mobility's 25% tax.

My request from you:
1. To understand whether Brad’s calculations are correct (obvious mistakes: RWM’s expenses should probably be $10k+, R&D should be 13,607)
2. I know you’re not a lawyer, but do you see any glaring illegalities in what he’s proposing? This seems to push RWM to zero profitability, won’t the ATO be asking questions?

Thanks in advance,
Asaf



> Begin forwarded message:
> 
> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward
> Date: 13 May 2025 at 7:17:54 PM AEST
> To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com>, Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>
> 
> Hi Asaf
> 
> I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:
> Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
> Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
> Raw Mobility does not own all the code
> Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
> The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but Shamir Holdings
> It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings to enure:
> both get revenue 
> both own code
> both have staff
> both have customers
> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at $500k fee), keeping in 
> mind that:
> Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
> Mobivate pays 8.5%
> Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is has just 1 customer)
> Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
> Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw Mobility, bearing in mind we are
> doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
> of the growth.
> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as you and Shamir Holdings 
> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or use a Mobivate email address.
> 
> See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach 
> (as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).
> 
> 
> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought about them as I am trying desperately
> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to so I can sign off on the financials, 
> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70 hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings). 
> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you would like to pay?
> 
> Thanks and kind regards
> 
> Brad
> 
> 
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our business relationship. 
>> 
>> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well entrenched for years.
>> 
>> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created unnecessary challenges. 
>> 
>> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing the value of Raw Mobility.
>> 
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>> 
>> 
>>> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf,
>>> 
>>> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the arrangement, services, software and staffing provided 
>>> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the representative of both Mobivate and
>>> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on and who owns what and who works 
>>> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out below to ensure current invoices are paid 
>>> by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.
>>> 
>>> For March: (invoice currently $500,668.96)
>>> your Salary $5,000
>>> Shamir Holding fee $18,333 (currently shown as License Fee)
>>> Vadeesh Acharya fee $10,000 (currently shown as R&D)
>>> Raw Mobility expenses $6,000 (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
>>> Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 - $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = $83,043
>>> Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate = $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376
>>> Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility: $18,333+10,000+$83,043 = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
>>> Raw Mobility will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses of $6,000.
>>> 
>>> It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
>>> of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings and the dividends Shamir Holdings would earn,
>>> without having to put all the money into Raw Mobility for absolutely no reason.
>>> 
>>> Thanks
>>> 
>>> Brad
>>> 
>>> On Tue, Apr 15, 2025 at 6:54 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> Please find attached the bank statements for the dates you requested. The password has been sent to your father via text message.
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>>> On 15 Apr 2025, at 8:39 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>> 
>>>>> Good morning Brad,
>>>>> 
>>>>> As I am currently in Israel assisting my father in Israel, I may not have sufficient time to prepare the spreadsheet you requested.
>>>>> 
>>>>> I have sent you an invitation to access Saasu, the accounting software utilised by Raw Mobility. This platform includes direct feeds from the company’s bank account, which you can review at your convenience.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Please let me know if you need any further assistance or additional information.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Regards,
>>>>> Asaf
>>>>> 
>>>>>> On 10 Apr 2025, at 12:10 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Good morning Brad,
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> I’m flying out for my holiday this morning (landing tomorrow), so i'll find some time to sift through bank data next week and get you the information you requested.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> I’ll quickly address a couple of items which you seem concerned with:
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> “Coffee Shop” - I have reduced Raw Mobility’s expenses by $15,000-$30,000 a year by giving up office space and amenities since 2020. I occasionally have meetings with dev or work from a coffee shop, and expense those to Raw Mobility per my discretion.
>>>>>> “Twilio” - Per our past conversation and agreement, I have one customer for which I send messages to through the platform at c

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#33  2025-05-13T23:13:47+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: Financial reports / Moving forward

Asaf

We will review and come back to you shortly.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Sent: Tuesday, 13 May 2025 10:52 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Fwd: Financial reports / Moving forward

Hi Eli,

Thanks for the call this evening, appreciated.

See the email below from Brad - he’s still pushing for restructuring the payment structure to avoid what he considers $100k monthly loss, which is effectively Raw Mobility's 25% tax.

My request from you:
1. To understand whether Brad’s calculations are correct (obvious mistakes: RWM’s expenses should probably be $10k+, R&D should be 13,607)
2. I know you’re not a lawyer, but do you see any glaring illegalities in what he’s proposing? This seems to push RWM to zero profitability, won’t the ATO be asking questions?

Thanks in advance,
Asaf



Begin forwarded message:

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward
Date: 13 May 2025 at 7:17:54 PM AEST
To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>>, Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com<mailto:mcg@margish.com>>

Hi Asaf

I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:

  *   Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
  *   Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
  *   Raw Mobility does not own all the code
  *   Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
  *   The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but Shamir Holdings
It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings to enure:

  *   both get revenue
  *   both own code
  *   both have staff
  *   both have customers
Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at $500k fee), keeping in
mind that:

  *   Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
  *   Mobivate pays 8.5%
  *   Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is has just 1 customer)
  *   Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
  *   Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw Mobility, bearing in mind we are
doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
of the growth.
Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as you and Shamir Holdings
clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or use a Mobivate email address.
See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach
(as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).


I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought about them as I am trying desperately
to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to so I can sign off on the financials,
whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70 hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings).
Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you would like to pay?

Thanks and kind regards

Brad


On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,

To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our business relationship.

Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well entrenched for years.

I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created unnecessary challenges.

Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing the value of Raw Mobility.

Regards,
Asaf



On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:

Hi Asaf,

It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the arrangement, services, software and staffing provided
by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the representative of both Mobivate and
Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on and who owns what and who works
for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out below to ensure current invoices are paid
by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.

For March: (invoice currently $500,668.96)

  *   your Salary $5,000
  *   Shamir Holding fee $18,333 (currently shown as License Fee)
  *   Vadeesh Acharya fee $10,000 (currently shown as R&D)
  *   Raw Mobility expenses $6,000 (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
  *   Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 - $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = $83,043
  *   Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate = $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376
Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility: $18,333+10,000+$83,043 = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
Raw Mobility will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses of $6,000.

It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings and the dividends Shamir Holdings would earn,
without having to put all the money into Raw Mobility for absolutely no reason.

Thanks

Brad

On Tue, Apr 15, 2025 at 6:54 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
Brad,

Please find attached the bank statements for the dates you requested. The password has been sent to your father via text message.




On 15 Apr 2025, at 8:39 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:

Good morning Brad,

As I am currently in Israel assisting my father in Israel, I may not have sufficient time to prepare the spreadsheet you requested.

I have sent you an invitation to access Saasu, the accounting software utilised by Raw Mobility. This platform includes direct feeds from the company’s bank account, which you can review at your convenience.

Please let me know if you need any further assistance or additional information.

Regards,
Asaf


On 10 Apr 2025, at 12:10 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:

Good morning Brad,

I’m flying out for my holiday this morning (landing tomorrow), so i'll find some time to sift through bank data next week and get you the information you requested.

I’ll quickly address a couple of items which you seem concerned with:


  1.  “Coffee Shop” - I have reduced Raw Mo

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#34  2025-05-14T12:26:25+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>,
 Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad,

>   But a Bonus is remuneration and not a License Fee. 

It’s included in the license fee from which I’m paid remuneration.

> I thought the messages at cost were to maximise the profit 


The agreement was that I get messages at cost, that means no profit on those messages.
I (via Shamir Holdings) do not compete with Raw Mobility/Mobivate, I don’t advertise bulk sms services, I don’t seek bulk sms clients. We discussed one client, we agreed, and I kept at my word.

If you want to change this commercial arrangement between us, I’m a phone call away - as I’ve always been.

> On 13 May 2025, at 6:00 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Asaf
> 
> Thanks for your email. My responses below:
> 
> Asaf: There is no written agreement. I invoice Raw Mobility parts of the agreed upon remuneration as per our (Brad & Asaf) verbal agreement.
> Brad: The only agreement we have is that a portion of your gross remuneration would be invoiced from your company. I expected this to show as a Consulting Fee. I was not aware of any License Fees at all. But again you refer to remuneration. Eli has repeatedly insisted that this is not remuneration and you have agreed. Please clarify once again?
> 
> Asaf: My invoices for that month included an agreed upon bonus payment of $90k (ex GST).
> Brad: But a Bonus is remuneration and not a License Fee. I hope we are in agreement on that?
> 
> Asaf: We discussed the fact that I would purchase/send messages at cost, that I have one customer, and you agreed to it. 
> Brad:  Yes but I thought the messages at cost were to maximise the profit for Raw Mobility. I had no idea you were invoicing via Shamir Holdings for these messages.
> 
> Thanks
> 
> Brad
> 
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 3:20 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>> Hi Eli
>> Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>> 
>> Not sure what is poorly worded about "remunerations to Asaf" but thanks for clarifying that it is a License Fee
>> 
>> R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:
>> 
>> July - 12,936.00 
>> Aug - 12,936.00 
>> Sep - 12,936.00 
>> Oct - 12,936.00 
>> Nov - 12,936.00 
>> Dec - 13,607.00 
>> Jan - 13,607.00 
>> Feb - 13,607.00 
>> Mar - 13,607.00 
>> Apr - 13,607.00 
>> May - 13,607.00 
>> June - 13,607.00 
>> Thanks
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>>> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Regards,
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>>> 
>>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>> 
>>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>> 
>>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>>  
>>> 
>>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>>> Sent: Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
>>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
>>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Hi Eli
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> I hope you are well.
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>> 
>>> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>>> Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.
>>> 
>>> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  
>>> 
>>> I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:
>>> 
>>> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
>>> 
>>> On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:
>>> 
>>> Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for contractor expenses  incurred.
>>> 
>>> Now you are both telling me this is NOT Asaf's remuneration but in fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw Mobility. Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?
>>> 
>>> Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor
>>> 
>>> In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:
>>> 
>>> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?
>>> 
>>> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will review and come back to you
>>> 
>>> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
>>> 
>>> I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.
>>> 
>>> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in Sassu file
>>> 
>>> Thanks
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Brad
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Regards,
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>>> 
>>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>> 
>>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>> 
>>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>>  
>>> 
>>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>>> Sent: Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
>>> To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
>>> Cc: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au <mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au <mailto:Alia@gsca.com.au>>
>>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in RED below.
>>> 
>>>  
>>> 
>>> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>> Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm
>>> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>>> Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>>> Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement, which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf. Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#35  2025-05-14T03:39:15+00:00
From:    Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: RE: Financial reports / Moving forward

Hi Asaf

What are you like at 4pm today?

Jeremy Goldman
Principal Lawyer
Commercial and Corporate
[cid:image001.png@01DBC4D5.8CD46710]
[cid:image005.png@01DBC4D5.936612E0]
Level 4, 555 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne VIC 3000
D
+61 3 8600 8886
 |
M
+61 416 160 227
 |
kcllaw.com.au<http://kcllaw.com.au/>
[cid:image003.png@01DBC4D5.8CD46710]<https://www.linkedin.com/in/jeremy-goldman-4032064/>

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
NOTICES
UNINTENDED RECIPIENT: This email and any attachments are confidential, and may be subject to legal or other professional ​privilege or copyright. You should not read, copy, use or disclose them without authorisation. If you are not an intended ​recipient any confidentiality or privilege is not waived. Please notify us by return email and permanently delete both messages.
VIRUS WARNING: KCL Law does not accept liability in connection with computer virus, data corruption, delay, interruption, ​unauthorised access or unauthorised amendment.

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Sent: Tuesday, 13 May 2025 7:29 PM
To: Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>
Subject: Fwd: Financial reports / Moving forward


Caution: External Email
Good evening Jeremy,

I hope all is well on you end.

Please see email below from my business partner.
Could you find some time tomorrow to discuss and dispense some commercial/legal advice?

Thanks in advance,
Asaf


Begin forwarded message:

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward
Date: 13 May 2025 at 7:17:54 PM AEST
To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>>, Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com<mailto:mcg@margish.com>>

Hi Asaf

I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:

  *   Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
  *   Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
  *   Raw Mobility does not own all the code
  *   Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
  *   The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but Shamir Holdings
It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings to enure:

  *   both get revenue
  *   both own code
  *   both have staff
  *   both have customers
Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at $500k fee), keeping in
mind that:

  *   Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
  *   Mobivate pays 8.5%
  *   Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is has just 1 customer)
  *   Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
  *   Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw Mobility, bearing in mind we are
doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
of the growth.
Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as you and Shamir Holdings
clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or use a Mobivate email address.
See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach
(as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).

Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance:

Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very difficult to engage in direct
conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to me, if not the worst. I guess
you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really urge you to contact a children's
hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit the kids in the oncology ward.

I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought about them as I am trying desperately
to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to so I can sign off on the financials,
whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70 hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings).
Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you would like to pay?

Thanks and kind regards

Brad


On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,

To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our business relationship.

Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well entrenched for years.

I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created unnecessary challenges.

Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing the value of Raw Mobility.

Regards,
Asaf



On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:

Hi Asaf,

It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the arrangement, services, software and staffing provided
by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the representative of both Mobivate and
Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on and who owns what and who works
for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out below to ensure current invoices are paid
by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.

For March: (invoice currently $500,668.96)

  *   your Salary $5,000
  *   Shamir Holding fee $18,333 (currently shown as License Fee)
  *   Vadeesh Acharya fee $10,000 (currently shown as R&D)
  *   Raw Mobility expenses $6,000 (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
  *   Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 - $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = $83,043
  *   Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate = $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376
Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility: $18,333+10,000+$83,043 = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
Raw Mobility will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses of $6,000.

It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings and the dividends Shamir Holdings would earn,
without having to put all the money into Raw Mobility for absolutely no reason.

Thanks

Brad

On Tue, Apr 15, 2025 at 6:54 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
Brad,

Please find attached the bank statements for the dates you requested. The password has been sent to your father via text message.




On 15 Apr 2025, at 8:39 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:

Good morning Brad,

As I am currently in Israel assisting my father in Israel, I may not have suf

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#36  2025-05-14T13:48:17+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>
Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward

Hi Jeremy,

4pm works for me, 4.15 would be better.

I’ve prepared the response below, effectively saying “what the F do you want from me” without saying much else.

-------------

Dear Brad,

I hope this email finds you well.

I read your email a couple of times, and I don’t get to the bottom of it. Not me, nor our accountant understand what you’re driving at. I hope you spoke to him and received satisfactory answers to all your questions. 
 
All that you mentioned was discussed between us - verbally, or via email/whatsapp and was agreed upon and transparent.

Reading your email, I’m very confused because i've been your business partner for nearly 20 years, and for some reason all I get is complaints, questions, and other annoyances.
Although I made millions of dollars to our business partnership, I never got an email saying thank you for your contribution, devotion, professionally and solidarity.
I can assure you one thing - you will never find a business partner that has as much integrity and professionally as I do.

Dividends - Refer to my email from 4/April.

-------------

> On 14 May 2025, at 1:39 pm, Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au> wrote:
> 
> Hi Asaf
>  
> What are you like at 4pm today?
>  
> Jeremy Goldman
> Principal Lawyer
> Commercial and Corporate
> <image001.png>
> <image005.png>
> Level 4, 555 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne VIC 3000
> D 
> +61 3 8600 8886
>  | 
> M 
> +61 416 160 227
>  | 
> kcllaw.com.au <http://kcllaw.com.au/>
> <image003.png> <https://www.linkedin.com/in/jeremy-goldman-4032064/>
>  
> Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
> NOTICES
> UNINTENDED RECIPIENT: This email and any attachments are confidential, and may be subject to legal or other professional ​privilege or copyright. You should not read, copy, use or disclose them without authorisation. If you are not an intended ​recipient any confidentiality or privilege is not waived. Please notify us by return email and permanently delete both messages. 
> VIRUS WARNING: KCL Law does not accept liability in connection with computer virus, data corruption, delay, interruption, ​unauthorised access or unauthorised amendment.
>     
> From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
> Sent: Tuesday, 13 May 2025 7:29 PM
> To: Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au <mailto:jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>>
> Subject: Fwd: Financial reports / Moving forward
>  
> Caution: External Email
> 
> Good evening Jeremy, 
>  
> I hope all is well on you end.
>  
> Please see email below from my business partner.
> Could you find some time tomorrow to discuss and dispense some commercial/legal advice?
>  
> Thanks in advance,
> Asaf
> 
> 
> Begin forwarded message:
>  
> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
> Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward
> Date: 13 May 2025 at 7:17:54 PM AEST
> To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>>, Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com <mailto:mcg@margish.com>>
>  
> Hi Asaf 
>  
> I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:
> Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
> Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
> Raw Mobility does not own all the code
> Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
> The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but Shamir Holdings
> It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings to enure:
> both get revenue 
> both own code
> both have staff
> both have customers
> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at $500k fee),keeping in 
> mind that:
> Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
> Mobivate pays 8.5%
> Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is has just 1 customer)
> Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
> Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw Mobility, bearing in mind we are
> doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
> of the growth.
> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as you and Shamir Holdings 
> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or use a Mobivate email address.
> 
> See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach
> (as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).
>  
> Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance:
> 
> Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very difficult to engage in direct
> conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to me, if not the worst. I guess
> you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really urge you to contact a children's
> hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit the kids in the oncology ward.
>  
> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought about them as I am trying desperately
> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to so I can sign off on the financials,
> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70 hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings).
> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you would like to pay?
>  
> Thanks and kind regards
>  
> Brad
>  
>  
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
> Brad, 
>  
> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our business relationship. 
>  
> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well entrenched for years.
>  
> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created unnecessary challenges. 
>  
> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing the value of Raw Mobility.
>  
> Regards,
> Asaf
>  
> 
> 
> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>  
> Hi Asaf,
>  
> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the arrangement, services, software and staffing provided
> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the representative of both Mobivate and
> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on and who owns what and who works
> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out below to ensure current invoices are paid
> by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.
>  
> For March: (invoice currently $500,668.96)
> your Salary $5,000

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#37  2025-05-14T17:31:32+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>,
 Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward

Brad,

Regarding dividends - I’m suggesting we proceed with a dividend payment of $800,000. I’m open to considering a higher amount if you think it is prudent - please let me know.
Attached is a screenshot of the current balance, per your request:
￼

Can you please confirm when the outstanding invoices from Mobivate amounting to $989,249.63 will be paid?

Due
Amount
10 May 2025
$488,580.67
1 May 2025
$500,668.96

In respect to all the other matters your raised in your email, I do not propose to address them now. Safe to say I’m as equally surprised as you that all of this appears to be “news” to you.
This email should not be seen as an acknowledgment/admission of any of the matters raised in your email.

Regards,
Asaf


> On 13 May 2025, at 7:17 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Asaf
> 
> I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:
> Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
> Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
> Raw Mobility does not own all the code
> Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
> The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but Shamir Holdings
> It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings to enure:
> both get revenue 
> both own code
> both have staff
> both have customers
> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at $500k fee), keeping in 
> mind that:
> Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
> Mobivate pays 8.5%
> Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is has just 1 customer)
> Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
> Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw Mobility, bearing in mind we are
> doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
> of the growth.
> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as you and Shamir Holdings 
> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or use a Mobivate email address.
> 
> See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach 
> (as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).
> 
> Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance:
> 
> Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very difficult to engage in direct
> conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to me, if not the worst. I guess
> you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really urge you to contact a children's
> hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit the kids in the oncology ward.
> 
> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought about them as I am trying desperately
> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to so I can sign off on the financials, 
> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70 hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings). 
> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you would like to pay?
> 
> Thanks and kind regards
> 
> Brad
> 
> 
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our business relationship. 
>> 
>> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well entrenched for years.
>> 
>> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created unnecessary challenges. 
>> 
>> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing the value of Raw Mobility.
>> 
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>> 
>> 
>>> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf,
>>> 
>>> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the arrangement, services, software and staffing provided 
>>> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the representative of both Mobivate and
>>> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on and who owns what and who works 
>>> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out below to ensure current invoices are paid 
>>> by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.
>>> 
>>> For March: (invoice currently $500,668.96)
>>> your Salary $5,000
>>> Shamir Holding fee $18,333 (currently shown as License Fee)
>>> Vadeesh Acharya fee $10,000 (currently shown as R&D)
>>> Raw Mobility expenses $6,000 (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
>>> Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 - $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = $83,043
>>> Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate = $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376
>>> Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility: $18,333+10,000+$83,043 = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
>>> Raw Mobility will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses of $6,000.
>>> 
>>> It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
>>> of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings and the dividends Shamir Holdings would earn,
>>> without having to put all the money into Raw Mobility for absolutely no reason.
>>> 
>>> Thanks
>>> 
>>> Brad
>>> 
>>> On Tue, Apr 15, 2025 at 6:54 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> Please find attached the bank statements for the dates you requested. The password has been sent to your father via text message.
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>>> On 15 Apr 2025, at 8:39 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>> 
>>>>> Good morning Brad,
>>>>> 
>>>>> As I am currently in Israel assisting my father in Israel, I may not have sufficient time to prepare the spreadsheet you requested.
>>>>> 
>>>>> I have sent you an invitation to access Saasu, the accounting software utilised by Raw Mobility. This platform includes direct feeds from the company’s bank account, which you can review at your convenience.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Please let me know if you need any further assistance or additional information.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Regards,
>>>>> Asaf
>>>>> 
>>>>>> On 10 Apr 2025, at 12:10 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Good morning Brad,
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> I’m flying out for my holiday this morning (landing tomorrow), so i'll find some time to sift through bank data next week and get you the information you requested.
>>>>>> 
>>>

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#38  2025-05-14T16:22:41+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward

Hi Asaf

   - payment was made - please confirm receipt?

   - the balance should therefore be over $3m and I propose a dividend of
   $2m which
   should leave plenty working capital as well as enough to cover the taxes.

BGG

On Wed, May 14, 2025 at 8:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:

> Brad,
>
> Regarding dividends - I’m suggesting we proceed with a dividend payment of
> $800,000. I’m open to considering a higher amount if you think it is
> prudent - please let me know.
> Attached is a screenshot of the current balance, per your request:
>
> Can you please confirm when the outstanding invoices from Mobivate
> amounting to $989,249.63 will be paid?
>
> *Due*
>
> *Amount*
>
> *10 May 2025*
>
> $488,580.67
>
> *1 May 2025*
>
> $500,668.96
>
> In respect to all the other matters your raised in your email, I do not
> propose to address them now. Safe to say I’m as equally surprised as you
> that all of this appears to be “news” to you.
> This email should not be seen as an acknowledgment/admission of any of the
> matters raised in your email.
>
> Regards,
> Asaf
>
>
> On 13 May 2025, at 7:17 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Asaf
>
> *I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:*
>
>    - Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
>    - Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
>    - Raw Mobility does not own all the code
>    - Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
>    - The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but
>    Shamir Holdings
>
> *It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir
> Holdings to enure:*
>
>    - both get revenue
>    - both own code
>    - both have staff
>    - both have customers
>
> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the
> best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM)
> that is half baked, leaving
> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at
> $500k fee),
> *keeping in mind that:*
>
>    - Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
>    - Mobivate pays 8.5%
>    - Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is
>    has just 1 customer)
>    - Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License
>    fee/R&D) and you get a salary
>    - Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw
>    Mobility, bearing in mind we are
>    doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate)
>    and are the sole reason for all
>    of the growth.
>
> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as
> you and Shamir Holdings
> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw
> Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or
> use a Mobivate email address.
>
>
> *See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach (as
> mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).*
>
> *Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree on
> dividend issuance:*
>
> Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very
> difficult to engage in direct
> conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to me,
> if not the worst. I guess
> you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really urge
> you to contact a children's
> hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit the
> kids in the oncology ward.
>
> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought
> about them as I am trying desperately
> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to
> so I can sign off on the financials,
> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70
> hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for
> Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings).
> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you
> would like to pay?
>
> Thanks and kind regards
>
> Brad
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Brad,
>>
>> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided
>> by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our
>> business relationship.
>>
>> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under
>> which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay
>> a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly
>> basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement
>> has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a
>> position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well
>> entrenched for years.
>>
>> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might
>> have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately,
>> recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct
>> conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created
>> unnecessary challenges.
>>
>> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss
>> further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing
>> the value of Raw Mobility.
>>
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>>
>>
>> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Asaf,
>>
>> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the
>> arrangement, services, software and staffing provided
>> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the
>> representative of both Mobivate and
>> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on
>> and who owns what and who works
>> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out
>> below to ensure current invoices are paid
>> by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.
>>
>> *For March*: (invoice currently $500,668.96)
>>
>>    - your Salary *$5,000*
>>    - Shamir Holding fee *$18,333* (currently shown as License Fee)
>>    - Vadeesh Acharya fee *$10,000* (currently shown as R&D)
>>    - Raw Mobility expenses *$6,000* (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
>>    - Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 -
>>    $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = *$83,043*
>>    - *Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate =
>>    $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376*
>>
>> *Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility*: $18,333+10,000+$83,043
>> = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
>> *Raw Mobility* will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses
>> of $6,000.
>>
>> It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir
>> Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
>> of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings
>> and the dividends Shamir Holdings would earn,
>> without having to put all the money into Raw Mobility for absolutely no
>> reason.
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>> Brad
>>
>> On Tue, Apr 15, 2025 at 6:54 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:
>>
>>> Brad,
>>>
>>> Please find attached the bank statements for the dates you requested.
>>> The password has been sent to your father via text message.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> On 15 Apr 2025, at 8:39 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> Good morning Brad,
>>>
>>> As I am currently in Israel assisting my father in Israel, I may not
>>> have sufficient time to prepare the spreadsheet you requested.
>>>
>>> I have sent you an invitation to access Saasu, the accounting software
>>> utilised by Raw Mobility. This platform includes direct feeds fro

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#39  2025-05-15T15:39:17+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>,
 Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward

Brad,

Thanks for settling the invoices.
I’ll revert once funds are cleared.

Regards,
Asaf


> On 15 May 2025, at 1:22 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Asaf
> payment was made - please confirm receipt?
> 
> the balance should therefore be over $3m and I propose a dividend of $2m which 
> should leave plenty working capital as well as enough to cover the taxes.
> BGG
> 
> On Wed, May 14, 2025 at 8:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> Regarding dividends - I’m suggesting we proceed with a dividend payment of $800,000. I’m open to considering a higher amount if you think it is prudent - please let me know.
>> Attached is a screenshot of the current balance, per your request:
>> 
>> Can you please confirm when the outstanding invoices from Mobivate amounting to $989,249.63 will be paid?
>> 
>> Due
>> Amount
>> 10 May 2025
>> $488,580.67
>> 1 May 2025
>> $500,668.96
>> 
>> In respect to all the other matters your raised in your email, I do not propose to address them now. Safe to say I’m as equally surprised as you that all of this appears to be “news” to you.
>> This email should not be seen as an acknowledgment/admission of any of the matters raised in your email.
>> 
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>> 
>> 
>>> On 13 May 2025, at 7:17 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf
>>> 
>>> I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:
>>> Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
>>> Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
>>> Raw Mobility does not own all the code
>>> Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
>>> The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but Shamir Holdings
>>> It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings to enure:
>>> both get revenue 
>>> both own code
>>> both have staff
>>> both have customers
>>> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
>>> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
>>> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at $500k fee), keeping in 
>>> mind that:
>>> Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
>>> Mobivate pays 8.5%
>>> Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is has just 1 customer)
>>> Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
>>> Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw Mobility, bearing in mind we are
>>> doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
>>> of the growth.
>>> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as you and Shamir Holdings 
>>> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
>>> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or use a Mobivate email address.
>>> 
>>> See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach 
>>> (as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).
>>> 
>>> Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance:
>>> 
>>> Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very difficult to engage in direct
>>> conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to me, if not the worst. I guess
>>> you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really urge you to contact a children's
>>> hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit the kids in the oncology ward.
>>> 
>>> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought about them as I am trying desperately
>>> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to so I can sign off on the financials, 
>>> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70 hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
>>> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings). 
>>> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you would like to pay?
>>> 
>>> Thanks and kind regards
>>> 
>>> Brad
>>> 
>>> 
>>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our business relationship. 
>>>> 
>>>> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well entrenched for years.
>>>> 
>>>> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created unnecessary challenges. 
>>>> 
>>>> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing the value of Raw Mobility.
>>>> 
>>>> Regards,
>>>> Asaf
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>>> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>> 
>>>>> Hi Asaf,
>>>>> 
>>>>> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the arrangement, services, software and staffing provided 
>>>>> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the representative of both Mobivate and
>>>>> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on and who owns what and who works 
>>>>> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out below to ensure current invoices are paid 
>>>>> by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.
>>>>> 
>>>>> For March: (invoice currently $500,668.96)
>>>>> your Salary $5,000
>>>>> Shamir Holding fee $18,333 (currently shown as License Fee)
>>>>> Vadeesh Acharya fee $10,000 (currently shown as R&D)
>>>>> Raw Mobility expenses $6,000 (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
>>>>> Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 - $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = $83,043
>>>>> Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate = $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376
>>>>> Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility: $18,333+10,000+$83,043 = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
>>>>> Raw Mobility will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses of $6,000.
>>>>> 
>>>>> It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
>>>>> of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings and the dividends Shamir Holdings would earn,
>>>>> without having to put all the money into Raw Mobility for absolutely no reason.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Thanks
>>>>> 
>>>>> Brad
>>>>> 
>>>>> On Tue, Apr 15, 2025 at 6:54 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Please find attached the bank statements for the dates you requested. The password has been sent to your father via text message.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> On 15 Apr 2025, at 8:39 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> Good morning Brad,
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> As I am currently in Israel

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#40  2025-05-20T16:13:21+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>,
 Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward

Hi Brad,

Confirming receipt of payment.
I propose $1.9m dividend and $130k bonus, keeping in mind I have not had a salary increase in 2 years.

Please allow a couple more days as we work out what the tax instalment for this quarter should be to maximise franking credits.
Please also re-confirm bank details of MARLAU Trust for the transfer.

Let me know,
Asaf

> On 15 May 2025, at 1:22 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Asaf
> payment was made - please confirm receipt?
> 
> the balance should therefore be over $3m and I propose a dividend of $2m which 
> should leave plenty working capital as well as enough to cover the taxes.
> BGG
> 
> On Wed, May 14, 2025 at 8:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> Regarding dividends - I’m suggesting we proceed with a dividend payment of $800,000. I’m open to considering a higher amount if you think it is prudent - please let me know.
>> Attached is a screenshot of the current balance, per your request:
>> 
>> Can you please confirm when the outstanding invoices from Mobivate amounting to $989,249.63 will be paid?
>> 
>> Due
>> Amount
>> 10 May 2025
>> $488,580.67
>> 1 May 2025
>> $500,668.96
>> 
>> In respect to all the other matters your raised in your email, I do not propose to address them now. Safe to say I’m as equally surprised as you that all of this appears to be “news” to you.
>> This email should not be seen as an acknowledgment/admission of any of the matters raised in your email.
>> 
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>> 
>> 
>>> On 13 May 2025, at 7:17 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf
>>> 
>>> I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:
>>> Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
>>> Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
>>> Raw Mobility does not own all the code
>>> Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
>>> The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but Shamir Holdings
>>> It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings to enure:
>>> both get revenue 
>>> both own code
>>> both have staff
>>> both have customers
>>> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
>>> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
>>> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at $500k fee), keeping in 
>>> mind that:
>>> Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
>>> Mobivate pays 8.5%
>>> Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is has just 1 customer)
>>> Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
>>> Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw Mobility, bearing in mind we are
>>> doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
>>> of the growth.
>>> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as you and Shamir Holdings 
>>> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
>>> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or use a Mobivate email address.
>>> 
>>> See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach 
>>> (as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).
>>> 
>>> Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance:
>>> 
>>> Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very difficult to engage in direct
>>> conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to me, if not the worst. I guess
>>> you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really urge you to contact a children's
>>> hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit the kids in the oncology ward.
>>> 
>>> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought about them as I am trying desperately
>>> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to so I can sign off on the financials, 
>>> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70 hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
>>> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings). 
>>> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you would like to pay?
>>> 
>>> Thanks and kind regards
>>> 
>>> Brad
>>> 
>>> 
>>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our business relationship. 
>>>> 
>>>> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well entrenched for years.
>>>> 
>>>> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created unnecessary challenges. 
>>>> 
>>>> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing the value of Raw Mobility.
>>>> 
>>>> Regards,
>>>> Asaf
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>>> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>> 
>>>>> Hi Asaf,
>>>>> 
>>>>> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the arrangement, services, software and staffing provided 
>>>>> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the representative of both Mobivate and
>>>>> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on and who owns what and who works 
>>>>> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out below to ensure current invoices are paid 
>>>>> by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.
>>>>> 
>>>>> For March: (invoice currently $500,668.96)
>>>>> your Salary $5,000
>>>>> Shamir Holding fee $18,333 (currently shown as License Fee)
>>>>> Vadeesh Acharya fee $10,000 (currently shown as R&D)
>>>>> Raw Mobility expenses $6,000 (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
>>>>> Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 - $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = $83,043
>>>>> Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate = $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376
>>>>> Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility: $18,333+10,000+$83,043 = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
>>>>> Raw Mobility will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses of $6,000.
>>>>> 
>>>>> It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
>>>>> of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings and the dividends Shamir Holdings would earn,
>>>>> without having to put all the money into Raw Mobility for absolutely no reason.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Thanks
>>>>> 
>>>>> Brad
>>>>> 
>>>>> On Tue, Apr 15, 2025 at 6:54 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Please find attached the bank statements for the dates you requested. The passw

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#41  2025-05-20T23:39:57+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: Financial reports / Moving forward

Asaf

It appears that there are errors in the spreadsheet but due to subsequent emails sent, status quo seems to be agreed to by Brad.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Eli Lebovits
Sent: Wednesday, 14 May 2025 9:14 AM
To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc: Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: Financial reports / Moving forward

Asaf

We will review and come back to you shortly.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Sent: Tuesday, 13 May 2025 10:52 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Fwd: Financial reports / Moving forward

Hi Eli,

Thanks for the call this evening, appreciated.

See the email below from Brad - he’s still pushing for restructuring the payment structure to avoid what he considers $100k monthly loss, which is effectively Raw Mobility's 25% tax.

My request from you:
1. To understand whether Brad’s calculations are correct (obvious mistakes: RWM’s expenses should probably be $10k+, R&D should be 13,607)
2. I know you’re not a lawyer, but do you see any glaring illegalities in what he’s proposing? This seems to push RWM to zero profitability, won’t the ATO be asking questions?

Thanks in advance,
Asaf

Begin forwarded message:

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Subject: Re: Financial reports / Moving forward
Date: 13 May 2025 at 7:17:54 PM AEST
To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>>, Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com<mailto:mcg@margish.com>>

Hi Asaf

I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:

  *   Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
  *   Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
  *   Raw Mobility does not own all the code
  *   Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
  *   The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but Shamir Holdings
It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings to enure:

  *   both get revenue
  *   both own code
  *   both have staff
  *   both have customers
Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example at $500k fee), keeping in
mind that:

  *   Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
  *   Mobivate pays 8.5%
  *   Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is has just 1 customer)
  *   Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
  *   Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw Mobility, bearing in mind we are
doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
of the growth.
Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off as you and Shamir Holdings
clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or use a Mobivate email address.
See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach
(as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).


I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought about them as I am trying desperately
to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to so I can sign off on the financials,
whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70 hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings).
Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you would like to pay?

Thanks and kind regards

Brad


On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
Brad,

To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact our business relationship.

Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well entrenched for years.

I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created unnecessary challenges.

Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing the value of Raw Mobility.

Regards,
Asaf


On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:

Hi Asaf,

It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the arrangement, services, software and staffing provided
by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As the representative of both Mobivate and
Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on and who owns what and who works
for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out below to ensure current invoices are paid
by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.

For March: (invoice currently $500,668.96)

  *   your Salary $5,000
  *   Shamir Holding fee $18,333 (currently shown as License Fee)
  *   Vadeesh Acharya fee $10,000 (currently shown as R&D)
  *   Raw Mobility expenses $6,000 (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
  *   Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 - $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = $83,043
  *   Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate = $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376
Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility: $18,333+10,000+$83,043 = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
Raw Mobility will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses of $6,000.

It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings and the dividends Shamir Holdings would earn,
without having to put all the money into Raw Mobility for absolutely no reason.

Thanks

Brad

On Tue, Apr 15, 2025 at 6:54 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
Brad,

Please find attached the bank statements for the dates you requested. The password has been sent to your father via text message.



On 15 Apr 2025, at 8:39 am, Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com<mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:

Good morning Brad,

As I am currently in Israel assisting my father in Israel, I may not have sufficient time to prepare the spreadsheet you requested.

I

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#42  2025-05-22T23:47:21+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Financial reports / Moving forward

Hi Asaf

I approve the dividend of 1.9m

Thanks

Brad

On Tue, May 20, 2025 at 7:13 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:

> Hi Brad,
>
>
>    - Confirming receipt of payment.
>    - I propose $1.9m dividend and $130k bonus, keeping in mind I have not
>    had a salary increase in 2 years.
>
>
> Please allow a couple more days as we work out what the tax instalment for
> this quarter should be to maximise franking credits.
> Please also re-confirm bank details of MARLAU Trust for the transfer.
>
> Let me know,
> Asaf
>
> On 15 May 2025, at 1:22 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Asaf
>
>    - payment was made - please confirm receipt?
>
>    - the balance should therefore be over $3m and I propose a dividend of
>    $2m which
>    should leave plenty working capital as well as enough to cover the
>    taxes.
>
> BGG
>
> On Wed, May 14, 2025 at 8:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Brad,
>>
>> Regarding dividends - I’m suggesting we proceed with a dividend payment
>> of $800,000. I’m open to considering a higher amount if you think it is
>> prudent - please let me know.
>> Attached is a screenshot of the current balance, per your request:
>>
>> Can you please confirm when the outstanding invoices from Mobivate
>> amounting to $989,249.63 will be paid?
>>
>> *Due*
>> *Amount*
>> *10 May 2025*
>> $488,580.67
>> *1 May 2025*
>> $500,668.96
>>
>> In respect to all the other matters your raised in your email, I do not
>> propose to address them now. Safe to say I’m as equally surprised as you
>> that all of this appears to be “news” to you.
>> This email should not be seen as an acknowledgment/admission of any of
>> the matters raised in your email.
>>
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>>
>>
>> On 13 May 2025, at 7:17 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Asaf
>>
>> *I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:*
>>
>>    - Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
>>    - Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
>>    - Raw Mobility does not own all the code
>>    - Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
>>    - The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility but
>>    Shamir Holdings
>>
>> *It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir
>> Holdings to enure:*
>>
>>    - both get revenue
>>    - both own code
>>    - both have staff
>>    - both have customers
>>
>> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in
>> the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
>> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company
>> (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
>> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example
>> at $500k fee),
>> *keeping in mind that:*
>>
>>    - Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
>>    - Mobivate pays 8.5%
>>    - Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is
>>    has just 1 customer)
>>    - Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services
>>    (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
>>    - Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw
>>    Mobility, bearing in mind we are
>>    doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via
>>    Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
>>    of the growth.
>>
>> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off
>> as you and Shamir Holdings
>> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw
>> Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
>> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or
>> use a Mobivate email address.
>>
>>
>> *See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach
>> (as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).*
>>
>> *Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree
>> on dividend issuance:*
>>
>> Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very
>> difficult to engage in direct
>> conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to me,
>> if not the worst. I guess
>> you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really urge
>> you to contact a children's
>> hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit the
>> kids in the oncology ward.
>>
>> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought
>> about them as I am trying desperately
>> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to
>> so I can sign off on the financials,
>> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70
>> hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
>> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for
>> Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings).
>> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you
>> would like to pay?
>>
>> Thanks and kind regards
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>>
>>> Brad,
>>>
>>> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements
>>> provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact
>>> our business relationship.
>>>
>>> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012, under
>>> which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated to pay
>>> a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a monthly
>>> basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That agreement
>>> has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now adopting a
>>> position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s been well
>>> entrenched for years.
>>>
>>> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might
>>> have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately,
>>> recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct
>>> conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created
>>> unnecessary challenges.
>>>
>>> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss
>>> further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing
>>> the value of Raw Mobility.
>>>
>>> Regards,
>>> Asaf
>>>
>>>
>>> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> Hi Asaf,
>>>
>>> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the
>>> arrangement, services, software and staffing provided
>>> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As
>>> the representative of both Mobivate and
>>> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on
>>> and who owns what and who works
>>> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out
>>> below to ensure current invoices are paid
>>> by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.
>>>
>>> *For March*: (invoice currently $500,668.96)
>>>
>>>    - your Salary *$5,000*
>>>    - Shamir Holding fee *$18,333* (currently shown as License Fee)
>>>    - Vadeesh Acharya fee *$10,000* (currently shown as R&D)
>>>    - Raw Mobility expenses *$6,000* (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
>>>    - Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 -
>>>    $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = *$83,043*
>>>    - *Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate =
>>>    $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376*
>>>
>>> *Shamir Holdings will then invoice Raw Mobility*:
>>> $18,333+10,000+$83,043 = $111,376 less cost of SMS (Mobivate + Twilio)
>>> *Raw Mobility* will then pay your salary of $5,000 and pay its expenses
>>> of $6,000.
>>>
>>> It has absolutely zero effect on the cash flows achieved by Shamir
>>> Holdings but gives Mobivate and Marlau the comfort
>>> of knowing that it is paying the costs of Raw Mobility & Shamir Holdings
>>> and the dividen

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#43  2025-05-30T09:24:17+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Financial reports / Moving forward

Hi Asaf

I am informed that the dividend, which was approved and declared, remains
unpaid.

Please can you let us know what the delay is in making payment?

Thank you

BGG

On Thu, May 22, 2025 at 11:47 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:

> Hi Asaf
>
> I approve the dividend of 1.9m
>
> Thanks
>
> Brad
>
> On Tue, May 20, 2025 at 7:13 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Hi Brad,
>>
>>
>>    - Confirming receipt of payment.
>>    - I propose $1.9m dividend and $130k bonus, keeping in mind I have
>>    not had a salary increase in 2 years.
>>
>>
>> Please allow a couple more days as we work out what the tax instalment
>> for this quarter should be to maximise franking credits.
>> Please also re-confirm bank details of MARLAU Trust for the transfer.
>>
>> Let me know,
>> Asaf
>>
>> On 15 May 2025, at 1:22 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Asaf
>>
>>    - payment was made - please confirm receipt?
>>
>>    - the balance should therefore be over $3m and I propose a
>>    dividend of $2m which
>>    should leave plenty working capital as well as enough to cover the
>>    taxes.
>>
>> BGG
>>
>> On Wed, May 14, 2025 at 8:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>>
>>> Brad,
>>>
>>> Regarding dividends - I’m suggesting we proceed with a dividend payment
>>> of $800,000. I’m open to considering a higher amount if you think it is
>>> prudent - please let me know.
>>> Attached is a screenshot of the current balance, per your request:
>>>
>>> Can you please confirm when the outstanding invoices from Mobivate
>>> amounting to $989,249.63 will be paid?
>>>
>>> *Due*
>>> *Amount*
>>> *10 May 2025*
>>> $488,580.67
>>> *1 May 2025*
>>> $500,668.96
>>>
>>> In respect to all the other matters your raised in your email, I do not
>>> propose to address them now. Safe to say I’m as equally surprised as you
>>> that all of this appears to be “news” to you.
>>> This email should not be seen as an acknowledgment/admission of any of
>>> the matters raised in your email.
>>>
>>> Regards,
>>> Asaf
>>>
>>>
>>> On 13 May 2025, at 7:17 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> Hi Asaf
>>>
>>> *I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:*
>>>
>>>    - Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
>>>    - Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
>>>    - Raw Mobility does not own all the code
>>>    - Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
>>>    - The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility
>>>    but Shamir Holdings
>>>
>>> *It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility & Shamir
>>> Holdings to enure:*
>>>
>>>    - both get revenue
>>>    - both own code
>>>    - both have staff
>>>    - both have customers
>>>
>>> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in
>>> the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
>>> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company
>>> (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
>>> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example
>>> at $500k fee),
>>> *keeping in mind that:*
>>>
>>>    - Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
>>>    - Mobivate pays 8.5%
>>>    - Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is
>>>    has just 1 customer)
>>>    - Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services
>>>    (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
>>>    - Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw
>>>    Mobility, bearing in mind we are
>>>    doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via
>>>    Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
>>>    of the growth.
>>>
>>> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off
>>> as you and Shamir Holdings
>>> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw
>>> Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
>>> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate or
>>> use a Mobivate email address.
>>>
>>>
>>> *See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach
>>> (as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).*
>>>
>>> *Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree
>>> on dividend issuance:*
>>>
>>> Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very
>>> difficult to engage in direct
>>> conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to me,
>>> if not the worst. I guess
>>> you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really
>>> urge you to contact a children's
>>> hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit
>>> the kids in the oncology ward.
>>>
>>> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even thought
>>> about them as I am trying desperately
>>> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer to
>>> so I can sign off on the financials,
>>> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70
>>> hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
>>> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for
>>> Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings).
>>> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you
>>> would like to pay?
>>>
>>> Thanks and kind regards
>>>
>>> Brad
>>>
>>>
>>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>>>
>>>> Brad,
>>>>
>>>> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements
>>>> provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact
>>>> our business relationship.
>>>>
>>>> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012,
>>>> under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated
>>>> to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a
>>>> monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That
>>>> agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now
>>>> adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s
>>>> been well entrenched for years.
>>>>
>>>> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you might
>>>> have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment. Unfortunately,
>>>> recent actions - including your decision to disengage from direct
>>>> conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have created
>>>> unnecessary challenges.
>>>>
>>>> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss
>>>> further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing
>>>> the value of Raw Mobility.
>>>>
>>>> Regards,
>>>> Asaf
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> Hi Asaf,
>>>>
>>>> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the
>>>> arrangement, services, software and staffing provided
>>>> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As
>>>> the representative of both Mobivate and
>>>> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on
>>>> and who owns what and who works
>>>> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward as set out
>>>> below to ensure current invoices are paid
>>>> by Mobivate to Raw Mobility.
>>>>
>>>> *For March*: (invoice currently $500,668.96)
>>>>
>>>>    - your Salary *$5,000*
>>>>    - Shamir Holding fee *$18,333* (currently shown as License Fee)
>>>>    - Vadeesh Acharya fee *$10,000* (currently shown as R&D)
>>>>    - Raw Mobility expenses *$6,000* (AWS, Google, Accounting fees etc)
>>>>    - Shamir Holding share = $500,668.96 - $5,000 - $18,333 - $10,000 -
>>>>    $6,000 = $461,353 * 0.18 = *$83,043*
>>>>    - *Raw Mobility invoice amount to Mobivate =
>>>>    $5000+$18,333+$10,000+$6000+$83,043 = $122,376

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#44  2025-05-31T10:08:42+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Financial reports / Moving forward

Brad,

Per advice from the accountant, we're adjusting the instalment amount for
the last BAS to ensure there's sufficient franking credits prior to paying
dividends.

We had some issues with the ATO system due to recent changes they made
which delayed submission.
This should be resolved in the next few days, and dividends will be paid.

Asaf

On Fri, May 30, 2025 at 6:24 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:

> Hi Asaf
>
> I am informed that the dividend, which was approved and declared, remains
> unpaid.
>
> Please can you let us know what the delay is in making payment?
>
> Thank you
>
> BGG
>
> On Thu, May 22, 2025 at 11:47 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
>> Hi Asaf
>>
>> I approve the dividend of 1.9m
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>> Brad
>>
>> On Tue, May 20, 2025 at 7:13 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>>
>>> Hi Brad,
>>>
>>>
>>>    - Confirming receipt of payment.
>>>    - I propose $1.9m dividend and $130k bonus, keeping in mind I have
>>>    not had a salary increase in 2 years.
>>>
>>>
>>> Please allow a couple more days as we work out what the tax instalment
>>> for this quarter should be to maximise franking credits.
>>> Please also re-confirm bank details of MARLAU Trust for the transfer.
>>>
>>> Let me know,
>>> Asaf
>>>
>>> On 15 May 2025, at 1:22 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> Hi Asaf
>>>
>>>    - payment was made - please confirm receipt?
>>>
>>>    - the balance should therefore be over $3m and I propose a
>>>    dividend of $2m which
>>>    should leave plenty working capital as well as enough to cover the
>>>    taxes.
>>>
>>> BGG
>>>
>>> On Wed, May 14, 2025 at 8:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>>>
>>>> Brad,
>>>>
>>>> Regarding dividends - I’m suggesting we proceed with a dividend payment
>>>> of $800,000. I’m open to considering a higher amount if you think it is
>>>> prudent - please let me know.
>>>> Attached is a screenshot of the current balance, per your request:
>>>>
>>>> Can you please confirm when the outstanding invoices from Mobivate
>>>> amounting to $989,249.63 will be paid?
>>>>
>>>> *Due*
>>>> *Amount*
>>>> *10 May 2025*
>>>> $488,580.67
>>>> *1 May 2025*
>>>> $500,668.96
>>>>
>>>> In respect to all the other matters your raised in your email, I do not
>>>> propose to address them now. Safe to say I’m as equally surprised as you
>>>> that all of this appears to be “news” to you.
>>>> This email should not be seen as an acknowledgment/admission of any of
>>>> the matters raised in your email.
>>>>
>>>> Regards,
>>>> Asaf
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> On 13 May 2025, at 7:17 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>
>>>> *I am very surprised and was genuinely unaware that:*
>>>>
>>>>    - Raw Mobility has only 1 staff member
>>>>    - Raw Mobility is set up a customer of Shamir Holdings
>>>>    - Raw Mobility does not own all the code
>>>>    - Vadeesh Acharya is not an employee of Raw mobility
>>>>    - The one other meaningful client is not a client of Raw Mobility
>>>>    but Shamir Holdings
>>>>
>>>> *It is now 100% clear that you have set up/managed Raw Mobility &
>>>> Shamir Holdings to enure:*
>>>>
>>>>    - both get revenue
>>>>    - both own code
>>>>    - both have staff
>>>>    - both have customers
>>>>
>>>> Whilst I fully understand why you have done this, it is clearly not in
>>>> the best interests of Mobivate/Marlau.
>>>> And therefore, I do not agree on paying such a high fee to a company
>>>> (RWM) that is half baked, leaving
>>>> Mobivate/Marlau almost $100k worse off each month (see attached example
>>>> at $500k fee),
>>>> *keeping in mind that:*
>>>>
>>>>    - Shamir Holdings uses Blender for free
>>>>    - Mobivate pays 8.5%
>>>>    - Shamir Holdings competes with Mobivate & Raw Mobility (even if is
>>>>    has just 1 customer)
>>>>    - Shamir Holdings gets very well remunerated for its services
>>>>    (License fee/R&D) and you get a salary
>>>>    - Whilst Mobivate and myself and my team get nothing from Raw
>>>>    Mobility, bearing in mind we are
>>>>    doing 100% of the sales function of Raw Mobility (albeit via
>>>>    Mobivate) and are the sole reason for all
>>>>    of the growth.
>>>>
>>>> Having said that, I do not want you and Shamir Holdings to be worse off
>>>> as you and Shamir Holdings
>>>> clearly offer a great service but are only doing so partially via Raw
>>>> Mobility. I also have honoured your previous
>>>> requests and have completely stopped asking you to represent Mobivate
>>>> or use a Mobivate email address.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> *See the attached spreadsheet that will give an outline of my approach
>>>> (as mentioned before the numbers may need tweaking).*
>>>>
>>>> *Asa far as disengaging in direct conversation and the refusal to agree
>>>> on dividend issuance:*
>>>>
>>>> Unfortunately, after your comments about my son, I am finding it very
>>>> difficult to engage in direct
>>>> conversation. It was one of the worst things anyone has ever said to
>>>> me, if not the worst. I guess
>>>> you have never been to a children's oncology ward and I would really
>>>> urge you to contact a children's
>>>> hospital and ask them if you can bring some toys/chocolates and visit
>>>> the kids in the oncology ward.
>>>>
>>>> I haven't refused to agree on dividends. In fact, I haven't even
>>>> thought about them as I am trying desperately
>>>> to understand what the bank statements in Raw Mobility actually refer
>>>> to so I can sign off on the financials,
>>>> whilst running Mobivate, training a new staff member, working 60 - 70
>>>> hours a week, saying Kaddish daily at Shul
>>>> and trying to be with my family whilst growing the revenue line for
>>>> Mobivate (and Raw Mobility / Shamir Holdings).
>>>> Please let me know what the cash balance is and how much dividend you
>>>> would like to pay?
>>>>
>>>> Thanks and kind regards
>>>>
>>>> Brad
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 5:17 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>
>>>>> To my knowledge, there are no conflicts between the arrangements
>>>>> provided by Raw Mobility, Shamir Holdings, and Mobivate that should impact
>>>>> our business relationship.
>>>>>
>>>>> Raw Mobility has maintained an agreement with Mobivate since 2012,
>>>>> under which Raw Mobility provides its services, and Mobivate is obligated
>>>>> to pay a fee of 8.5% of revenue generated using the Blender platform on a
>>>>> monthly basis, as detailed in the invoices issued by Raw Mobility. That
>>>>> agreement has not changed, and I’m at a loss to understand why you are now
>>>>> adopting a position which conflicts and contravenes an arrangement that’s
>>>>> been well entrenched for years.
>>>>>
>>>>> I would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss any concerns you
>>>>> might have directly with you to ensure clarity and alignment.
>>>>> Unfortunately, recent actions - including your decision to disengage from
>>>>> direct conversation and the refusal to agree on dividend issuance - have
>>>>> created unnecessary challenges.
>>>>>
>>>>> Now that I’m back in Australia I’m happy to have a call to discuss
>>>>> further, but the position you adopt here is concerning and risks depressing
>>>>> the value of Raw Mobility.
>>>>>
>>>>> Regards,
>>>>> Asaf
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> On 3 May 2025, at 11:55 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> Hi Asaf,
>>>>>
>>>>> It is very clear that there are a lot of conflicts between the
>>>>> arrangement, services, software and staffing provided
>>>>> by Raw Mobility and Shamir Holdings to each other and to Mobivate. As
>>>>> the representative of both Mobivate and
>>>>> Marlau, whilst we are in the process of understanding what is going on
>>>>> and who owns what and who works
>>>>> for where, Mobivate and Marlau are prepared to move forward 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#45  2025-06-05T09:29:39+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>
Subject: Fwd: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

Good morning Jeremy,

I hope all is well on your end.

We have completed the payment of dividends.
Brad is still refusing to sign off on the finances of Raw Mobility
I requested that he clarifies what he wants changed, but received no coherent response (see below)

Please let me know when you have some time to discuss my options for response and progress. I’ll adjust to meet your availability.

Thanks in advance,
Asaf

> Begin forwarded message:
> 
> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend
> Date: 5 June 2025 at 7:48:22 am AEST
> To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com>
> Cc: Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>
> 
> Asaf
> 
> Since the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:
> to discuss your salary?
> for a salary increase?
> for a bonus?
> to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?
> Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everyday
> and every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken an
> unreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenue
> of both companies.
> 
> It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)
> and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.
> 
> BGG
> 
> 
> 
> On Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> 1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation
>> 2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed 
>> 
>> Thanks,
>> Asaf
>> 
>> -- 
>> Asaf  Shamir
>> Raw Mobility
>> 
>> M:   +61-417-188345
>> P:   +61-3-86582162
>> www.rawmobility.com <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>> 
>>> On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf
>>> 
>>> I cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Eli
>>> revise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that they
>>> are not.
>>> 
>>> Thanks
>>> 
>>> Brad
>>> 
>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.
>>>> 
>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>> Brad,
>>>>> 
>>>>> I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?
>>>>> 
>>>>> On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> We cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send 
>>>>>> me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to 
>>>>>> just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> --
>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>> 
>>>>  <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>
>>>> +61-417-188345
>>>> +61-3-86582162
>>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>>  <http://www.rawmobility.com/>

================================================================================
#46  2025-06-06T11:46:15+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>
Subject: Re: Confirm account details for dividend

Good morning Jeremy,

Just wondering if you received the email below?

Thanks in advance,
Asaf

> On 5 Jun 2025, at 9:29 AM, Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
> 
> Good morning Jeremy,
> 
> I hope all is well on your end.
> 
> We have completed the payment of dividends.
> Brad is still refusing to sign off on the finances of Raw Mobility
> I requested that he clarifies what he wants changed, but received no coherent response (see below)
> 
> Please let me know when you have some time to discuss my options for response and progress. I’ll adjust to meet your availability.
> 
> Thanks in advance,
> Asaf
> 
>> Begin forwarded message:
>> 
>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend
>> Date: 5 June 2025 at 7:48:22 am AEST
>> To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com>
>> Cc: Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>
>> 
>> Asaf
>> 
>> Since the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:
>> to discuss your salary?
>> for a salary increase?
>> for a bonus?
>> to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?
>> Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everyday
>> and every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken an
>> unreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenue
>> of both companies.
>> 
>> It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)
>> and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.
>> 
>> BGG
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> On Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>> Brad,
>>> 
>>> 1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation
>>> 2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed 
>>> 
>>> Thanks,
>>> Asaf
>>> 
>>> -- 
>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>> Raw Mobility
>>> 
>>> M:   +61-417-188345
>>> P:   +61-3-86582162
>>> www.rawmobility.com <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>>> 
>>>> On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>> 
>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>> 
>>>> I cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Eli
>>>> revise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that they
>>>> are not.
>>>> 
>>>> Thanks
>>>> 
>>>> Brad
>>>> 
>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>> Brad,
>>>>> 
>>>>> Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.
>>>>> 
>>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> We cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send 
>>>>>>> me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to 
>>>>>>> just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> 
>>>>> 
>>>>> 
>>>>> --
>>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>>> 
>>>>>  <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>
>>>>> +61-417-188345
>>>>> +61-3-86582162
>>>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>>>  <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>

================================================================================
#47  2025-06-10T13:29:37+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

הי אחי, 

השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.

Brad,

It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.

We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.

To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.

We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.

This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.

If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.

Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..

My preference is to work together to find a solution.

Regards,
Asaf


> On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Asaf
> 
> Since the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:
> to discuss your salary?
> for a salary increase?
> for a bonus?
> to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?
> Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everyday
> and every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken an
> unreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenue
> of both companies.
> 
> It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)
> and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.
> 
> BGG
> 
> 
> 
> On Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> 1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation
>> 2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed 
>> 
>> Thanks,
>> Asaf
>> 
>> -- 
>> Asaf  Shamir
>> Raw Mobility
>> 
>> M:   +61-417-188345
>> P:   +61-3-86582162
>> www.rawmobility.com <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>> 
>>> On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf
>>> 
>>> I cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Eli
>>> revise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that they
>>> are not.
>>> 
>>> Thanks
>>> 
>>> Brad
>>> 
>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.
>>>> 
>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>> Brad,
>>>>> 
>>>>> I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?
>>>>> 
>>>>> On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> We cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send 
>>>>>> me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to 
>>>>>> just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> --
>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>> 
>>>>  <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>
>>>> +61-417-188345
>>>> +61-3-86582162
>>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>>  <http://www.rawmobility.com/>

================================================================================
#48  2025-06-10T08:03:31+03:00
From:    shamir@midasholdings.com
To:      Shamir Asaf <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

חילקת את הדיבידנד? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿הי אחי, השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.Brad,It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..My preference is to work together to find a solution.Regards,Asaf

On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:AsafSince the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:to discuss your salary?for a salary increase?for a bonus?to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everydayand every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken anunreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenueof both companies.It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.BGGOn Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed Thanks,Asaf
-- Asaf  ShamirRaw MobilityM:   +61-417-188345P:   +61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafI cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Elirevise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that theyare not.ThanksBradOn Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafWe cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).ThanksBGG-- Asaf  ShamirRaw Mobility+61-417-188345+61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

================================================================================
#49  2025-06-10T15:03:59+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      shamir@midasholdings.com
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

כן.

   Asaf Shamir
m: 61417188345
s: asaf-shamir


On Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:

> חילקת את הדיבידנד?
> Best regards,
>
> Eyal Shamir
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> Mobile +972-505636136
>
> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬
>
> ﻿
>
> הי אחי,
>
> השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח
> לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.
>
> Brad,
>
> It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of
> faith, trust and confidence.
>
> We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident
> director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with
> you, which you are not prepared to do.
>
> To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our
> differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation,
> facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of
> experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.
>
> We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you
> could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not
> in Australia.
>
> This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd
> party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.
>
> If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues
> for resolving these disputes between us.
>
> Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail
> to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday
> (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice
> in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to
> oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts.
> .
>
> My preference is to work together to find a solution.
>
> Regards,
> Asaf
>
>
> On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Asaf
>
> *Since the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate
> you have asked me:*
>
>    1. to discuss your salary?
>    2. for a salary increase?
>    3. for a bonus?
>    4. to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?
>
> Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I
> am working everyday
> and every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial
> statements have taken an
> unreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used
> to increase revenue
> of both companies.
>
> It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack
> integrity (and neither should you)
> and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will
> forever remain unsigned.
>
> BGG
>
>
>
> On Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:
>
>> Brad,
>>
>> 1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at
>> this allegation
>> 2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be
>> changed
>>
>> Thanks,
>> Asaf
>>
>> --
>> Asaf  Shamir
>> Raw Mobility
>>
>> M:   +61-417-188345
>> P:   +61-3-86582162
>> www.rawmobility.com
>>
>> On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Asaf
>>
>> I cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I
>> suggest that you and Eli
>> revise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something
>> that they
>> are not.
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>> Brad
>>
>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:
>>
>>> Brad,
>>>
>>> Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.
>>>
>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com>
>>> wrote:
>>>
>>>> Brad,
>>>>
>>>> I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all
>>>> transactions on the account.
>>>>
>>>> Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?
>>>>
>>>> On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>
>>>>> We cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can
>>>>> you send
>>>>> me the *bank statements of Raw Mobility* from *1 January 2015* until *31
>>>>> May 2025*.
>>>>>
>>>>> I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for
>>>>> you to
>>>>> just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).
>>>>>
>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>
>>>>> BGG
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>> --
>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>> Raw Mobility
>>>
>>> <asaf@shamir.com.au>
>>> +61-417-188345
>>> +61-3-86582162
>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>
>>
>>
>

================================================================================
#50  2025-06-10T08:36:58+03:00
From:    shamir@midasholdings.com
To:      Shamir Asaf <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

למה??אמרתי לך לא לחלק עד שיחתום…Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:04, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿כן.    Asaf Shamirm: 61417188345s: asaf-shamirOn Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:חילקת את הדיבידנד? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿הי אחי, השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.Brad,It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..My preference is to work together to find a solution.Regards,Asaf

On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:AsafSince the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:to discuss your salary?for a salary increase?for a bonus?to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everydayand every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken anunreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenueof both companies.It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.BGGOn Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed Thanks,Asaf
-- Asaf  ShamirRaw MobilityM:   +61-417-188345P:   +61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafI cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Elirevise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that theyare not.ThanksBradOn Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafWe cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).ThanksBGG-- Asaf  ShamirRaw Mobility+61-417-188345+61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

================================================================================
#51  2025-06-10T15:39:50+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

פועל לפי הנחייה של העורך דין.

> On 10 Jun 2025, at 3:36 PM, shamir@midasholdings.com wrote:
> 
> למה??
> אמרתי לך לא לחלק עד שיחתום…
> Best regards,
> 
> Eyal Shamir
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> Mobile +972-505636136
> 
>> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:04, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬
>> 
>> ﻿
>> כן. 
>> 
>>    Asaf Shamir
>> m: 61417188345
>> s: asaf-shamir
>> 
>> 
>> On Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com <mailto:shamir@midasholdings.com>> wrote:
>>> חילקת את הדיבידנד? 
>>> Best regards,
>>> 
>>> Eyal Shamir
>>> Midas Corporation Ltd.
>>> Mobile +972-505636136
>>> 
>>>> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> כתב/ה:‬
>>>> 
>>>> ﻿
>>> 
>>>> הי אחי, 
>>>> 
>>>> השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.
>>>> 
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.
>>>> 
>>>> We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.
>>>> 
>>>> To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.
>>>> 
>>>> We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.
>>>> 
>>>> This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.
>>>> 
>>>> If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.
>>>> 
>>>> Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..
>>>> 
>>>> My preference is to work together to find a solution.
>>>> 
>>>> Regards,
>>>> Asaf
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>>> On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>> 
>>>>> Asaf
>>>>> 
>>>>> Since the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:
>>>>> to discuss your salary?
>>>>> for a salary increase?
>>>>> for a bonus?
>>>>> to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?
>>>>> Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everyday
>>>>> and every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken an
>>>>> unreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenue
>>>>> of both companies.
>>>>> 
>>>>> It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)
>>>>> and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.
>>>>> 
>>>>> BGG
>>>>> 
>>>>> 
>>>>> 
>>>>> On Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation
>>>>>> 2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed 
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Thanks,
>>>>>> Asaf
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> -- 
>>>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> M:   +61-417-188345
>>>>>> P:   +61-3-86582162
>>>>>> www.rawmobility.com <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> I cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Eli
>>>>>>> revise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that they
>>>>>>> are not.
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> Brad
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> We cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send 
>>>>>>>>>> me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to 
>>>>>>>>>> just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> --
>>>>>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>>>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>  <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>
>>>>>>>> +61-417-188345
>>>>>>>> +61-3-86582162
>>>>>>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>>>>>>  <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>>>>

================================================================================
#52  2025-06-10T08:41:14+03:00
From:    shamir@midasholdings.com
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

אז למה אתה מתייעץ איתי? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:37, ‏shamir@midasholdings.com כתב/ה:‬﻿למה??אמרתי לך לא לחלק עד שיחתום…Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:04, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿כן.    Asaf Shamirm: 61417188345s: asaf-shamirOn Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:חילקת את הדיבידנד? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿הי אחי, השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.Brad,It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..My preference is to work together to find a solution.Regards,Asaf

On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:AsafSince the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:to discuss your salary?for a salary increase?for a bonus?to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everydayand every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken anunreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenueof both companies.It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.BGGOn Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed Thanks,Asaf
-- Asaf  ShamirRaw MobilityM:   +61-417-188345P:   +61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafI cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Elirevise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that theyare not.ThanksBradOn Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafWe cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).ThanksBGG-- Asaf  ShamirRaw Mobility+61-417-188345+61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

================================================================================
#53  2025-06-10T15:45:25+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

אני מתייעץ אתך אבל לא עושה דברים שיסכנו אותי חוקית.
אחי אם אתה מעדיף שלא אשאל אותך זה גם בסדר.


> On 10 Jun 2025, at 3:41 PM, shamir@midasholdings.com wrote:
> 
> אז למה אתה מתייעץ איתי? 
> 
> Best regards,
> 
> Eyal Shamir
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> Mobile +972-505636136
> 
>> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:37, ‏shamir@midasholdings.com כתב/ה:‬
>> 
>> ﻿
>> למה??
>> אמרתי לך לא לחלק עד שיחתום…
>> Best regards,
>> 
>> Eyal Shamir
>> Midas Corporation Ltd.
>> Mobile +972-505636136
>> 
>>> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:04, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬
>>> 
>>> ﻿
>>> כן. 
>>> 
>>>    Asaf Shamir
>>> m: 61417188345
>>> s: asaf-shamir
>>> 
>>> 
>>> On Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com <mailto:shamir@midasholdings.com>> wrote:
>>>> חילקת את הדיבידנד? 
>>>> Best regards,
>>>> 
>>>> Eyal Shamir
>>>> Midas Corporation Ltd.
>>>> Mobile +972-505636136
>>>> 
>>>>> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> כתב/ה:‬
>>>>> 
>>>>> ﻿
>>>> 
>>>>> הי אחי, 
>>>>> 
>>>>> השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Brad,
>>>>> 
>>>>> It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.
>>>>> 
>>>>> We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.
>>>>> 
>>>>> To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.
>>>>> 
>>>>> We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.
>>>>> 
>>>>> This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.
>>>>> 
>>>>> If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..
>>>>> 
>>>>> My preference is to work together to find a solution.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Regards,
>>>>> Asaf
>>>>> 
>>>>> 
>>>>>> On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Asaf
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Since the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:
>>>>>> to discuss your salary?
>>>>>> for a salary increase?
>>>>>> for a bonus?
>>>>>> to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?
>>>>>> Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everyday
>>>>>> and every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken an
>>>>>> unreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenue
>>>>>> of both companies.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)
>>>>>> and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> On Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> 1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation
>>>>>>> 2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed 
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> Thanks,
>>>>>>> Asaf
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> -- 
>>>>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> M:   +61-417-188345
>>>>>>> P:   +61-3-86582162
>>>>>>> www.rawmobility.com <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> I cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Eli
>>>>>>>> revise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that they
>>>>>>>> are not.
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> Brad
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> We cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send 
>>>>>>>>>>> me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to 
>>>>>>>>>>> just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> --
>>>>>>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>>>>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>  <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>
>>>>>>>>> +61-417-188345
>>>>>>>>> +61-3-86582162
>>>>>>>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>>>>>>>  <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>>>>>

================================================================================
#54  2025-06-10T08:46:51+03:00
From:    shamir@midasholdings.com
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

מה מסכן אותך חוקית אם לא מחלק דיבידנד? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:37, ‏shamir@midasholdings.com כתב/ה:‬﻿למה??אמרתי לך לא לחלק עד שיחתום…Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:04, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿כן.    Asaf Shamirm: 61417188345s: asaf-shamirOn Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:חילקת את הדיבידנד? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿הי אחי, השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.Brad,It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..My preference is to work together to find a solution.Regards,Asaf

On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:AsafSince the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:to discuss your salary?for a salary increase?for a bonus?to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everydayand every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken anunreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenueof both companies.It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.BGGOn Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed Thanks,Asaf
-- Asaf  ShamirRaw MobilityM:   +61-417-188345P:   +61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafI cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Elirevise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that theyare not.ThanksBradOn Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafWe cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).ThanksBGG-- Asaf  ShamirRaw Mobility+61-417-188345+61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

================================================================================
#55  2025-06-10T15:50:49+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

אחי,

סיכמנו על חלוקת דיבידנד, אני לא אמור לעכב את זה. חלק מהטענות שלי כלפיו זה שהוא מעכב את הדיבידנד.
ובלי שום קשר, כשאמרת לי לא לחלק הכסף עבר.

אני עכשיו מסרב לשתף איתו פעולה כשהוא מנסה להציג אותי בתור עובד של החברה שלו, הוא שולח לי אימיילים שאני משחק באש וכו.. ממש מפגר.

> On 10 Jun 2025, at 3:46 PM, shamir@midasholdings.com wrote:
> 
> מה מסכן אותך חוקית אם לא מחלק דיבידנד? 
> Best regards,
> 
> Eyal Shamir
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> Mobile +972-505636136
> 
>> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:37, ‏shamir@midasholdings.com כתב/ה:‬
>> 
>> ﻿
>> למה??
>> אמרתי לך לא לחלק עד שיחתום…
>> Best regards,
>> 
>> Eyal Shamir
>> Midas Corporation Ltd.
>> Mobile +972-505636136
>> 
>>> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:04, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬
>>> 
>>> ﻿
>>> כן. 
>>> 
>>>    Asaf Shamir
>>> m: 61417188345
>>> s: asaf-shamir
>>> 
>>> 
>>> On Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com <mailto:shamir@midasholdings.com>> wrote:
>>>> חילקת את הדיבידנד? 
>>>> Best regards,
>>>> 
>>>> Eyal Shamir
>>>> Midas Corporation Ltd.
>>>> Mobile +972-505636136
>>>> 
>>>>> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> כתב/ה:‬
>>>>> 
>>>>> ﻿
>>>> 
>>>>> הי אחי, 
>>>>> 
>>>>> השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Brad,
>>>>> 
>>>>> It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.
>>>>> 
>>>>> We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.
>>>>> 
>>>>> To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.
>>>>> 
>>>>> We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.
>>>>> 
>>>>> This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.
>>>>> 
>>>>> If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..
>>>>> 
>>>>> My preference is to work together to find a solution.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Regards,
>>>>> Asaf
>>>>> 
>>>>> 
>>>>>> On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Asaf
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Since the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:
>>>>>> to discuss your salary?
>>>>>> for a salary increase?
>>>>>> for a bonus?
>>>>>> to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?
>>>>>> Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everyday
>>>>>> and every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken an
>>>>>> unreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenue
>>>>>> of both companies.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)
>>>>>> and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> On Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> 1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation
>>>>>>> 2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed 
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> Thanks,
>>>>>>> Asaf
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> -- 
>>>>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> M:   +61-417-188345
>>>>>>> P:   +61-3-86582162
>>>>>>> www.rawmobility.com <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> I cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Eli
>>>>>>>> revise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that they
>>>>>>>> are not.
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> Brad
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?
>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>> On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> We cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send 
>>>>>>>>>>> me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to 
>>>>>>>>>>> just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>> --
>>>>>>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>>>>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>>>  <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>
>>>>>>>>> +61-417-188345
>>>>>>>>> +61-3-86582162
>>>>>>>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>>>>>>>  <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>>>>>

================================================================================
#56  2025-06-10T09:26:44+03:00
From:    shamir@midasholdings.com
To:      Shamir Asaf <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

לדעתי באופן שאתה מנסה לפתור את זה, יהיה מאוד קשה. גם בטלפון האחרון שלנו אמרתי לך שהוא לא יפסיק עד שיעיף אותך. אתה מנסה להיות איתו נחמד ו״בסדר״ והוא מצפצף עליך בגדול. אני מציע שעד שלא יחתום על הדוחות, נתק איתו קשר וסגור את המערכת. אם הוא פונה אליך, רק תגיב במייל - ״נא לחתום באופן מיידי על הדוחות״  אל תתקשר בשום צורה אחרת ובמקביל תחשוב להעביר את הכל לעסק אחר בבעלות 100% שלך.תתייעץ עם עורכי הדין שלך לגבי מה שאמרתי, אבל קח בחשבון שהם לוקחים אותך לסיבוב שלא לצורך Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:51, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿אחי,סיכמנו על חלוקת דיבידנד, אני לא אמור לעכב את זה. חלק מהטענות שלי כלפיו זה שהוא מעכב את הדיבידנד.ובלי שום קשר, כשאמרת לי לא לחלק הכסף עבר.אני עכשיו מסרב לשתף איתו פעולה כשהוא מנסה להציג אותי בתור עובד של החברה שלו, הוא שולח לי אימיילים שאני משחק באש וכו.. ממש מפגר.On 10 Jun 2025, at 3:46 PM, shamir@midasholdings.com wrote:מה מסכן אותך חוקית אם לא מחלק דיבידנד? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:37, ‏shamir@midasholdings.com כתב/ה:‬﻿למה??אמרתי לך לא לחלק עד שיחתום…Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:04, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿כן.    Asaf Shamirm: 61417188345s: asaf-shamirOn Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:חילקת את הדיבידנד? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿הי אחי, השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.Brad,It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..My preference is to work together to find a solution.Regards,Asaf

On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:AsafSince the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:to discuss your salary?for a salary increase?for a bonus?to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everydayand every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken anunreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenueof both companies.It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.BGGOn Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed Thanks,Asaf
-- Asaf  ShamirRaw MobilityM:   +61-417-188345P:   +61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafI cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Elirevise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that theyare not.ThanksBradOn Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafWe cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).ThanksBGG-- Asaf  ShamirRaw Mobility+61-417-188345+61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

================================================================================
#57  2025-06-10T16:58:22+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      shamir@midasholdings.com
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

אני אתקשר אליך בערב (שלי) אם אתה זמין.

   Asaf Shamir
m: 61417188345
s: asaf-shamir


On Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 16:27, <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:

> לדעתי באופן שאתה מנסה לפתור את זה, יהיה מאוד קשה.
> גם בטלפון האחרון שלנו אמרתי לך שהוא לא יפסיק עד שיעיף אותך.
> אתה מנסה להיות איתו נחמד ו״בסדר״ והוא מצפצף עליך בגדול.
> אני מציע שעד שלא יחתום על הדוחות, נתק איתו קשר וסגור את המערכת. אם הוא
> פונה אליך, רק תגיב במייל - ״נא לחתום באופן מיידי על הדוחות״  אל תתקשר בשום
> צורה אחרת ובמקביל תחשוב להעביר את הכל לעסק אחר בבעלות 100% שלך.
> תתייעץ עם עורכי הדין שלך לגבי מה שאמרתי, אבל קח בחשבון שהם לוקחים אותך
> לסיבוב שלא לצורך
> Best regards,
>
> Eyal Shamir
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> Mobile +972-505636136
>
> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:51, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬
>
> ﻿אחי,
>
>
> סיכמנו על חלוקת דיבידנד, אני לא אמור לעכב את זה. חלק מהטענות שלי כלפיו זה
> שהוא מעכב את הדיבידנד.
> ובלי שום קשר, כשאמרת לי לא לחלק הכסף עבר.
>
> אני עכשיו מסרב לשתף איתו פעולה כשהוא מנסה להציג אותי בתור עובד של החברה
> שלו, הוא שולח לי אימיילים שאני משחק באש וכו.. ממש מפגר.
>
> On 10 Jun 2025, at 3:46 PM, shamir@midasholdings.com wrote:
>
> מה מסכן אותך חוקית אם לא מחלק דיבידנד?
> Best regards,
>
> Eyal Shamir
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> Mobile +972-505636136
>
> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:37, ‏shamir@midasholdings.com כתב/ה:‬
>
> ﻿
> למה??
> אמרתי לך לא לחלק עד שיחתום…
> Best regards,
>
> Eyal Shamir
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> Mobile +972-505636136
>
> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:04, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬
>
> ﻿
> כן.
>
>    Asaf Shamir
> m: 61417188345
> s: asaf-shamir
>
>
> On Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:
>
>> חילקת את הדיבידנד?
>> Best regards,
>>
>> Eyal Shamir
>> Midas Corporation Ltd.
>> Mobile +972-505636136
>>
>> ‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬
>>
>> ﻿
>>
>> הי אחי,
>>
>> השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח
>> לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.
>>
>> Brad,
>>
>> It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of
>> faith, trust and confidence.
>>
>> We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident
>> director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with
>> you, which you are not prepared to do.
>>
>> To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our
>> differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation,
>> facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of
>> experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.
>>
>> We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and
>> you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re
>> not in Australia.
>>
>> This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd
>> party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.
>>
>> If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues
>> for resolving these disputes between us.
>>
>> Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail
>> to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday
>> (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice
>> in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to
>> oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the
>> courts..
>>
>> My preference is to work together to find a solution.
>>
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>>
>>
>> On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>
>> Asaf
>>
>> *Since the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate
>> you have asked me:*
>>
>>    1. to discuss your salary?
>>    2. for a salary increase?
>>    3. for a bonus?
>>    4. to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?
>>
>> Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I
>> am working everyday
>> and every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial
>> statements have taken an
>> unreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used
>> to increase revenue
>> of both companies.
>>
>> It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack
>> integrity (and neither should you)
>> and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will
>> forever remain unsigned.
>>
>> BGG
>>
>>
>>
>> On Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:
>>
>>> Brad,
>>>
>>> 1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence
>>> at this allegation
>>> 2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be
>>> changed
>>>
>>> Thanks,
>>> Asaf
>>>
>>> --
>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>> Raw Mobility
>>>
>>> M:   +61-417-188345
>>> P:   +61-3-86582162
>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>
>>> On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> Hi Asaf
>>>
>>> I cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I
>>> suggest that you and Eli
>>> revise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as
>>> something that they
>>> are not.
>>>
>>> Thanks
>>>
>>> Brad
>>>
>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:
>>>
>>>> Brad,
>>>>
>>>> Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.
>>>>
>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com>
>>>> wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>
>>>>> I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all
>>>>> transactions on the account.
>>>>>
>>>>> Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?
>>>>>
>>>>> On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>>
>>>>>> We cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can
>>>>>> you send
>>>>>> me the *bank statements of Raw Mobility* from *1 January 2015* until *31
>>>>>> May 2025*.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier
>>>>>> for you to
>>>>>> just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the
>>>>>> bank).
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>>
>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>> --
>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>>
>>>> <asaf@shamir.com.au>
>>>> +61-417-188345
>>>> +61-3-86582162
>>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>>
>>>
>>>
>>
>

================================================================================
#58  2025-06-10T10:03:23+03:00
From:    shamir@midasholdings.com
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend

אין בעיהBest regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 9:58, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿אני אתקשר אליך בערב (שלי) אם אתה זמין.    Asaf Shamirm: 61417188345s: asaf-shamirOn Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 16:27, <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:לדעתי באופן שאתה מנסה לפתור את זה, יהיה מאוד קשה. גם בטלפון האחרון שלנו אמרתי לך שהוא לא יפסיק עד שיעיף אותך. אתה מנסה להיות איתו נחמד ו״בסדר״ והוא מצפצף עליך בגדול. אני מציע שעד שלא יחתום על הדוחות, נתק איתו קשר וסגור את המערכת. אם הוא פונה אליך, רק תגיב במייל - ״נא לחתום באופן מיידי על הדוחות״  אל תתקשר בשום צורה אחרת ובמקביל תחשוב להעביר את הכל לעסק אחר בבעלות 100% שלך.תתייעץ עם עורכי הדין שלך לגבי מה שאמרתי, אבל קח בחשבון שהם לוקחים אותך לסיבוב שלא לצורך Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:51, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿אחי,סיכמנו על חלוקת דיבידנד, אני לא אמור לעכב את זה. חלק מהטענות שלי כלפיו זה שהוא מעכב את הדיבידנד.ובלי שום קשר, כשאמרת לי לא לחלק הכסף עבר.אני עכשיו מסרב לשתף איתו פעולה כשהוא מנסה להציג אותי בתור עובד של החברה שלו, הוא שולח לי אימיילים שאני משחק באש וכו.. ממש מפגר.On 10 Jun 2025, at 3:46 PM, shamir@midasholdings.com wrote:מה מסכן אותך חוקית אם לא מחלק דיבידנד? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:37, ‏shamir@midasholdings.com כתב/ה:‬﻿למה??אמרתי לך לא לחלק עד שיחתום…Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 8:04, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿כן.    Asaf Shamirm: 61417188345s: asaf-shamirOn Tue, 10 Jun 2025 at 15:03, <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:חילקת את הדיבידנד? Best regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-10 ביוני 2025, בשעה 6:29, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿הי אחי, השותף החמוד שלי עדיין לא מוכן לחתום על המסמכים למס הכנסה. אני הולך לשלוח לו את האימייל הבא - אודה לך אם תוכל לתת קצת הערות.Brad,It appears this commercial relationship is severely impacted by lack of faith, trust and confidence.We are essentially at a stalemate, and because I’m the sole resident director in Australia - I need to sign off on these accounts jointly with you, which you are not prepared to do.To move forward, I propose we engage in mediation to help resolve our differences. To that end, I invite you to participate in a mediation, facilitated by a mutually agreed-upon barrister with at least 15 years of experience in shareholder/partnership disputes.We would both be free to involve legal representatives if desired, and you could obviously participate remotely to accommodate for the fact you’re not in Australia.This offer is being extended in a genuine attempt to try and have a 3rd party help us resolve outstanding disputes between us.If you fail to take up this offer, I invite you to propose other avenues for resolving these disputes between us.Other than simply repeating questions you’ve already raised, if you fail to comply with what I think is a reasonable request by 5pm next Tuesday (17/June), you will leave me with no alternative but to seek legal advice in respect of which I believe your actions are likely to amount to oppressive conduct requiring me to pursue a resolution through the courts..My preference is to work together to find a solution.Regards,Asaf

On 5 Jun 2025, at 7:48 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:AsafSince the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:to discuss your salary?for a salary increase?for a bonus?to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everydayand every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken anunreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenueof both companies.It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.BGGOn Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed Thanks,Asaf
-- Asaf  ShamirRaw MobilityM:   +61-417-188345P:   +61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafI cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Elirevise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that theyare not.ThanksBradOn Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com> wrote:Brad,I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:Hi AsafWe cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).ThanksBGG-- Asaf  ShamirRaw Mobility+61-417-188345+61-3-86582162www.rawmobility.com

================================================================================
#59  2025-06-10T23:34:48+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>
Subject: Re: Confirm account details for dividend

Hi Jeremy,

I hope all is well on your end.
I still haven’t sent Brad the email, but I did receive additional advice (from my brother) and I’d like to ask you a couple of questions.

If you have 10 minutes tomorrow (Wednesday), please let me know so we can have a chat.

Thanks,
Asaf

> On 6 Jun 2025, at 11:46 AM, Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
> 
> Good morning Jeremy,
> 
> Just wondering if you received the email below?
> 
> Thanks in advance,
> Asaf
> 
>> On 5 Jun 2025, at 9:29 AM, Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>> 
>> Good morning Jeremy,
>> 
>> I hope all is well on your end.
>> 
>> We have completed the payment of dividends.
>> Brad is still refusing to sign off on the finances of Raw Mobility
>> I requested that he clarifies what he wants changed, but received no coherent response (see below)
>> 
>> Please let me know when you have some time to discuss my options for response and progress. I’ll adjust to meet your availability.
>> 
>> Thanks in advance,
>> Asaf
>> 
>>> Begin forwarded message:
>>> 
>>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>>> Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: Confirm account details for dividend
>>> Date: 5 June 2025 at 7:48:22 am AEST
>>> To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com>
>>> Cc: Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>
>>> 
>>> Asaf
>>> 
>>> Since the inception of Raw Mobility, how many times would you estimate you have asked me:
>>> to discuss your salary?
>>> for a salary increase?
>>> for a bonus?
>>> to discuss the salary of Vadeesh Acharya?
>>> Please let me know as soon as possible but please also understand that I am working everyday
>>> and every night to grow Mobivate and Raw Mobility and these financial statements have taken an
>>> unreasonable amount of my time and is wasting my time which could be used to increase revenue
>>> of both companies.
>>> 
>>> It is very simple. I will not sign off on financial statements that lack integrity (and neither should you)
>>> and I do not care how long it takes. Either they get fixed up or will forever remain unsigned.
>>> 
>>> BGG
>>> 
>>> 
>>> 
>>> On Wed, Jun 4, 2025 at 1:31 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> 1. I refute the assertion that expenses are disguised and take offence at this allegation
>>>> 2. Please provide clarify regarding what exactly you think should be changed 
>>>> 
>>>> Thanks,
>>>> Asaf
>>>> 
>>>> -- 
>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>> 
>>>> M:   +61-417-188345
>>>> P:   +61-3-86582162
>>>> www.rawmobility.com <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>>>> 
>>>>> On 3 Jun 2025, at 7:41 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>> 
>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>> 
>>>>> I cannot sign off on financial statements that lack integrity so I suggest that you and Eli
>>>>> revise them and stop disguising expenses and displaying them as something that they
>>>>> are not.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Thanks
>>>>> 
>>>>> Brad
>>>>> 
>>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 1:43 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> Please finalize signing the financial reports for last year.
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> On Mon, Jun 2, 2025 at 10:25 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@rawmobility.com <mailto:asaf@rawmobility.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>> Brad,
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> I provided you with access to Saasu, which has access to all transactions on the account.
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> Does that not provide you with sufficient visibility?
>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>> On Thu, May 29, 2025 at 9:35 PM bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> We cannot reconcile the dividends in Marlau, so next week, please can you send 
>>>>>>>> me the bank statements of Raw Mobility from 1 January 2015 until 31 May 2025.
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> I have from 14 December 2023 to 14 March 2025 but it may be easier for you to 
>>>>>>>> just get me all in one go (you may need to request them from the bank).
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> BGG
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> 
>>>>>> --
>>>>>> Asaf  Shamir
>>>>>> Raw Mobility
>>>>>> 
>>>>>>  <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>
>>>>>> +61-417-188345
>>>>>> +61-3-86582162
>>>>>> www.rawmobility.com
>>>>>>  <http://www.rawmobility.com/>
>> 
>

================================================================================
#60  2025-06-12T06:24:35+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not
responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
$159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?

Please can you respond straight away.

Thank you

Brad

On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:

> Hi Eli
>
>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>
>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>    thanks for clarifying that it is a
>
> *License Fee *
>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>
>    July - 12,936.00
>    Aug - 12,936.00
>    Sep - 12,936.00
>    Oct - 12,936.00
>    Nov - 12,936.00
>    Dec - 13,607.00
>    Jan - 13,607.00
>    Feb - 13,607.00
>    Mar - 13,607.00
>    Apr - 13,607.00
>    May - 13,607.00
>    June - 13,607.00
>
> Thanks
>
> Brad
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli
>>
>>
>>
>> I hope you are well.
>>
>>
>>
>> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>
>> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>> *Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a
>> lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?*
>>
>>
>>
>> *If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.*
>>
>> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>> software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
>>
>> *I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:*
>>
>> *As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
>> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.*
>>
>> *On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:*
>>
>> *Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec
>> 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in
>> addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for
>> contractor expenses ** incurred.*
>>
>> Now you are both telling me this is *NOT* Asaf's remuneration but in
>> fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to
>> Raw Mobility. *Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?*
>>
>> *Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.
>> To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and
>> reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir
>> Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor*
>>
>> *In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:*
>>
>> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93
>> ($105,169 ex GST)?
>>
>> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your
>> allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will
>> review and come back to you
>>
>> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
>> ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number
>> so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
>>
>> *I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June
>> 2024.*
>>
>> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation
>> in Sassu file
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>>
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>>
>> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
>> *To:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>;
>> Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)
>>
>>
>>
>> Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in *RED* below.
>>
>>
>>
>>    1. Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>    Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf
>>    to confirm
>>    Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>>    2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>>    software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I
>>    understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate
>>    and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>>    Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement,
>>    which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf.
>>    Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to
>>    $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments
>>    contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf.  Based on my brief
>>    review of previous correspondence, I don’t see any contradiction. In any
>>    case, my understanding is as per my email of 9/5 which Asaf has
>>    subsequently confirmed to be consistent with his understanding.
>>    3. Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open
>>    Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset
>>    is @ cost.
>>    Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer
>>    Shamir Holdings? This is a commercial issue between you and Asaf
>>    Surely arms length transactions (usually documented in the rules of
>>    transfer pricing) are essential when 2 Australian companies have the
>>    identical Director/UBO's? I don’t see a transfer pricing issue.
>>    Rather, there is a commercial agreement in place which looks to have been
>>    in place for quite some time.  If not documented, you and Asaf can agree to
>>    do so.  Likewise, the same should hold true for fees Raw Mobility charges
>>    Mobivate.
>>    Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf
>>    to confirm.
>>    Is it fair to say that Shamir Holdings has one or more customers that
>>    utilise and pay Shamir Holdings for the delivery of bulk SMS messages? Asaf
>>    to confirm
>>    4. Shamir Holdings employees a staff member and on-charges the staff
>>    member’s remuneration for any work performed for Raw Mobility to Raw
>>    Mobility.  In the financial statements, amounts on-charged have been
>>    recognised in the ‘Open Model Licence Fee’ expense line item.  We can
>>    certainly include the on-charging of the employee’s salary as a separate
>>    line item for clarity.
>>    Eli, are you happy with the Man Accs / F/S's calling it an Open Model
>>    License Fee when in fact a part of it has nothing to do with 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#61  2025-06-12T06:13:30+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad

The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings.

We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.

Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.

I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
$159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?

Please can you respond straight away.

Thank you

Brad

On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
Hi Eli

  1.  Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
  2.  Not sure what is poorly worded about "remunerations to Asaf" but thanks for clarifying that it is a License Fee
  3.  R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:

July - 12,936.00
Aug - 12,936.00
Sep - 12,936.00
Oct - 12,936.00
Nov - 12,936.00
Dec - 13,607.00
Jan - 13,607.00
Feb - 13,607.00
Mar - 13,607.00
Apr - 13,607.00
May - 13,607.00
June - 13,607.00
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well.

Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?

If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.
2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:
Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for contractor expenses  incurred.
Now you are both telling me this is NOT Asaf's remuneration but in fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw Mobility. Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?
Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor
In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:
How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?
I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will review and come back to you
In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.
Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in Sassu file
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Cc: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au<mailto:Alia@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)

Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in RED below.


  1.  Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf to confirm
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
  2.  Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement, which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf. Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf.  Based on my brief review of previous correspondence, I don’t see any contradiction. In any case, my understanding is as per my email of 9/5 which Asaf has subsequently confirmed to be consistent with his understanding.
  3.  Invoices rendered by Shamir Holdings to Raw Mobility for Open Model Licence Fees are reduced by sms’ purchased from Raw Mobility.  Offset is @ cost.
Why would Raw Mobility not mark up the SMS costs to its customer Shamir Holdings? This is a commercial issue between you and Asaf
Surely arms length transactions (usually documented in the rules of transfer pricing) are essential when 2 Australian companies have the identical Director/UBO's? I don’t see a transfer pricing issue.  Rather, there is a commercial agreement in place which looks to have been in place for quite some time.  If not documented, you and Asaf can agree to do so.  Likewise, the same should hold true 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#62  2025-06-12T07:30:00+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to
Shamir Holdings?

Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as
an R&D fee in the bank statement?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Brad
>
>
>
> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to
> Shamir Holdings.
>
>
>
> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these
> expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>
>
>
> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to
> reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial
> statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>
>
>
> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw
> Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not
> responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
>
> $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>
>
>
> Please can you respond straight away.
>
>
>
> Thank you
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Eli
>
>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>    thanks for clarifying that it is a *License Fee*
>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>
>    July - 12,936.00
>    Aug - 12,936.00
>    Sep - 12,936.00
>    Oct - 12,936.00
>    Nov - 12,936.00
>    Dec - 13,607.00
>    Jan - 13,607.00
>    Feb - 13,607.00
>    Mar - 13,607.00
>    Apr - 13,607.00
>    May - 13,607.00
>    June - 13,607.00
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well.
>
>
>
> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>
> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
> *Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a
> lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?*
>
>
>
> *If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.*
>
> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
> software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
>
> *I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:*
>
> *As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.*
>
> *On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:*
>
> *Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec
> 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in
> addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for
> contractor expenses ** incurred.*
>
> Now you are both telling me this is *NOT* Asaf's remuneration but in fact
> a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw
> Mobility. *Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?*
>
> *Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To
> be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and
> reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir
> Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor*
>
> *In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:*
>
> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93
> ($105,169 ex GST)?
>
> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your
> allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will
> review and come back to you
>
> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
> ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number
> so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
>
> *I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.*
>
> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in
> Sassu file
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
> *To:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
> *Cc:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au>;
> Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)
>
>
>
> Thank you for confirming Asaf. Please see my comments in *RED* below.
>
>
>
>    1. Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>    Is there an Agreement in this regard? If so, please send it to me. Asaf
>    to confirm
>    Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>    2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
>    software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  I
>    understand that the Open Model Licence Fees relate to IP which is separate
>    and distinct from IP owned by Raw Mobility.
>    Surprised to hear that both of you have agreed to this statement,
>    which completely contradicts previous emails sent by Vincent and Asaf.
>    Having said that, how do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to
>    $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)? Please explain how my comments
>    contradict previous statements made by Vincent and Asaf.  Based on my brief
>    review of previous correspondence, I don’t see any contradiction. In any
>    case, my understanding is as per my email of 9/5 which Asaf has
>    subsequently confirmed to be consistent with his understanding.
>    3. Invoices rendered 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#63  2025-06-12T08:00:18+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad

I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as contracting services.

I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.

In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings?

Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as an R&D fee in the bank statement?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad

The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings.

We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.

Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.

I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
$159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?

Please can you respond straight away.

Thank you

Brad

On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
Hi Eli

  1.  Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
  2.  Not sure what is poorly worded about "remunerations to Asaf" but thanks for clarifying that it is a License Fee
  3.  R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:

July - 12,936.00
Aug - 12,936.00
Sep - 12,936.00
Oct - 12,936.00
Nov - 12,936.00
Dec - 13,607.00
Jan - 13,607.00
Feb - 13,607.00
Mar - 13,607.00
Apr - 13,607.00
May - 13,607.00
June - 13,607.00
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well.

Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?

If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.
2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:
Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for contractor expenses  incurred.
Now you are both telling me this is NOT Asaf's remuneration but in fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw Mobility. Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?
Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor
In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:
How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?
I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will review and come back to you
In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.
Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in Sassu file
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Sunday, 11 May 2025 9:38 PM
To: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>
Cc: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>; Karen Monohan <Karen@gsca.com.au<mailto:Karen@gsca.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>; Alia Sargent <Alia@gsca.com.au<mailto:Alia@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli & Asaf (and team)

Thank you for confirming A

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#64  2025-06-13T08:36:54+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Good morning Eli,

For whatever it's worth - the bank statements show "R&D/Support Contractor”.

￼

> On 12 Jun 2025, at 6:00 pm, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
> 
> Brad
>  
> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as contracting services.
>  
> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>  
> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>  
> Regards,
>  
> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>  
> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>  
> Hi Eli
>  
> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings?
>  
> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>  
> Thanks
>  
> Brad
>  
> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
> Brad
>  
> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings.
>  
> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>  
> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>  
> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>  
> Regards,
>  
> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>  
> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
> Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>  
> Hi Eli
>  
> I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not responded to my question regarding R&D payments of 
> $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>  
> Please can you respond straight away. 
>  
> Thank you
>  
> Brad
>  
> On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
> Hi Eli
> Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
> Not sure what is poorly worded about "remunerations to Asaf" but thanks for clarifying that it is a License Fee
> R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:
> 
> July - 12,936.00 
> Aug - 12,936.00 
> Sep - 12,936.00 
> Oct - 12,936.00 
> Nov - 12,936.00 
> Dec - 13,607.00 
> Jan - 13,607.00 
> Feb - 13,607.00 
> Mar - 13,607.00 
> Apr - 13,607.00 
> May - 13,607.00 
> June - 13,607.00 
> Thanks
>  
> Brad
>  
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>  
> Regards,
>  
> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>  
> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
> Sent: Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>  
> Hi Eli
>  
> I hope you are well.
>  
> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
> Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?
>  
> If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.
> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  
> I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:
> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
> On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:
> Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for contractor expenses  incurred.
> Now you are both telling me this is NOT Asaf's remuneration but in fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw Mobility. Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?
> Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor
> In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:
> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?
> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will review and come back to you
> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
> I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.
> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in Sassu file
> Thanks
>  
> Brad
>  
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>  
> Regards,
>  
> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKhM5YaBWTwnuWRwV?h=Ffy_XiJHVDM0Wgz__0kV2Er1DskGUbX1F2s6RALrSHw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>  
> From: b

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#65  2025-06-12T23:11:07+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

noted

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Sent: Friday, 13 June 2025 8:37 AM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc: Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Good morning Eli,

For whatever it's worth - the bank statements show "R&D/Support Contractor”.

[cid:image001.png@01DBDC43.1774ED20]


On 12 Jun 2025, at 6:00 pm, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:

Brad

I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as contracting services.

I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.

In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tGNgDWJ5smvLZdt4?h=cHExTFJ82OmKXo68ES5zL3tazaY0hZX_rp_lhLKGgIg=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings?

Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as an R&D fee in the bank statement?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad

The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings.

We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.

Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.

I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
$159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?

Please can you respond straight away.

Thank you

Brad

On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
Hi Eli

  1.  Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
  2.  Not sure what is poorly worded about "remunerations to Asaf" but thanks for clarifying that it is a License Fee
  3.  R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:

July - 12,936.00
Aug - 12,936.00
Sep - 12,936.00
Oct - 12,936.00
Nov - 12,936.00
Dec - 13,607.00
Jan - 13,607.00
Feb - 13,607.00
Mar - 13,607.00
Apr - 13,607.00
May - 13,607.00
June - 13,607.00
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well.

Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?

If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.
2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:
Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for contractor expenses  incurred.
Now you are both telling me this is NOT Asaf's remuneration but in fact a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw Mobility. Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?
Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor
In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:
How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93 ($105,169 ex GST)?
I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will review and come back to you
In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.
Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in Sassu file
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please ref

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#66  2025-06-16T14:59:02+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Email to Brad

הי אחי,

מקווה שאתם מחזיקים מעמד בטירוף הטילים.

דיברתי עם העורך דין שלי..
1. אין לו בעיה שתשלח לו אימייל - תרגמתי לאנגלית (למטה), תעבור על זה אם אתה
יכול ותשלח. אולי דבר איתי לפני.
2. ההמלצה שלו זה לנסות ולהכריח אותו לחתום דרך בית משפט, כי נראה לו שבראד
סתם מקשקש ומושך זמן.

אנסה לתפוס אותך יותר מאוחר היום.


A week ago, you approved and received your share (82%) of a $1.9 million
dividend - a significant sum.


Common sense dictates that if you had any concerns about the financial
reports, you - as a majority shareholder in the company - should have
deferred the dividend approval until the reports were finalized.

Your conduct within the company, toward Asaf, and in failing to report to
the tax authorities as required, at the very least, demonstrates a lack of
good faith toward Asaf and other stakeholders.


Unlike you, who conceals your activities, involvement, and control of the
company behind questionable tax structures, Asaf is an Australian citizen
who reports his income in Australia, pays taxes there, and has nothing to
hide from you or the Australian tax authorities.


Should you choose not to sign the financial reports, that is solely your
decision, driven by what seem to be questionable motives.

We have no intention of continuing to engage in conflict with you over this
matter. However, if the financial reports remain unsigned, the company may
face an investigation by the Australian tax authorities.


As a law-abiding citizen, Asaf will fully cooperate and provide all
required information in accordance with the law. You will bear sole
responsibility for any consequences that may arise for you or related
parties from the Australian tax authorities.


I am surprised that, instead of allowing Asaf to focus on his work and
maximize returns for the company and its shareholders, you persistently
harass him over matters for which you are solely responsible, driven by
motives unrelated to me.

-- 
   Asaf Shamir
m: 61417188345
s: asaf-shamir

================================================================================
#67  2025-06-16T11:45:33+03:00
From:    Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: Email to Brad

בוקר טוב,
אין בעיה.
שלח לי את מה שהקלדת בעברית כשדיברנו, לראות אולי משהו נשמט.
בלי קשר, הנוסח טיפה חלבי לטעמי, אבל איך שמרגיש לך נכון זה בסדר.
הוא יבין את המסר

On Mon, Jun 16, 2025 at 7:59 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:

> הי אחי,
>
> מקווה שאתם מחזיקים מעמד בטירוף הטילים.
>
> דיברתי עם העורך דין שלי..
> 1. אין לו בעיה שתשלח לו אימייל - תרגמתי לאנגלית (למטה), תעבור על זה אם אתה
> יכול ותשלח. אולי דבר איתי לפני.
> 2. ההמלצה שלו זה לנסות ולהכריח אותו לחתום דרך בית משפט, כי נראה לו שבראד
> סתם מקשקש ומושך זמן.
>
> אנסה לתפוס אותך יותר מאוחר היום.
>
>
> A week ago, you approved and received your share (82%) of a $1.9 million
> dividend - a significant sum.
>
>
> Common sense dictates that if you had any concerns about the financial
> reports, you - as a majority shareholder in the company - should have
> deferred the dividend approval until the reports were finalized.
>
> Your conduct within the company, toward Asaf, and in failing to report to
> the tax authorities as required, at the very least, demonstrates a lack of
> good faith toward Asaf and other stakeholders.
>
>
> Unlike you, who conceals your activities, involvement, and control of the
> company behind questionable tax structures, Asaf is an Australian citizen
> who reports his income in Australia, pays taxes there, and has nothing to
> hide from you or the Australian tax authorities.
>
>
> Should you choose not to sign the financial reports, that is solely your
> decision, driven by what seem to be questionable motives.
>
> We have no intention of continuing to engage in conflict with you over
> this matter. However, if the financial reports remain unsigned, the company
> may face an investigation by the Australian tax authorities.
>
>
> As a law-abiding citizen, Asaf will fully cooperate and provide all
> required information in accordance with the law. You will bear sole
> responsibility for any consequences that may arise for you or related
> parties from the Australian tax authorities.
>
>
> I am surprised that, instead of allowing Asaf to focus on his work and
> maximize returns for the company and its shareholders, you persistently
> harass him over matters for which you are solely responsible, driven by
> motives unrelated to me.
>
> --
>    Asaf Shamir
> m: 61417188345
> s: asaf-shamir
>


-- 
Best Regards,

Eyal Shamir,
Managing Director

Midas Corporation Ltd.

Office:  +972-3-6447372
Mobile: +972-505-636136
Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com

================================================================================
#68  2025-06-16T18:47:40+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: Email to Brad

אחי,

הנה מה שהקראת לי:


לפני שבוע אישרת וקובלת את חלקך בדיבידנד של 1.9 מליון דולר - סכום מהותי.
ככל שהיו לך טענות לגבי הדוחות הכספיים, השכל הישר אומר שהיית צריך לדחות את אישור הדיבידנד עד לאחר אישור הדוחות

התנהלוכה הנלוזה בחברה ומולי ומניעת הדיווח לרשויות המס כנדרש לכל הפחות מעידה על חוסר תום לב כלפי וכלפי צדדים נוספים

שלא כמוך - שמסתיר את פעילותו, מעורבותו ושליטתו בחברה מאחורי מבני מס מפוקפקים, אני אזרח אוסטרלי שמדווח על הכנסותיו באוסטרליה ומשלם  את מיסיו באוסטרליה אין לי שום דבר להסתיר ממך או מרשויות המס באוסטרליה.

ככל שאתה תחליט שאין ברצונך לחתום על הדוחות הכספיים זהו שיקול בלעדי שלך והוא מונע ממניעים פסולים כאלה ואחרים.

אין בכוונתי להמשיך להתעמת איתך בעניין הנ״ל.
ככל שהדוחות הכספיים לא ייחתמו, ייתכן ותיפתח כנגד החברה חקירה ברשויות המס באוסטרליה, ואני כמובן כאזרח שומר חוק אשתף פעולה ואמסור את כל המידע הנדרש על פי חוק. ואתה תישא בבלעדיות בכל ההשלכות שעלולות להתגלע כלפיך וכלפי צדדים הקשורים עמך על ידי רשויות המס באוסטרליה.

אני מתפלא שבמקום לתת לי להמשיך לעבוד ולהשיא את התשואה שלי לחברה ולבעלי המניות, אתה בוחר להמשיך ולהטריד אותי באופן קבוע בעניינים שאתה אחראי להם בלעדית ממניעים שלא קשורים אלי.


> On 16 Jun 2025, at 6:45 PM, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:
> 
> בוקר טוב,
> אין בעיה.
> שלח לי את מה שהקלדת בעברית כשדיברנו, לראות אולי משהו נשמט.
> בלי קשר, הנוסח טיפה חלבי לטעמי, אבל איך שמרגיש לך נכון זה בסדר.
> הוא יבין את המסר
> 
> On Mon, Jun 16, 2025 at 7:59 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> הי אחי,
>> 
>> מקווה שאתם מחזיקים מעמד בטירוף הטילים.
>> 
>> דיברתי עם העורך דין שלי.. 
>> 1. אין לו בעיה שתשלח לו אימייל - תרגמתי לאנגלית (למטה), תעבור על זה אם אתה יכול ותשלח. אולי דבר איתי לפני.
>> 2. ההמלצה שלו זה לנסות ולהכריח אותו לחתום דרך בית משפט, כי נראה לו שבראד סתם מקשקש ומושך זמן.
>> 
>> אנסה לתפוס אותך יותר מאוחר היום.
>> 
>> 
>> A week ago, you approved and received your share (82%) of a $1.9 million dividend - a significant sum. 
>> 
>> Common sense dictates that if you had any concerns about the financial reports, you - as a majority shareholder in the company - should have deferred the dividend approval until the reports were finalized.
>> Your conduct within the company, toward Asaf, and in failing to report to the tax authorities as required, at the very least, demonstrates a lack of good faith toward Asaf and other stakeholders.
>> 
>> Unlike you, who conceals your activities, involvement, and control of the company behind questionable tax structures, Asaf is an Australian citizen who reports his income in Australia, pays taxes there, and has nothing to hide from you or the Australian tax authorities.
>> 
>> Should you choose not to sign the financial reports, that is solely your decision, driven by what seem to be questionable motives. 
>> We have no intention of continuing to engage in conflict with you over this matter. However, if the financial reports remain unsigned, the company may face an investigation by the Australian tax authorities. 
>> 
>> As a law-abiding citizen, Asaf will fully cooperate and provide all required information in accordance with the law. You will bear sole responsibility for any consequences that may arise for you or related parties from the Australian tax authorities.
>> 
>> I am surprised that, instead of allowing Asaf to focus on his work and maximize returns for the company and its shareholders, you persistently harass him over matters for which you are solely responsible, driven by motives unrelated to me.
>> 
>> --
>>    Asaf Shamir
>> m: 61417188345
>> s: asaf-shamir
> 
> 
> 
> --
> Best Regards,
> 
> Eyal Shamir, 
> Managing Director
>  
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> 
> Office:  +972-3-6447372
> Mobile: +972-505-636136
> Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com <mailto:shamir@midasholdings.com>

================================================================================
#69  2025-06-16T18:55:17+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: Email to Brad

אני אתקשר אליך עוד שעה

> On 16 Jun 2025, at 6:47 PM, Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
> 
> אחי,
> 
> הנה מה שהקראת לי:
> 
> 
> לפני שבוע אישרת וקובלת את חלקך בדיבידנד של 1.9 מליון דולר - סכום מהותי.
> ככל שהיו לך טענות לגבי הדוחות הכספיים, השכל הישר אומר שהיית צריך לדחות את אישור הדיבידנד עד לאחר אישור הדוחות
> 
> התנהלוכה הנלוזה בחברה ומולי ומניעת הדיווח לרשויות המס כנדרש לכל הפחות מעידה על חוסר תום לב כלפי וכלפי צדדים נוספים
> 
> שלא כמוך - שמסתיר את פעילותו, מעורבותו ושליטתו בחברה מאחורי מבני מס מפוקפקים, אני אזרח אוסטרלי שמדווח על הכנסותיו באוסטרליה ומשלם  את מיסיו באוסטרליה אין לי שום דבר להסתיר ממך או מרשויות המס באוסטרליה.
> 
> ככל שאתה תחליט שאין ברצונך לחתום על הדוחות הכספיים זהו שיקול בלעדי שלך והוא מונע ממניעים פסולים כאלה ואחרים.
> 
> אין בכוונתי להמשיך להתעמת איתך בעניין הנ״ל.
> ככל שהדוחות הכספיים לא ייחתמו, ייתכן ותיפתח כנגד החברה חקירה ברשויות המס באוסטרליה, ואני כמובן כאזרח שומר חוק אשתף פעולה ואמסור את כל המידע הנדרש על פי חוק. ואתה תישא בבלעדיות בכל ההשלכות שעלולות להתגלע כלפיך וכלפי צדדים הקשורים עמך על ידי רשויות המס באוסטרליה.
> 
> אני מתפלא שבמקום לתת לי להמשיך לעבוד ולהשיא את התשואה שלי לחברה ולבעלי המניות, אתה בוחר להמשיך ולהטריד אותי באופן קבוע בעניינים שאתה אחראי להם בלעדית ממניעים שלא קשורים אלי.
> 
> 
>> On 16 Jun 2025, at 6:45 PM, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:
>> 
>> בוקר טוב,
>> אין בעיה.
>> שלח לי את מה שהקלדת בעברית כשדיברנו, לראות אולי משהו נשמט.
>> בלי קשר, הנוסח טיפה חלבי לטעמי, אבל איך שמרגיש לך נכון זה בסדר.
>> הוא יבין את המסר
>> 
>> On Mon, Jun 16, 2025 at 7:59 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>>> הי אחי,
>>> 
>>> מקווה שאתם מחזיקים מעמד בטירוף הטילים.
>>> 
>>> דיברתי עם העורך דין שלי.. 
>>> 1. אין לו בעיה שתשלח לו אימייל - תרגמתי לאנגלית (למטה), תעבור על זה אם אתה יכול ותשלח. אולי דבר איתי לפני.
>>> 2. ההמלצה שלו זה לנסות ולהכריח אותו לחתום דרך בית משפט, כי נראה לו שבראד סתם מקשקש ומושך זמן.
>>> 
>>> אנסה לתפוס אותך יותר מאוחר היום.
>>> 
>>> 
>>> A week ago, you approved and received your share (82%) of a $1.9 million dividend - a significant sum. 
>>> 
>>> Common sense dictates that if you had any concerns about the financial reports, you - as a majority shareholder in the company - should have deferred the dividend approval until the reports were finalized.
>>> Your conduct within the company, toward Asaf, and in failing to report to the tax authorities as required, at the very least, demonstrates a lack of good faith toward Asaf and other stakeholders.
>>> 
>>> Unlike you, who conceals your activities, involvement, and control of the company behind questionable tax structures, Asaf is an Australian citizen who reports his income in Australia, pays taxes there, and has nothing to hide from you or the Australian tax authorities.
>>> 
>>> Should you choose not to sign the financial reports, that is solely your decision, driven by what seem to be questionable motives. 
>>> We have no intention of continuing to engage in conflict with you over this matter. However, if the financial reports remain unsigned, the company may face an investigation by the Australian tax authorities. 
>>> 
>>> As a law-abiding citizen, Asaf will fully cooperate and provide all required information in accordance with the law. You will bear sole responsibility for any consequences that may arise for you or related parties from the Australian tax authorities.
>>> 
>>> I am surprised that, instead of allowing Asaf to focus on his work and maximize returns for the company and its shareholders, you persistently harass him over matters for which you are solely responsible, driven by motives unrelated to me.
>>> 
>>> --
>>>    Asaf Shamir
>>> m: 61417188345
>>> s: asaf-shamir
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> --
>> Best Regards,
>> 
>> Eyal Shamir, 
>> Managing Director
>>  
>> Midas Corporation Ltd.
>> 
>> Office:  +972-3-6447372
>> Mobile: +972-505-636136
>> Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com <mailto:shamir@midasholdings.com>

================================================================================
#70  2025-06-16T11:57:09+03:00
From:    Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: Email to Brad

מציע להוסיף את הממורקר. לשיקולך

On Mon, Jun 16, 2025 at 11:47 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:

> אחי,
>
> הנה מה שהקראת לי:
>
>
> לפני שבוע אישרת וקובלת את חלקך בדיבידנד של 1.9 מליון דולר - סכום מהותי.
>
> ככל שהיו לך טענות לגבי הדוחות הכספיים, השכל הישר אומר שהיית צריך לדחות את
> אישור הדיבידנד עד לאחר אישור הדוחות
>
>
> התנהלוכה הנלוזה בחברה ומולי ומניעת הדיווח לרשויות המס כנדרש לכל הפחות
> מעידה על חוסר תום לב כלפי וכלפי צדדים נוספים
>
>
> שלא כמוך - שמסתיר את פעילותו, מעורבותו ושליטתו בחברה מאחורי מבני מס
> מפוקפקים, אני אזרח אוסטרלי שמדווח על הכנסותיו באוסטרליה ומשלם  את מיסיו
> באוסטרליה אין לי שום דבר להסתיר ממך או מרשויות המס באוסטרליה.
>
>
> ככל שאתה תחליט שאין ברצונך לחתום על הדוחות הכספיים זהו שיקול בלעדי שלך
> והוא מונע ממניעים פסולים כאלה ואחרים.
>
>
> אין בכוונתי להמשיך להתעמת איתך בעניין הנ״ל.
>
> ככל שהדוחות הכספיים לא ייחתמו, ייתכן ותיפתח כנגד החברה חקירה ברשויות המס
> באוסטרליה, ואני כמובן כאזרח שומר חוק אשתף פעולה ואמסור את כל המידע הנדרש על
> פי חוק. ואתה תישא בבלעדיות בכל ההשלכות שעלולות להתגלע כלפיך וכלפי צדדים
> הקשורים עמך על ידי רשויות המס באוסטרליה.
>
>
> אני מתפלא שבמקום לתת לי להמשיך לעבוד ולהשיא את התשואה שלי לחברה ולבעלי
> המניות, אתה בוחר להמשיך ולהטריד אותי באופן קבוע בעניינים שאתה אחראי להם
> בלעדית ממניעים שלא קשורים אלי.
>
>
>
> On 16 Jun 2025, at 6:45 PM, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:
>
> בוקר טוב,
> אין בעיה.
> שלח לי את מה שהקלדת בעברית כשדיברנו, לראות אולי משהו נשמט.
> בלי קשר, הנוסח טיפה חלבי לטעמי, אבל איך שמרגיש לך נכון זה בסדר.
> הוא יבין את המסר
>
> On Mon, Jun 16, 2025 at 7:59 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
>> הי אחי,
>>
>> מקווה שאתם מחזיקים מעמד בטירוף הטילים.
>>
>> דיברתי עם העורך דין שלי..
>> 1. אין לו בעיה שתשלח לו אימייל - תרגמתי לאנגלית (למטה), תעבור על זה אם
>> אתה יכול ותשלח. אולי דבר איתי לפני.
>> 2. ההמלצה שלו זה לנסות ולהכריח אותו לחתום דרך בית משפט, כי נראה לו שבראד
>> סתם מקשקש ומושך זמן.
>>
>> אנסה לתפוס אותך יותר מאוחר היום.
>>
>>
>> A week ago, you approved and received your share (82%) of a $1.9 million
>> dividend - a significant sum.
>>
>> Common sense dictates that if you had any concerns about the financial
>> reports, you - as a majority shareholder in the company - should have
>> deferred the dividend approval until the reports were finalized.
>> Your conduct within the company, toward Asaf, and in failing to report to
>> the tax authorities as required, at the very least, demonstrates a lack of
>> good faith toward Asaf and other stakeholders.
>>
>> Unlike you, who conceals your activities, involvement, and control of the
>> company behind questionable tax structures, Asaf is an Australian citizen
>> who reports his income in Australia, pays taxes there, and has nothing to
>> hide from you or the Australian tax authorities.
>>
>> Should you choose not to sign the financial reports, that is solely your
>> decision, driven by what seem to be questionable motives.
>> We have no intention of continuing to engage in conflict with you over
>> this matter. However, if the financial reports remain unsigned, the company
>> may face an investigation by the Australian tax authorities.
>>
>> As a law-abiding citizen, Asaf will fully cooperate and provide all
>> required information in accordance with the law. You will bear sole
>> responsibility for any consequences that may arise for you or related
>> parties from the Australian tax authorities.
>>
>> I am surprised that, instead of allowing Asaf to focus on his work and
>> maximize returns for the company and its shareholders, you persistently
>> harass him over matters for which you are solely responsible, driven by
>> motives unrelated to me.
>>
>> --
>>    Asaf Shamir
>> m: 61417188345
>> s: asaf-shamir
>>
>
>
> --
> Best Regards,
>
> Eyal Shamir,
> Managing Director
>
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
>
> Office:  +972-3-6447372
> Mobile: +972-505-636136
> Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com
>
>
>

-- 
Best Regards,

Eyal Shamir,
Managing Director

Midas Corporation Ltd.

Office:  +972-3-6447372
Mobile: +972-505-636136
Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com

================================================================================
#71  2025-06-18T17:27:50+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Email to Brad

Eyal,

Here’s the email:


Two weeks ago, you approved and received your share (82%) of a $1.9 million dividend - a significant sum. 

Common sense dictates that if you had any concerns about the financial reports, you - as a majority shareholder in the company - should have deferred the dividend approval until the reports were finalized.
Your despicable conduct within the company, toward Asaf, and in failing to report to the tax authorities as required, at the very least, demonstrates a lack of good faith toward Asaf and other stakeholders.

Unlike you, who conceals your activities, involvement, and control of the company behind questionable tax structures, Asaf is an Australian citizen who reports his income in Australia, pays taxes there, and has nothing to hide from you or the Australian tax authorities.

Should you choose not to sign the financial reports, that is solely your decision, driven by what seem to be questionable motives. 
We have no intention of continuing to engage in conflict with you over this matter. However, if the financial reports remain unsigned, the company may face an investigation by the Australian tax authorities. 

As a law-abiding citizen, Asaf will fully cooperate and provide all required information in accordance with the law. You will bear sole responsibility for any consequences that may arise for you or related parties from the Australian tax authorities.

I am surprised that, instead of allowing Asaf to focus on his work and maximize returns for the company and its shareholders, you persistently harass him over matters for which you are solely responsible, driven by motives unrelated to Asaf.

================================================================================
#72  2025-06-18T11:09:13+03:00
From:    Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Brad 1

Brad,

Sorry that I have to intervene....

Two weeks ago, you approved and received your share (82%) of a $1.9 million
dividend - a significant sum.

As you know, about 10 years ago the company had appointed auditors by
your approval, that peppered and filed the financial reports since, and you
as the major shareholder and a director approved and signed as well.

If you had any concerns about the financial reports,* you - as the majority
shareholder in the company (and a CPA) - should have delayed the dividend
approval and distribution, until the reports were finalized*.
*However, by your instruction the company maximized the dividend
distribution ... which raises questions to your motivation by sending this
mail.*

*Your despicable conduct within the company*, toward Asaf, and *in failing
to report to the tax authorities as required by law*, at the very least,
*demonstrates your lack of good faith toward Asaf, the company and the tax
authorities .*
Unlike you, who conceals your activities, involvement, and control of the
company behind questionable tax structures, Asaf is an Australian citizen
who reports his income in Australia, pays taxes there, and has nothing to
hide from you or the Australian tax authorities.

Should you choose not to sign the financial reports (which you
approved when demanded the dividend distribution), that is solely your
decision, driven by what seem to be questionable motives.

We have no intention of continuing to engage in conflict with you over this
matter. However, as you probably know, if the financial reports remain
unsigned, the company may face an investigation by the Australian tax
authorities.

As a law-abiding citizen, Asaf will fully cooperate and provide all
required information in accordance with the law and you will bear sole
responsibility for any consequences that may arise for you / the company /
Asaf or any related parties from the Australian tax authorities.

I am surprised that, instead of allowing Asaf to focus on his work and
maximize returns for the company and its shareholders, you persistently
harass him over matters for which you are solely responsible, driven by
motives unrelated to Asaf.

Eyal

-- 
Best Regards,

Eyal Shamir,
Managing Director

Midas Corporation Ltd.

Office:  +972-3-6447372
Mobile: +972-505-636136
Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com

================================================================================
#73  2025-06-23T13:16:16+03:00
From:    Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: מכתב לבראד - 2

הי אחי,
מציע לכתוב לו משהו בסגנון (מציע שעל הנוסח הסופי יעבור העו"ד שלך):

בראד שלום רב,
מוזר מאוד שאתה מוצא לנכון לשלוח לי מכתב שנוסח ע"י עו"ד.... כרצונך....

את שהיה לי לומר, כבר כתבתי ולכן לא אתייחס באופן ספציפי לתשובותיך (המוזרות)
שמעלות שאלות באשר לתום הלב בו אתה פועל, אבל אוסיף כי:

ראשית אציין כי כפי שאתה יודע, המכתב שקיבלת ממני, היה מצומצם בהיקפו והתייחס
לנושאים ספציפיים שעלו, אתה כמובן מבין שיש לאחי לא מעט טענות אחרות הנוגעות
אליך, דרך התנהלותך לאורך השנים ואופן השליטה שלך בחברה.

שנית, כרואה חשבון בהשכלתך, אתה יודע יודע את המשמעות של חתימה על דוחות
כספיים המבוקרים ע"י רואה חשבון (זאת בנוסף על היותך דירקטור ובעל השליטה
בעקיפין בחברה). אתה גם מבין את משמעות אישור וחלוקת דיבידנד בפועל טרם חתימה
(טכנית) על הדוחות וסירוב לחתימה לאחר מכן, בשל טענות משוללות כל יסוד.

שלישית, כפי שנמסר לי ע"י אסף (ומגובה בתכתובות), אתה זה שדחף להגדיל למקסימום
את הדיבידנד בחברה, וזאת, בניגוד לאסף שבחר להיות שמרן והציע להשאיר רזרבות
משמעותיות של רווחים ראויים לחלוקה.

רביעית, כבעל השליטה בחברה וכדירקטור, אתה מוזמן כמובן לפנות
לרואי החשבון המבקרים ולקבל מהם כל מידע הנדרש על ידך או הבהרות בנוגע לדוחות
הכספיים (לפי השכל הישר ולמען הזהירות, דבר שהיית אמור לעשות טרם אישור
הדוחות, הכרזת ומשיכת הדיבידנד).

בנימה אישית, אני מציע לך לחדול מפעולותיך הנפסדות ולהישיר מבט לעתיד ולהתקדם
בחיים.

בברכה,

אייל

-- 
Best Regards,

Eyal Shamir,
Managing Director

Midas Corporation Ltd.

Office:  +972-3-6447372
Mobile: +972-505-636136
Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com

================================================================================
#74  2025-06-24T17:50:50+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: מכתב לבראד - 2

Translation:

I have already expressed my position in writing, and therefore, I will not specifically address your (peculiar) responses, which raise questions regarding the good faith of your actions. However, I would like to add the following:

First, as you are aware, the letter you received from me was limited in scope and addressed specific issues that arose. You undoubtedly understand that my brother has numerous additional claims concerning you, your conduct over the years, and the manner in which you control the company.

Second, as a trained accountant, you are well aware of the significance of signing audited financial statements (in addition to your roles as a director and indirect controlling shareholder of the company). You also understand the implications of approving and distributing dividends in practice prior to the (technical) signing of the financial statements, and subsequently refusing to sign them based on baseless claims.

Third, as conveyed to me by Asaf (and supported by correspondence), it was you who pushed to maximise the dividend distribution in the company, in contrast to Asaf, who opted for a conservative approach and proposed retaining significant reserves of distributable profits.

Fourth, as the controlling shareholder and director, you are, of course, welcome to contact the auditing accountants and obtain any required information or clarifications regarding the financial statements (a step that, in accordance with common sense and due caution, you should have taken prior to approving the statements, declaring, and withdrawing the dividend).

On a personal note, I suggest you cease your detrimental actions, look toward the future, and move forward in life.


> On 23 Jun 2025, at 8:16 PM, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:
> 
> הי אחי,
> מציע לכתוב לו משהו בסגנון (מציע שעל הנוסח הסופי יעבור העו"ד שלך):
> 
> בראד שלום רב,
> מוזר מאוד שאתה מוצא לנכון לשלוח לי מכתב שנוסח ע"י עו"ד.... כרצונך....
> 
> את שהיה לי לומר, כבר כתבתי ולכן לא אתייחס באופן ספציפי לתשובותיך (המוזרות) שמעלות שאלות באשר לתום הלב בו אתה פועל, אבל אוסיף כי:
> 
> ראשית אציין כי כפי שאתה יודע, המכתב שקיבלת ממני, היה מצומצם בהיקפו והתייחס לנושאים ספציפיים שעלו, אתה כמובן מבין שיש לאחי לא מעט טענות אחרות הנוגעות אליך, דרך התנהלותך לאורך השנים ואופן השליטה שלך בחברה.
> 
> שנית, כרואה חשבון בהשכלתך, אתה יודע יודע את המשמעות של חתימה על דוחות כספיים המבוקרים ע"י רואה חשבון (זאת בנוסף על היותך דירקטור ובעל השליטה בעקיפין בחברה). אתה גם מבין את משמעות אישור וחלוקת דיבידנד בפועל טרם חתימה (טכנית) על הדוחות וסירוב לחתימה לאחר מכן, בשל טענות משוללות כל יסוד.
> 
> שלישית, כפי שנמסר לי ע"י אסף (ומגובה בתכתובות), אתה זה שדחף להגדיל למקסימום את הדיבידנד בחברה, וזאת, בניגוד לאסף שבחר להיות שמרן והציע להשאיר רזרבות משמעותיות של רווחים ראויים לחלוקה.
> 
> רביעית, כבעל השליטה בחברה וכדירקטור, אתה מוזמן כמובן לפנות לרואי החשבון המבקרים ולקבל מהם כל מידע הנדרש על ידך או הבהרות בנוגע לדוחות הכספיים (לפי השכל הישר ולמען הזהירות, דבר שהיית אמור לעשות טרם אישור הדוחות, הכרזת ומשיכת הדיבידנד).
> 
> בנימה אישית, אני מציע לך לחדול מפעולותיך הנפסדות ולהישיר מבט לעתיד ולהתקדם בחיים.
> 
> בברכה,
> 
> אייל
> 
> --
> Best Regards,
> 
> Eyal Shamir, 
> Managing Director
>  
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> 
> Office:  +972-3-6447372
> Mobile: +972-505-636136
> Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com <mailto:shamir@midasholdings.com>

================================================================================
#75  2025-06-24T11:41:19+03:00
From:    shamir@midasholdings.com
To:      Shamir Asaf <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: מכתב לבראד - 2

ראיתי. אשנה טיפה ואשלח לך. אח״כ נעביר לוBest regards,Eyal ShamirMidas Corporation Ltd.Mobile +972-505636136‫ב-24 ביוני 2025, בשעה 10:51, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬﻿Translation:I have already expressed my position in writing, and therefore, I will not specifically address your (peculiar) responses, which raise questions regarding the good faith of your actions. However, I would like to add the following:First, as you are aware, the letter you received from me was limited in scope and addressed specific issues that arose. You undoubtedly understand that my brother has numerous additional claims concerning you, your conduct over the years, and the manner in which you control the company.Second, as a trained accountant, you are well aware of the significance of signing audited financial statements (in addition to your roles as a director and indirect controlling shareholder of the company). You also understand the implications of approving and distributing dividends in practice prior to the (technical) signing of the financial statements, and subsequently refusing to sign them based on baseless claims.Third, as conveyed to me by Asaf (and supported by correspondence), it was you who pushed to maximise the dividend distribution in the company, in contrast to Asaf, who opted for a conservative approach and proposed retaining significant reserves of distributable profits.Fourth, as the controlling shareholder and director, you are, of course, welcome to contact the auditing accountants and obtain any required information or clarifications regarding the financial statements (a step that, in accordance with common sense and due caution, you should have taken prior to approving the statements, declaring, and withdrawing the dividend).On a personal note, I suggest you cease your detrimental actions, look toward the future, and move forward in life.On 23 Jun 2025, at 8:16 PM, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:הי אחי,מציע לכתוב לו משהו בסגנון (מציע שעל הנוסח הסופי יעבור העו"ד שלך):בראד שלום רב,מוזר מאוד שאתה מוצא לנכון לשלוח לי מכתב שנוסח ע"י עו"ד.... כרצונך....את שהיה לי לומר, כבר כתבתי ולכן לא אתייחס באופן ספציפי לתשובותיך (המוזרות) שמעלות שאלות באשר לתום הלב בו אתה פועל, אבל אוסיף כי:ראשית אציין כי כפי שאתה יודע, המכתב שקיבלת ממני, היה מצומצם בהיקפו והתייחס לנושאים ספציפיים שעלו, אתה כמובן מבין שיש לאחי לא מעט טענות אחרות הנוגעות אליך, דרך התנהלותך לאורך השנים ואופן השליטה שלך בחברה.שנית, כרואה חשבון בהשכלתך, אתה יודע יודע את המשמעות של חתימה על דוחות כספיים המבוקרים ע"י רואה חשבון (זאת בנוסף על היותך דירקטור ובעל השליטה בעקיפין בחברה). אתה גם מבין את משמעות אישור וחלוקת דיבידנד בפועל טרם חתימה (טכנית) על הדוחות וסירוב לחתימה לאחר מכן, בשל טענות משוללות כל יסוד.שלישית, כפי שנמסר לי ע"י אסף (ומגובה בתכתובות), אתה זה שדחף להגדיל למקסימום את הדיבידנד בחברה, וזאת, בניגוד לאסף שבחר להיות שמרן והציע להשאיר רזרבות משמעותיות של רווחים ראויים לחלוקה.רביעית, כבעל השליטה בחברה וכדירקטור, אתה מוזמן כמובן לפנות לרואי החשבון המבקרים ולקבל מהם כל מידע הנדרש על ידך או הבהרות בנוגע לדוחות הכספיים (לפי השכל הישר ולמען הזהירות, דבר שהיית אמור לעשות טרם אישור הדוחות, הכרזת ומשיכת הדיבידנד).בנימה אישית, אני מציע לך לחדול מפעולותיך הנפסדות ולהישיר מבט לעתיד ולהתקדם בחיים.בברכה,אייל-- Best Regards,Eyal Shamir, Managing Director Midas Corporation Ltd.Office:  +972-3-6447372Mobile: +972-505-636136Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com

================================================================================
#76  2025-06-25T07:39:20+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli & Vincent

I hope you are both well. I am looking for a copy of the bank statements
from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. For the last 10.5 years.

*For the record* I have repeatedly asked Asaf for them & today he said I
must ask you.

In addition, I urgently need today’s bank balance. Again I asked Asaf & he
has not provided it.

Please let me know asap.

Regards

Brad

On Thu, 12 Jun 2025 at 09:00, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Brad
>
>
>
> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In
> return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In
> essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees
> invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as
> contracting services.
>
>
>
> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is
> entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>
>
>
> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek
> confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to
> Shamir Holdings?
>
>
>
> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as
> an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>
>
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to
> Shamir Holdings.
>
>
>
> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these
> expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>
>
>
> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to
> reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial
> statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>
>
>
> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw
> Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not
> responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
>
> $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>
>
>
> Please can you respond straight away.
>
>
>
> Thank you
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Eli
>
>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>    thanks for clarifying that it is a *License Fee*
>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>
>    July - 12,936.00
>    Aug - 12,936.00
>    Sep - 12,936.00
>    Oct - 12,936.00
>    Nov - 12,936.00
>    Dec - 13,607.00
>    Jan - 13,607.00
>    Feb - 13,607.00
>    Mar - 13,607.00
>    Apr - 13,607.00
>    May - 13,607.00
>    June - 13,607.00
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well.
>
>
>
> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>
> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
> *Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a
> lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?*
>
>
>
> *If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.*
>
> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
> software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
>
> *I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:*
>
> *As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.*
>
> *On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:*
>
> *Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec
> 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in
> addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for
> contractor expenses ** incurred.*
>
> Now you are both telling me this is *NOT* Asaf's remuneration but in fact
> a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw
> Mobility. *Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?*
>
> *Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To
> be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and
> reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir
> Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor*
>
> *In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:*
>
> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93
> ($105,169 ex GST)?
>
> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your
> allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will
> review and come back to you
>
> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
> ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number
> so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
>
> *I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.*
>
> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in
> Sassu file
>
> Thanks
>
>

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#77  2025-06-25T10:10:46+00:00
From:    Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
To:      bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: RE: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad

We don’t have access to the bank account.  We do have access to the Sassu file which gets direct bank feeds.

Assuming you have access to the Sassu file, you will be able to obtain bank data.

If you still require bank statement, Asaf will need to obtain from the bank.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Sent: Wednesday, 25 June 2025 4:39 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli & Vincent

I hope you are both well. I am looking for a copy of the bank statements from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. For the last 10.5 years.

For the record I have repeatedly asked Asaf for them & today he said I must ask you.

In addition, I urgently need today’s bank balance. Again I asked Asaf & he has not provided it.

Please let me know asap.

Regards

Brad

On Thu, 12 Jun 2025 at 09:00, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad

I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as contracting services.

I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.

In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKwhWneeFssd9oA6Y?h=A533M6s16DPJPcQKOqPA8QSPlrBLeD2gGntrFPySpw4=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings?

Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as an R&D fee in the bank statement?

Thanks

Brad

On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad

The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings.

We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.

Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.

I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
$159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?

Please can you respond straight away.

Thank you

Brad

On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
Hi Eli

  1.  Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
  2.  Not sure what is poorly worded about "remunerations to Asaf" but thanks for clarifying that it is a License Fee
  3.  R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:

July - 12,936.00
Aug - 12,936.00
Sep - 12,936.00
Oct - 12,936.00
Nov - 12,936.00
Dec - 13,607.00
Jan - 13,607.00
Feb - 13,607.00
Mar - 13,607.00
Apr - 13,607.00
May - 13,607.00
June - 13,607.00
Thanks

Brad

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow

Regards,

Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au<https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>

From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com<mailto:brad@bradgish.com>>
Sent: Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au<mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au<mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au<mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Eli

I hope you are well.

Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?

If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.
2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:
As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:
Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for contractor expenses  incurred.
Now you are both telling me this is NOT Asaf's remuneration but in fact a 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#78  2025-06-25T12:13:00+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Asaf, this is the *final time* I will *personally* be asking you for:

   - the bank statements from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. for the last 10.5
   years
   - the latest bank balance on ALL of Raw Mobility accounts

If I do not get this information by *5pm Melbourne time on Tuesday 1 July
2025* or a reasonable explanation for the
delay for the historic bank statements, I will be forced by *you*, to
consider my options, and reserve all my and Marlau's
rights in this regard.

Brad Gishen
As Director of Raw Mobility Pty Limited
For and on behalf of Marlau Trust




On Wed, Jun 25, 2025 at 11:10 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Brad
>
>
>
> We don’t have access to the bank account.  We do have access to the Sassu
> file which gets direct bank feeds.
>
>
>
> Assuming you have access to the Sassu file, you will be able to obtain
> bank data.
>
>
>
> If you still require bank statement, Asaf will need to obtain from the
> bank.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Wednesday, 25 June 2025 4:39 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli & Vincent
>
>
>
> I hope you are both well. I am looking for a copy of the bank statements
> from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. For the last 10.5 years.
>
>
>
> *For the record* I have repeatedly asked Asaf for them & today he said I
> must ask you.
>
>
>
> In addition, I urgently need today’s bank balance. Again I asked Asaf & he
> has not provided it.
>
>
>
> Please let me know asap.
>
>
>
> Regards
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, 12 Jun 2025 at 09:00, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In
> return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In
> essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees
> invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as
> contracting services.
>
>
>
> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is
> entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>
>
>
> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek
> confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKwhWneeFssd9oA6Y?h=A533M6s16DPJPcQKOqPA8QSPlrBLeD2gGntrFPySpw4=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to
> Shamir Holdings?
>
>
>
> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as
> an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>
>
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to
> Shamir Holdings.
>
>
>
> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these
> expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>
>
>
> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to
> reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial
> statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>
>
>
> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw
> Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not
> responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
>
> $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>
>
>
> Please can you respond straight away.
>
>
>
> Thank you
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Eli
>
>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>    thanks for clarifying that it is a *License Fee*
>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>
>    July - 12,936.00
>    Aug - 12,936.00
>    Sep - 12,936.00
>    Oct - 12,936.00
>    Nov - 12,936.00
>    Dec - 13,607.00
>    Jan - 13,607.00
>    Feb - 13,607.00
>    Mar - 13,607.00
>    Apr - 13,607.00
>    May - 13,607.00
>    June - 13,607.00
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well.
>
>
>
> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>
> Is Asaf also a D

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#79  2025-06-25T21:14:58+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Fwd: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

FYI:

---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
Date: Wed, Jun 25, 2025 at 9:13 PM
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
Ltd
To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>


Asaf, this is the *final time* I will *personally* be asking you for:

   - the bank statements from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. for the last 10.5
   years
   - the latest bank balance on ALL of Raw Mobility accounts

If I do not get this information by *5pm Melbourne time on Tuesday 1 July
2025* or a reasonable explanation for the
delay for the historic bank statements, I will be forced by *you*, to
consider my options, and reserve all my and Marlau's
rights in this regard.

Brad Gishen
As Director of Raw Mobility Pty Limited
For and on behalf of Marlau Trust




On Wed, Jun 25, 2025 at 11:10 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Brad
>
>
>
> We don’t have access to the bank account.  We do have access to the Sassu
> file which gets direct bank feeds.
>
>
>
> Assuming you have access to the Sassu file, you will be able to obtain
> bank data.
>
>
>
> If you still require bank statement, Asaf will need to obtain from the
> bank.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Wednesday, 25 June 2025 4:39 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli & Vincent
>
>
>
> I hope you are both well. I am looking for a copy of the bank statements
> from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. For the last 10.5 years.
>
>
>
> *For the record* I have repeatedly asked Asaf for them & today he said I
> must ask you.
>
>
>
> In addition, I urgently need today’s bank balance. Again I asked Asaf & he
> has not provided it.
>
>
>
> Please let me know asap.
>
>
>
> Regards
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, 12 Jun 2025 at 09:00, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In
> return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In
> essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees
> invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as
> contracting services.
>
>
>
> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is
> entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>
>
>
> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek
> confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKwhWneeFssd9oA6Y?h=A533M6s16DPJPcQKOqPA8QSPlrBLeD2gGntrFPySpw4=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to
> Shamir Holdings?
>
>
>
> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as
> an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>
>
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to
> Shamir Holdings.
>
>
>
> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these
> expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>
>
>
> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to
> reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial
> statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>
>
>
> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw
> Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not
> responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
>
> $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>
>
>
> Please can you respond straight away.
>
>
>
> Thank you
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Eli
>
>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>    thanks for clarifying that it is a *License Fee*
>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>
>    July - 12,936.00
>    Aug - 12,936.00
>    Sep - 12,936.00
>    Oct - 12,936.00
>    Nov - 12,936.00
>    Dec - 13,607.00
>    Jan - 13,607.00
>    Feb - 13,607.00
>    Mar - 13,607.00
>    Apr - 13,607.00
>    May - 13,607.00
>    June - 13,607.00
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovit

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#80  2025-06-25T15:32:02+03:00
From:    Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
To:      Shamir Asaf <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Re: מכתב לבראד - 2

Brad,

It is very strange that the reply I got from you was written by an
attorney..... but, as you like....

I have already expressed my position in writing, and therefore, I will not
specifically address your (peculiar) responses, which raise questions
regarding the good faith of your actions. However, I would like to add the
following:

First, as you are aware, the letter you received from me was limited in
scope and addressed specific issues that arose. You undoubtedly understand
that my brother has numerous additional claims concerning you, your conduct
over the years, and the manner in which you control the company.

Second, as a trained accountant, you are well aware of the significance of
signing audited financial statements (in addition to your roles as a
director and indirect controlling shareholder of the company). You also
understand the implications of approving and distributing dividends in
practice prior to the (technical) signing of the financial statements, and
subsequently refusing to sign them afterwards.

Third, as conveyed to me by Asaf (and supported by correspondence), it was
you who pushed to maximise the dividend distribution in the company, in
contrast to Asaf, who opted for a conservative approach and proposed
retaining significant reserves of distributable profits.

Fourth, as the controlling shareholder and director, you are, of course,
welcome to contact the auditing accountants and obtain any required
information or clarifications regarding the financial statements (a step
that, in accordance with common sense and due caution, you should have
taken prior to approving the statements, declaring, and withdrawing the
dividend).

Fifth, I also advise you to contact your father (the alleged trustee...)
who is cc to this mail, that will provide you with all necessary info.

On a personal note, I suggest you cease your detrimental actions, look
toward the future, and move forward in life.

Eyal

On Tue, Jun 24, 2025 at 11:41 AM <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:

> ראיתי. אשנה טיפה ואשלח לך. אח״כ נעביר לו
> Best regards,
>
> Eyal Shamir
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
> Mobile +972-505636136
>
> ‫ב-24 ביוני 2025, בשעה 10:51, ‏‏Asaf Shamir ‏<asaf@shamir.com.au> כתב/ה:‬
>
> ﻿Translation:
>
> I have already expressed my position in writing, and therefore, I will not
> specifically address your (peculiar) responses, which raise questions
> regarding the good faith of your actions. However, I would like to add the
> following:
>
> First, as you are aware, the letter you received from me was limited in
> scope and addressed specific issues that arose. You undoubtedly understand
> that my brother has numerous additional claims concerning you, your conduct
> over the years, and the manner in which you control the company.
>
> Second, as a trained accountant, you are well aware of the significance of
> signing audited financial statements (in addition to your roles as a
> director and indirect controlling shareholder of the company). You also
> understand the implications of approving and distributing dividends in
> practice prior to the (technical) signing of the financial statements, and
> subsequently refusing to sign them based on baseless claims.
>
> Third, as conveyed to me by Asaf (and supported by correspondence), it was
> you who pushed to maximise the dividend distribution in the company, in
> contrast to Asaf, who opted for a conservative approach and proposed
> retaining significant reserves of distributable profits.
>
> Fourth, as the controlling shareholder and director, you are, of course,
> welcome to contact the auditing accountants and obtain any required
> information or clarifications regarding the financial statements (a step
> that, in accordance with common sense and due caution, you should have
> taken prior to approving the statements, declaring, and withdrawing the
> dividend).
>
> On a personal note, I suggest you cease your detrimental actions, look
> toward the future, and move forward in life.
>
>
> On 23 Jun 2025, at 8:16 PM, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com> wrote:
>
> הי אחי,
> מציע לכתוב לו משהו בסגנון (מציע שעל הנוסח הסופי יעבור העו"ד שלך):
>
> בראד שלום רב,
> מוזר מאוד שאתה מוצא לנכון לשלוח לי מכתב שנוסח ע"י עו"ד.... כרצונך....
>
> את שהיה לי לומר, כבר כתבתי ולכן לא אתייחס באופן ספציפי לתשובותיך (המוזרות)
> שמעלות שאלות באשר לתום הלב בו אתה פועל, אבל אוסיף כי:
>
> ראשית אציין כי כפי שאתה יודע, המכתב שקיבלת ממני, היה מצומצם בהיקפו והתייחס
> לנושאים ספציפיים שעלו, אתה כמובן מבין שיש לאחי לא מעט טענות אחרות הנוגעות
> אליך, דרך התנהלותך לאורך השנים ואופן השליטה שלך בחברה.
>
> שנית, כרואה חשבון בהשכלתך, אתה יודע יודע את המשמעות של חתימה על דוחות
> כספיים המבוקרים ע"י רואה חשבון (זאת בנוסף על היותך דירקטור ובעל השליטה
> בעקיפין בחברה). אתה גם מבין את משמעות אישור וחלוקת דיבידנד בפועל טרם חתימה
> (טכנית) על הדוחות וסירוב לחתימה לאחר מכן, בשל טענות משוללות כל יסוד.
>
> שלישית, כפי שנמסר לי ע"י אסף (ומגובה בתכתובות), אתה זה שדחף להגדיל
> למקסימום את הדיבידנד בחברה, וזאת, בניגוד לאסף שבחר להיות שמרן והציע להשאיר
> רזרבות משמעותיות של רווחים ראויים לחלוקה.
>
> רביעית, כבעל השליטה בחברה וכדירקטור, אתה מוזמן כמובן לפנות
> לרואי החשבון המבקרים ולקבל מהם כל מידע הנדרש על ידך או הבהרות בנוגע לדוחות
> הכספיים (לפי השכל הישר ולמען הזהירות, דבר שהיית אמור לעשות טרם אישור
> הדוחות, הכרזת ומשיכת הדיבידנד).
>
> בנימה אישית, אני מציע לך לחדול מפעולותיך הנפסדות ולהישיר מבט לעתיד ולהתקדם
> בחיים.
>
> בברכה,
>
> אייל
>
> --
> Best Regards,
>
> Eyal Shamir,
> Managing Director
>
> Midas Corporation Ltd.
>
> Office:  +972-3-6447372
> Mobile: +972-505-636136
> Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com
>
>
>

-- 
Best Regards,

Eyal Shamir,
Managing Director

Midas Corporation Ltd.

Office:  +972-3-6447372
Mobile: +972-505-636136
Mail: shamir@midasholdings.com

================================================================================
#81  2025-07-01T11:14:41+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>,
 Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad,

As your business partner for many years, I want it to be clear that I have nothing to hide from you, and I’m disappointed that you continue to question my integrity despite my successfully running Raw Mobility and delivering increasing profits for you and your shareholders over the years.

However - since I already offered you (via email dated 30/Jan/2025) access to Raw Mobility's online banking, access to Raw Mobility's accounting software (Saasu), and was refused by you (for mysterious reasons); and have already provided you with bank balances; and given that you question the information given to you by our accountant (Green & Sternfeld) for the last 10 years; and since you question with no reason info I provide to you; I suggest:

To avoid any questions or doubt regarding my integrity and that of the documents, it would be best if you acquired those statements directly from the bank.

As a controlling shareholder and a director of Raw Mobility you are more than welcome to approach Westpac Bank directly, and as I understand, they will provide you with the information you require. 

Asaf

-- 
Asaf    Shamir
+61-417-188345




> On 25 Jun 2025, at 9:13 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Asaf, this is the final time I will personally be asking you for:
> the bank statements from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. for the last 10.5 years
> the latest bank balance on ALL of Raw Mobility accounts
> If I do not get this information by 5pm Melbourne time on Tuesday 1 July 2025 or a reasonable explanation for the 
> delay for the historic bank statements, I will be forced by you, to consider my options, and reserve all my and Marlau's
> rights in this regard.
> 
> Brad Gishen
> As Director of Raw Mobility Pty Limited
> For and on behalf of Marlau Trust
> 
> 
> 
> 
> On Wed, Jun 25, 2025 at 11:10 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> We don’t have access to the bank account.  We do have access to the Sassu file which gets direct bank feeds.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Assuming you have access to the Sassu file, you will be able to obtain bank data.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> If you still require bank statement, Asaf will need to obtain from the bank.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Regards,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> 
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>> Sent: Wednesday, 25 June 2025 4:39 PM
>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Hi Eli & Vincent
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I hope you are both well. I am looking for a copy of the bank statements from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. For the last 10.5 years. 
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> For the record I have repeatedly asked Asaf for them & today he said I must ask you. 
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> In addition, I urgently need today’s bank balance. Again I asked Asaf & he has not provided it. 
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Please let me know asap. 
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Regards 
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> On Thu, 12 Jun 2025 at 09:00, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as contracting services.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Regards,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144 <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKwhWneeFssd9oA6Y?h=A533M6s16DPJPcQKOqPA8QSPlrBLeD2gGntrFPySpw4=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>> Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Hi Eli
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings?
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Thanks
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Regards,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144 <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>> Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Hi Eli
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not responded to my question regarding R&D payments of 
>> 
>> $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Please can you respond straight away. 
>> 
>>  
>> 
>>

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#82  2025-07-02T09:18:08+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>, Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>, 
	Martin Gishen <mcg@margish.com>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
 Mobility Pty Ltd

Dear Asaf,

You are under a *legal obligation* to provide the information I have
requested.

Your refusal to do so is *without justifiable basis and obvious*.

Please be advised that *I will* obtain the necessary information, *irrespective
of your recalcitrance* and
you can be *absolutely certain* that in doing so, *a punitive cost order
against you* will be sought.

"As your business partner for many years", I *urge* you to reconsider your
position.

*Your continued non-cooperation is both ill-advised and detrimental to your
own best interests. *

It would be *prudent* for you to furnish the requested information
*immediately.*

Yours faithfully,

Brad Gishen
As Director of Raw Mobility Pty Limited
For and on behalf of Marlau Trust

On Tue, Jul 1, 2025 at 2:14 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:

> Brad,
>
> As your business partner for many years, I want it to be clear that I have
> nothing to hide from you, and I’m disappointed that you continue to
> question my integrity despite my successfully running Raw Mobility and
> delivering increasing profits for you and your shareholders over the years.
>
> However - since I already offered you (via email dated 30/Jan/2025) access
> to Raw Mobility's online banking, access to Raw Mobility's accounting
> software (Saasu), and was refused by you (for mysterious reasons); and have
> already provided you with bank balances; and given that you question the
> information given to you by our accountant (Green & Sternfeld) for the last
> 10 years; and since you question with no reason info I provide to you; I
> suggest:
>
> To avoid any questions or doubt regarding my integrity and that of the
> documents, it would be best if you acquired those statements directly from
> the bank.
>
> As a controlling shareholder and a director of Raw Mobility you are more
> than welcome to approach Westpac Bank directly, and as I understand, they
> will provide you with the information you require.
>
> Asaf
>
> --
> Asaf    Shamir
> +61-417-188345
>
>
>
>
> On 25 Jun 2025, at 9:13 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Asaf, this is the *final time* I will *personally* be asking you for:
>
>    - the bank statements from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. for the last
>    10.5 years
>    - the latest bank balance on ALL of Raw Mobility accounts
>
> If I do not get this information by *5pm Melbourne time on Tuesday 1 July
> 2025* or a reasonable explanation for the
> delay for the historic bank statements, I will be forced by *you*, to
> consider my options, and reserve all my and Marlau's
> rights in this regard.
>
> Brad Gishen
> As Director of Raw Mobility Pty Limited
> For and on behalf of Marlau Trust
>
>
>
>
> On Wed, Jun 25, 2025 at 11:10 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> We don’t have access to the bank account.  We do have access to the Sassu
>> file which gets direct bank feeds.
>>
>>
>>
>> Assuming you have access to the Sassu file, you will be able to obtain
>> bank data.
>>
>>
>>
>> If you still require bank statement, Asaf will need to obtain from the
>> bank.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Wednesday, 25 June 2025 4:39 PM
>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli & Vincent
>>
>>
>>
>> I hope you are both well. I am looking for a copy of the bank statements
>> from 1 January 2015 to date, ie. For the last 10.5 years.
>>
>>
>>
>> *For the record* I have repeatedly asked Asaf for them & today he said I
>> must ask you.
>>
>>
>>
>> In addition, I urgently need today’s bank balance. Again I asked Asaf &
>> he has not provided it.
>>
>>
>>
>> Please let me know asap.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards
>>
>>
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> On Thu, 12 Jun 2025 at 09:00, Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In
>> return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In
>> essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees
>> invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as
>> contracting services.
>>
>>
>>
>> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is
>> entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>>
>>
>>
>> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek
>> confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrmKwhWneeFssd9oA6Y?h=A533M6s16DPJPcQKOqPA8QSPlrBLeD2gGntrFPySpw4=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli
>>
>>
>>
>> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee
>> to Shamir Holdings?
>>
>>
>>
>> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded
>> as an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>>
>>
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>>
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to
>> Shamir Holdings.
>>
>>
>>
>> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these
>> expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>>
>>
>>
>> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to
>> reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial
>> statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>>
>>
>>
>> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw
>> Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xrrA8yyQLEfphYhMZFA?h=vbQGkiMRFF8IBotKjqhPW_ls-uCOVMeeP8OhOxbZdws=&u=https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145%2BMalvern%2BRoad%2C%2BMalvern%2C%2BVictoria%2B3144?entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg>
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsc

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#83  2025-07-27T14:16:16+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Cc:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Asaf

I am still waiting for an explanation of the *R&D expense* - exactly what
it is and how it is calculated?

Asaf, despite your ongoing *unlawful* withholding of information, I can
assure you I have and will get every single thing I need.

Please send me an immediate explanation and to reiterate what was said to
you previously:

*Your continued non-cooperation is both ill-advised and detrimental to your
own best interests. *

Brad Gishen

On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 9:00 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:

> Brad
>
>
>
> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In
> return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In
> essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees
> invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as
> contracting services.
>
>
>
> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is
> entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>
>
>
> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek
> confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to
> Shamir Holdings?
>
>
>
> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as
> an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>
>
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to
> Shamir Holdings.
>
>
>
> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these
> expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>
>
>
> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to
> reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial
> statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>
>
>
> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw
> Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not
> responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
>
> $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>
>
>
> Please can you respond straight away.
>
>
>
> Thank you
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Eli
>
>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>    thanks for clarifying that it is a *License Fee*
>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>
>    July - 12,936.00
>    Aug - 12,936.00
>    Sep - 12,936.00
>    Oct - 12,936.00
>    Nov - 12,936.00
>    Dec - 13,607.00
>    Jan - 13,607.00
>    Feb - 13,607.00
>    Mar - 13,607.00
>    Apr - 13,607.00
>    May - 13,607.00
>    June - 13,607.00
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>
> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>
> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>
>
>
> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility
> Pty Ltd
>
>
>
> Hi Eli
>
>
>
> I hope you are well.
>
>
>
> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>
> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
> *Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a
> lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?*
>
>
>
> *If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.*
>
> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for
> software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.
>
> *I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:*
>
> *As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via
> Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.*
>
> *On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:*
>
> *Open model License fee - please send a breakdown for Oct, Nov and Dec
> 2024 GSCA: We understand that the expense includes remunerations to Asaf in
> addition to his fixed wages (Employee Base Pay) and reimbursements for
> contractor expenses ** incurred.*
>
> Now you are both telling me this is *NOT* Asaf's remuneration but in fact
> a License fee for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licensed to Raw
> Mobility. *Do you seriously think that this is not a contradiction?*
>
> *Previous explanations were poorly worded and therefore misunderstood.  To
> be clear, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility for licence fees and
> reimbursement of contractor’s salary.  Proceeds are then used by Shamir
> Holdings to remunerate Asaf and to remunerate the contractor*
>
> *In addition you seemed to ignore my question so I will ask it again:*
>
> How do you explain the fee in March 2024 amounting to $115,686.93
> ($105,169 ex GST)?
>
> I didn’t ignore your question.  I wanted clarity with respect to your
> allegation before responding.  Now that this issue is clarified, I will
> review and come back to you
>
> In addition, please can you explain the R&D fee amounting to $159,929.00
> ($145,390 ex GST)?  Please clarify from where you reference this number
> so that we can consider and respond accordingly.
>
> *I get this number from the bank statements for the year ending June 2024.*
>
> Please provide breakdown of each amount so that we can trace allocation in
> Sassu file
>
> Thanks
>
>
>
> Brad
>
>
>
> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 9:47 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
> Brad – please refer to my comments inline below in BLUE.
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
>
>
> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>
> *Green & Sternfeld P

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#84  2025-07-29T17:22:49+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>,
 Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad,

It seems that for some reason you’re trying to create an artificial dispute between us with false allegations.
I spoke to the bank again, and I urge you to contact them, and as a director and majority shareholder - they’ll provide you with all needed information and more at your request.
As was discussed between us many times, and by your request & approval - those expenses are related to a Shamir Holdings employee that is providing software development & support services to Raw Mobility. This has been the case for nearly 7 years, so I’m unsure about the meaning behind your question.
Your conduct toward me over the past months, which includes numerous false allegations and ongoing attempts to escalate into manufactured conflict between us, raises questions regarding your motivations. I hope this does not include any hidden intentions regarding our longstanding partnership, the company, and its activities.

Regards,
Asaf


> On 27 Jul 2025, at 11:16 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Asaf
> 
> I am still waiting for an explanation of the R&D expense - exactly what it is and how it is calculated?
> 
> Asaf, despite your ongoing unlawful withholding of information, I can assure you I have and will get every single thing I need.
> 
> Please send me an immediate explanation and to reiterate what was said to you previously:
> 
> Your continued non-cooperation is both ill-advised and detrimental to your own best interests. 
> 
> Brad Gishen
> 
> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 9:00 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as contracting services.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Regards,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> 
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>> Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Hi Eli
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings?
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Thanks
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Regards,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> 
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>> Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Hi Eli
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not responded to my question regarding R&D payments of 
>> 
>> $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Please can you respond straight away. 
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Thank you
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>> 
>> Hi Eli
>> 
>> Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>> Not sure what is poorly worded about "remunerations to Asaf" but thanks for clarifying that it is a License Fee
>> R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:
>> 
>> July - 12,936.00 
>> Aug - 12,936.00 
>> Sep - 12,936.00 
>> Oct - 12,936.00 
>> Nov - 12,936.00 
>> Dec - 13,607.00 
>> Jan - 13,607.00 
>> Feb - 13,607.00 
>> Mar - 13,607.00 
>> Apr - 13,607.00 
>> May - 13,607.00 
>> June - 13,607.00 
>> Thanks
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Brad
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>> 
>> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Regards,
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>> 
>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>> 
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>> 
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>  
>> 
>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>> Sent: Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Hi Eli
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> I hope you are well.
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>> 
>> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>> Eli, do you not see some major conflicts here? I know you are not a lawyer but I do assume you understand the basics of company Law?
>> 
>>  
>> 
>> If there is disclosure, I don’t see a major conflict.
>> 
>> 2. Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility Open Model Licence Fees for software designed by Shamir Holdings and licenced to Raw Mobility.  
>> 
>> I asked this question and Asaf's reply on 1 May 2025 was:
>> 
>> As per our prior discussions and agreement I invoice Raw Mobility (via Shamir Holdings) as part of my agreed upon remuneration structure.
>> 
>> On the 22nd of January Vincent wrote this to me:
>> 
>> Open model License fee - please send 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#85  2025-07-29T16:15:03+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>, Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd

Hi Asaf

   - Once again, you have failed to respond to my question as to how the
   amount is calculated
   - I have never agreed for Raw Mobility to pay for the expenses of a
   Shamir Holdings employee
   - There has never been any disclosure by you, that this was being done
   - I did agree for Raw Mobility to hire a developer in its own capacity
   - please send me with immediate effect:
      - the name of this employee that is being paid for by Raw Mobility
      - his/her address, email address and mobile phone number
      - payslips for this employee for the last 18 months
      - written confirmation that this employee works exclusively and on a
      full time basis on
      software owned by Raw Mobility
   - Should you fail (*as I expect*) to provide this information, then
   please do not make a single further
   payment out of Raw Mobility, in this regard.

Yours faithfully

Brad Gishen

On Tue, Jul 29, 2025 at 8:22 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:

> Brad,
>
>
>    1. It seems that for some reason you’re trying to create an artificial
>    dispute between us with false allegations.
>    2. I spoke to the bank again, and I urge you to contact them, and as a
>    director and majority shareholder - they’ll provide you with all needed
>    information and more at your request.
>    3. As was discussed between us many times, and by your request &
>    approval - those expenses are related to a Shamir Holdings employee that is
>    providing software development & support services to Raw Mobility. This has
>    been the case for nearly 7 years, so I’m unsure about the meaning behind
>    your question.
>    4. Your conduct toward me over the past months, which includes
>    numerous false allegations and ongoing attempts to escalate into
>    manufactured conflict between us, raises questions regarding your
>    motivations. I hope this does not include any hidden intentions regarding
>    our longstanding partnership, the company, and its activities.
>
>
> Regards,
> Asaf
>
>
> On 27 Jul 2025, at 11:16 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Asaf
>
> I am still waiting for an explanation of the *R&D expense* - exactly what
> it is and how it is calculated?
>
> Asaf, despite your ongoing *unlawful* withholding of information, I can
> assure you I have and will get every single thing I need.
>
> Please send me an immediate explanation and to reiterate what was said to
> you previously:
>
> *Your continued non-cooperation is both ill-advised and detrimental to
> your own best interests. *
>
> Brad Gishen
>
> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 9:00 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In
>> return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In
>> essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees
>> invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as
>> contracting services.
>>
>>
>>
>> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is
>> entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>>
>>
>>
>> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek
>> confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli
>>
>>
>>
>> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee
>> to Shamir Holdings?
>>
>>
>>
>> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded
>> as an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>>
>>
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>>
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to
>> Shamir Holdings.
>>
>>
>>
>> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these
>> expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>>
>>
>>
>> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to
>> reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial
>> statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>>
>>
>>
>> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw
>> Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15xVSc4oRHKmzGC1bPY9F?h=a-w5odvX26SctwxBlT4KSxc71TOhYnuM_WqrtoHlpTw=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 3:25 PM
>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli
>>
>>
>>
>> I hope you are well. A full month has now passed and you have still not
>> responded to my question regarding R&D payments of
>>
>> $159,929.00 ($145,390 ex GST)?
>>
>>
>>
>> Please can you respond straight away.
>>
>>
>>
>> Thank you
>>
>>
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> On Mon, 12 May 2025 at 15:20, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Eli
>>
>>    1. Your interpretation of Company Law is noted, thank you
>>    2. Not sure what is poorly worded about "*remunerations to Asaf*" but
>>    thanks for clarifying that it is a *License Fee*
>>    3. *R&D amounts paid to Shamir Holdings were:*
>>
>>    July - 12,936.00
>>    Aug - 12,936.00
>>    Sep - 12,936.00
>>    Oct - 12,936.00
>>    Nov - 12,936.00
>>    Dec - 13,607.00
>>    Jan - 13,607.00
>>    Feb - 13,607.00
>>    Mar - 13,607.00
>>    Apr - 13,607.00
>>    May - 13,607.00
>>    June - 13,607.00
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>>
>>
>> Brad
>>
>>
>>
>> On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 10:18 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>>
>> Brad – please refer to my responses inline below in yellow
>>
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>>
>>
>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>
>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>
>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>
>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>> <https://clicktime.symantec.com/15x87tG95pFQph2gfshT9?h=dWhphQEVBjbPpHJVWp1WWSMTVSjnbNU6bpdwQm_6IzI=&u=http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>
>>
>>
>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>> *Sent:* Monday, 12 May 2025 7:01 PM
>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
>> *Cc:* Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au>
>> *Subject:* Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
>> Mobility Pty Ltd
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Eli
>>
>>
>>
>> I hope you are well.
>>
>>
>>
>> Raw Mobility is a client of Shamir Holdings
>>
>> Is Asaf also a Director of Shamir Holdings Limited? Yes
>> *Eli, do you n

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#86  2025-07-30T16:49:44+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Jeremy Goldman <jgoldman@kcllaw.com.au>
Cc:      Eyal Shamir <shamir@midasholdings.com>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Jeremy - this is a draft of what I intend to send to brad. 

Brad,

Could you please provide me with some agreement/direction to engage this developer directly via Raw Mobility?

We had conversations on the topic back in 2018 where I stated that I (rather than RM) will hire a developer following your (as a director) repeated refusals to agree not to compete with Raw Mobility & ongoing threats to build a competing system at Mobivate. The goal was to provide relief to concerns regarding support availability & workload, and those were addressed.
Moreover - you have been signing Raw Mobility ITRs for years where the "Salaries & Wages” section only shows the agreed upon wages part of my remuneration ($60k).

I confirm that the developer works 100% of his time (including after hours & support) on Raw Mobility.
Please confirm again that you’d like the developer to stop work/support on Raw Mobility related software.

---

I’d just like to point out that we created this company to develop the software and sell Bulk SMS - I partnered with you for your expertise in driving sales just as you partnered with me for my technical skills. 
Once the product became viable - you started demanding the source code, and eventually decided to resell the software via your own company (Mobivate), own the customers (nearly 13,000 at this point), and diverted profits and opportunities from our joint business. Last month (June 2025) alone YOUR gross profit that is visible from Raw Mobility’s platform was over $2.5 million (AUD) whereas Raw Mobility’s stood at $560k (of which the majority, again, goes to you).

Despite your repeated attempts to acquire RMs source code by threats and intimidation, threats to withhold my salary, threats to develop a competing product, non-disclosure of Bulk SMS related revenue generated through Raw Mobility's platform, presenting me as a Mobivate employee & consultant to customers without compensation and more - I have tried at every turn to find a compromise and preserve the integrity of Raw Mobility as a business and our relationship.

Now we’re at a point where you renege on past agreements, slander me, and are actually moving existing customers from Raw Mobility’s platform and onto yours - in direct conflict of interest and duty of loyalty as a director.

Asaf

> On 30 Jul 2025, at 1:15 AM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Asaf 
> Once again, you have failed to respond to my question as to how the amount is calculated
> I have never agreed for Raw Mobility to pay for the expenses of a Shamir Holdings employee
> There has never been any disclosure by you, that this was being done
> I did agree for Raw Mobility to hire a developer in its own capacity 
> please send me with immediate effect:
> the name of this employee that is being paid for by Raw Mobility
> his/her address, email address and mobile phone number
> payslips for this employee for the last 18 months
> written confirmation that this employee works exclusively and on a full time basis on 
> software owned by Raw Mobility 
> Should you fail (as I expect) to provide this information, then please do not make a single further
> payment out of Raw Mobility, in this regard.  
> Yours faithfully
> 
> Brad Gishen
> 
> On Tue, Jul 29, 2025 at 8:22 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> It seems that for some reason you’re trying to create an artificial dispute between us with false allegations.
>> I spoke to the bank again, and I urge you to contact them, and as a director and majority shareholder - they’ll provide you with all needed information and more at your request.
>> As was discussed between us many times, and by your request & approval - those expenses are related to a Shamir Holdings employee that is providing software development & support services to Raw Mobility. This has been the case for nearly 7 years, so I’m unsure about the meaning behind your question.
>> Your conduct toward me over the past months, which includes numerous false allegations and ongoing attempts to escalate into manufactured conflict between us, raises questions regarding your motivations. I hope this does not include any hidden intentions regarding our longstanding partnership, the company, and its activities.
>> 
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>> 
>> 
>>> On 27 Jul 2025, at 11:16 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf
>>> 
>>> I am still waiting for an explanation of the R&D expense - exactly what it is and how it is calculated?
>>> 
>>> Asaf, despite your ongoing unlawful withholding of information, I can assure you I have and will get every single thing I need.
>>> 
>>> Please send me an immediate explanation and to reiterate what was said to you previously:
>>> 
>>> Your continued non-cooperation is both ill-advised and detrimental to your own best interests. 
>>> 
>>> Brad Gishen
>>> 
>>> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 9:00 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>>>> Brad
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as contracting services.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Regards,
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>>>> 
>>>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>>>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>>> 
>>>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>>> 
>>>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>>>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>>>> Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
>>>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>>>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
>>>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Hi Eli
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings?
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Thanks
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Brad
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>>>> 
>>>> Brad
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Regards,
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>>>> 
>>>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>>>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>>> 
>>>> Postal Address: PO

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#87  2025-07-31T09:58:24+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty
 Ltd

Brad,

Could you please provide me with a copy of the agreement/direction to engage this developer directly via Raw Mobility Pty Ltd that you have indicated you provided?
 
Your request here is more than a little surprising, given that we had conversations about this matter back in 2018 where I stated that I (rather than RM) would hire a developer following your (as a director) repeated refusals to agree not to compete with Raw Mobility & threats to build a competing system at Mobivate.
 
The goal was to provide relief to concerns regarding support availability & workload, and those were addressed through hiring the developer.
 
Moreover, you have been signing Raw Mobility ITRs for years where the "Salaries & Wages” section only reflects the agreed upon wages being part of my remuneration ($60k) with no developer wages evident in these ITRs.
 
I confirm that the developer works 100% of his time (including after hours & support) on Raw Mobility.
 
Please confirm again whether you would like the developer to stop work/support on Raw Mobility related software.

---

I’d just like to point out that we created this company to develop the software and sell Bulk SMS - I partnered with you for your expertise in driving sales just as you partnered with me for my technical skills.
 
Once the product became viable - you demanded the source code, and eventually decided to resell the software via your own company (Mobivate), own the customers (nearly 13,000 at this point), and divert profits and opportunities from our joint business.
 
Last month (June 2025) alone YOUR gross profit that is visible on Raw Mobility’s platform exceeded $2.5 million (AUD) whereas Raw Mobility’s stood at $560k (of which the majority, again, goes to you).
 
Despite your repeated attempts to acquire RMs source code by threats and intimidation, threats to develop a competing product, non-disclosure of Bulk SMS related revenue generated through Raw Mobility's platform, presenting me as a Mobivate employee & consultant to customers without compensation and more - I have tried at every turn to find a compromise and preserve the integrity of Raw Mobility as a business and our relationship.
 
Now we’re at a point where you renege on past agreements, slander me, and are actively moving existing customers from Raw Mobility’s platform onto your platform - in a direct conflict of interest and duty of loyalty as a director.

Again - I propose we engage in mediation (per my email from 12/June/2025) to resolve this.

Asaf


> On 30 Jul 2025, at 1:15 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Asaf 
> Once again, you have failed to respond to my question as to how the amount is calculated
> I have never agreed for Raw Mobility to pay for the expenses of a Shamir Holdings employee
> There has never been any disclosure by you, that this was being done
> I did agree for Raw Mobility to hire a developer in its own capacity 
> please send me with immediate effect:
> the name of this employee that is being paid for by Raw Mobility
> his/her address, email address and mobile phone number
> payslips for this employee for the last 18 months
> written confirmation that this employee works exclusively and on a full time basis on 
> software owned by Raw Mobility 
> Should you fail (as I expect) to provide this information, then please do not make a single further
> payment out of Raw Mobility, in this regard.  
> Yours faithfully
> 
> Brad Gishen
> 
> On Tue, Jul 29, 2025 at 8:22 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> It seems that for some reason you’re trying to create an artificial dispute between us with false allegations.
>> I spoke to the bank again, and I urge you to contact them, and as a director and majority shareholder - they’ll provide you with all needed information and more at your request.
>> As was discussed between us many times, and by your request & approval - those expenses are related to a Shamir Holdings employee that is providing software development & support services to Raw Mobility. This has been the case for nearly 7 years, so I’m unsure about the meaning behind your question.
>> Your conduct toward me over the past months, which includes numerous false allegations and ongoing attempts to escalate into manufactured conflict between us, raises questions regarding your motivations. I hope this does not include any hidden intentions regarding our longstanding partnership, the company, and its activities.
>> 
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>> 
>> 
>>> On 27 Jul 2025, at 11:16 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf
>>> 
>>> I am still waiting for an explanation of the R&D expense - exactly what it is and how it is calculated?
>>> 
>>> Asaf, despite your ongoing unlawful withholding of information, I can assure you I have and will get every single thing I need.
>>> 
>>> Please send me an immediate explanation and to reiterate what was said to you previously:
>>> 
>>> Your continued non-cooperation is both ill-advised and detrimental to your own best interests. 
>>> 
>>> Brad Gishen
>>> 
>>> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 9:00 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>>>> Brad
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.  In return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as contracting services.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Regards,
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Eli Lebovits CA  I  Director
>>>> 
>>>> Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd
>>>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>>> 
>>>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>>> 
>>>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>>>> eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:eli@gsca.com.au>   I  www.gsca.com.au <http://www.gsca.com.au/>
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> From: bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> 
>>>> Sent: Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
>>>> To: Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>>
>>>> Cc: Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>>; Vincent Cai <Vincent@gsca.com.au <mailto:Vincent@gsca.com.au>>
>>>> Subject: Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw Mobility Pty Ltd
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Hi Eli
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Thank you for your email. What exactly do you mean by a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings?
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Contracting for what? How is the amount derived? And why is it recorded as an R&D fee in the bank statement?
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Thanks
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Brad
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 7:13 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au <mailto:Eli@gsca.com.au>> wrote:
>>>> 
>>>> Brad
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> The amount of $159,929 (incl GST) in fact represents a contracting fee to Shamir Holdings.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> We understood this amount to be licence fees on the basis that these expenses were recorded as such in the company’s Sassu file.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> Whilst the net/taxable profit will not change, we are comfortable to reclassify the expense so that it presents accurately in the financial statements.  Please confirm that you would like us to proceed on this basis.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 
>>>> I note that we have been able to secure an extension to lodge Raw Mobility’s 2024 ITR until 12 July 2025.
>>>> 
>>>>  
>>>> 

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#88  2025-07-31T12:24:28+01:00
From:    bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Cc:      Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
 Mobility Pty Ltd

Dear Asaf

I confirm receipt of your email dated *31 July 2025*, which:

   - as expected does not answer my questions
   - indicates that you are deliberately withholding information
   - is *defamatory* of me and Mobivate Limited in which such defamation, *our
   rights are reserved*
   - inaccurately grossly breaches customer confidentiality
   - is littered with nonsense and incorrect facts

Your request to prove that I asked you to hire someone directly via Raw
Mobility is absurd and will be treated
with the contempt it deserves.

Your email of *29 July 2025*, is an admission that the R&D expenses are in
fact *"expenses related to a Shamir*
*Holdings employee" *and has nothing at all to do with R&D.

Raw Mobility will *no longer pay an amount to Shamir Holdings* to cover the
cost of a Shamir Holdings employee
without full visibility of what that employee costs, which you need to
provide with immediate effect.

*Lastly I will not waste my time on mediation and as mentioned before am
proceeding with a forensic auditor.*

Yours faithfully

Brad Gishen
On Thu, 31 Jul 2025 at 00:58, Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:

> Brad,
>
> Could you please provide me with a copy of the agreement/direction to
> engage this developer directly via Raw Mobility Pty Ltd that you have
> indicated you provided?
>
> Your request here is more than a little surprising, given that we had
> conversations about this matter back in 2018 where I stated that I (rather
> than RM) would hire a developer following your (as a director) repeated
> refusals to agree not to compete with Raw Mobility & threats to build a
> competing system at Mobivate.
>
> The goal was to provide relief to concerns regarding support availability
> & workload, and those were addressed through hiring the developer.
>
> Moreover, you have been signing Raw Mobility ITRs for years where the
> "Salaries & Wages” section only reflects the agreed upon wages being part
> of my remuneration ($60k) with no developer wages evident in these ITRs.
>
> I confirm that the developer works 100% of his time (including after hours
> & support) on Raw Mobility.
>
> Please confirm again whether you would like the developer to stop
> work/support on Raw Mobility related software.
>
> ---
>
> I’d just like to point out that we created this company to develop the
> software and sell Bulk SMS - I partnered with you for your expertise in
> driving sales just as you partnered with me for my technical skills.
>
> Once the product became viable - you demanded the source code, and
> eventually decided to resell the software via your own company (Mobivate),
> own the customers (nearly 13,000 at this point), and divert profits and
> opportunities from our joint business.
>
> Last month (June 2025) alone YOUR gross profit that is visible on Raw
> Mobility’s platform exceeded $2.5 million (AUD) whereas Raw Mobility’s
> stood at $560k (of which the majority, again, goes to you).
>
> Despite your repeated attempts to acquire RMs source code by threats and
> intimidation, threats to develop a competing product, non-disclosure of
> Bulk SMS related revenue generated through Raw Mobility's platform,
> presenting me as a Mobivate employee & consultant to customers without
> compensation and more - I have tried at every turn to find a compromise and
> preserve the integrity of Raw Mobility as a business and our relationship.
>
> Now we’re at a point where you renege on past agreements, slander me, and
> are actively moving existing customers from Raw Mobility’s platform onto
> your platform - in a direct conflict of interest and duty of loyalty as a
> director.
>
> Again - I propose we engage in mediation (per my email from 12/June/2025)
> to resolve this.
>
> Asaf
>
>
> On 30 Jul 2025, at 1:15 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Asaf
>
>    - Once again, you have failed to respond to my question as to how the
>    amount is calculated
>    - I have never agreed for Raw Mobility to pay for the expenses of a
>    Shamir Holdings employee
>    - There has never been any disclosure by you, that this was being done
>    - I did agree for Raw Mobility to hire a developer in its own capacity
>    - please send me with immediate effect:
>       - the name of this employee that is being paid for by Raw Mobility
>       - his/her address, email address and mobile phone number
>       - payslips for this employee for the last 18 months
>       - written confirmation that this employee works exclusively and on
>       a full time basis on
>       software owned by Raw Mobility
>    - Should you fail (*as I expect*) to provide this information, then
>    please do not make a single further
>    payment out of Raw Mobility, in this regard.
>
> Yours faithfully
>
> Brad Gishen
>
> On Tue, Jul 29, 2025 at 8:22 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au> wrote:
>
>> Brad,
>>
>>
>>    1. It seems that for some reason you’re trying to create an
>>    artificial dispute between us with false allegations.
>>    2. I spoke to the bank again, and I urge you to contact them, and as
>>    a director and majority shareholder - they’ll provide you with all needed
>>    information and more at your request.
>>    3. As was discussed between us many times, and by your request &
>>    approval - those expenses are related to a Shamir Holdings employee that is
>>    providing software development & support services to Raw Mobility. This has
>>    been the case for nearly 7 years, so I’m unsure about the meaning behind
>>    your question.
>>    4. Your conduct toward me over the past months, which includes
>>    numerous false allegations and ongoing attempts to escalate into
>>    manufactured conflict between us, raises questions regarding your
>>    motivations. I hope this does not include any hidden intentions regarding
>>    our longstanding partnership, the company, and its activities.
>>
>>
>> Regards,
>> Asaf
>>
>>
>> On 27 Jul 2025, at 11:16 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Asaf
>>
>> I am still waiting for an explanation of the *R&D expense* - exactly
>> what it is and how it is calculated?
>>
>> Asaf, despite your ongoing *unlawful* withholding of information, I can
>> assure you I have and will get every single thing I need.
>>
>> Please send me an immediate explanation and to reiterate what was said to
>> you previously:
>>
>> *Your continued non-cooperation is both ill-advised and detrimental to
>> your own best interests. *
>>
>> Brad Gishen
>>
>> On Thu, Jun 12, 2025 at 9:00 AM Eli Lebovits <Eli@gsca.com.au> wrote:
>>
>>> Brad
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> I understand that Shamir Holdings performs services for Raw Mobility.
>>> In return for these services, Shamir Holdings invoices Raw Mobility.  In
>>> essence, Shamir Holdings therefore contracts to Raw Mobility.  The fees
>>> invoices by Raw Mobility for these services are what I have referred to as
>>> contracting services.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> I cannot explain why the Sassu file records the amount as R&D.  It is
>>> entirely plausible that the bookkeeper did this in error.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> In terms of how the amount is calculated, you will need to seek
>>> confirmation of the methodology directly with Asaf.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Regards,
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> *Eli Lebovits **CA*  I  Director
>>>
>>> *Green & Sternfeld Pty Ltd*
>>> Office Address: Level 1, 1133-1145 Malvern Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144
>>> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/1133-1145+Malvern+Road,+Malvern,+Victoria+3144?entry=gmail&source=g>
>>>
>>> Postal Address: PO Box 7005, Glen Iris, Victoria 3146
>>>
>>> T: + 61 3 9527 5041  I  F: + 61 3 9527 2297  I  M: + 61 405 41 61 61
>>> eli@gsca.com.au   I  www.gsca.com.au
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> *From:* bradgish <brad@bradgish.com>
>>> *Sent:* Thursday, 12 June 2025 4:30 PM
>>> *To:* Eli Lebovits <Eli@

[... truncated ...]

================================================================================
#89  2025-08-01T09:58:03+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
Subject: Brad dispute questions and proof 

-- 
   Asaf Shamir
m: 61417188345
s: asaf-shamir

================================================================================
#90  2025-08-05T00:50:57+10:00
From:    Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au>
To:      Brad Gishen <brad@bradgish.com>
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: 2024 Income Tax Return and Financial Report - Raw
 Mobility Pty Ltd

Dear Brad,

> indicates that you are deliberately withholding information

 
You have full visibility - via our shared accountant, Saasu accounting system (which you were invited to join), and company bank account (which you were also invited to gain access to). 
Moreover - we discussed the recent cost increases in relation to this matter in Nov 2023 over WhatsApp, in full transparency.
 
In contrast - over the past 14 years or so Raw Mobility has charged Mobivate a percentage of revenue, yet you have not disclosed Mobivate’s Bulk SMS revenue even once - and RM had to rely only on information available on its platform despite my request for transparency.
 
> has nothing at all to do with R&D.

 
I am frankly baffled at this bizarre exchange.
 
> Raw Mobility will no longer pay an amount to Shamir Holdings to cover the cost of a Shamir Holdings employee without full visibility

 
I trust this email clearly demonstrates my transparency regarding the costs and supports the continuation of Raw Mobility’s monthly payments. 

As discontinuing the monthly payments would result in the cessation of all additional support and development services provided by the employee, I urge you to reconsider your position - as it only serves to impair Raw Mobility’s operational capacity.  
 
Regards,
Asaf

> On 31 Jul 2025, at 9:24 pm, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com> wrote:
> 
> Dear Asaf
> 
> I confirm receipt of your email dated 31 July 2025, which: 
> as expected does not answer my questions
> indicates that you are deliberately withholding information
> is defamatory of me and Mobivate Limited in which such defamation, our rights are reserved
> inaccurately grossly breaches customer confidentiality 
> is littered with nonsense and incorrect facts
> Your request to prove that I asked you to hire someone directly via Raw Mobility is absurd and will be treated 
> with the contempt it deserves. 
> 
> Your email of 29 July 2025, is an admission that the R&D expenses are in fact "expenses related to a Shamir
> Holdings employee" and has nothing at all to do with R&D.
> 
> Raw Mobility will no longer pay an amount to Shamir Holdings to cover the cost of a Shamir Holdings employee 
> without full visibility of what that employee costs, which you need to provide with immediate effect.
> 
> Lastly I will not waste my time on mediation and as mentioned before am proceeding with a forensic auditor.
> 
> Yours faithfully
> 
> Brad Gishen
> On Thu, 31 Jul 2025 at 00:58, Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>> Brad,
>> 
>> Could you please provide me with a copy of the agreement/direction to engage this developer directly via Raw Mobility Pty Ltd that you have indicated you provided?
>>  
>> Your request here is more than a little surprising, given that we had conversations about this matter back in 2018 where I stated that I (rather than RM) would hire a developer following your (as a director) repeated refusals to agree not to compete with Raw Mobility & threats to build a competing system at Mobivate.
>>  
>> The goal was to provide relief to concerns regarding support availability & workload, and those were addressed through hiring the developer.
>>  
>> Moreover, you have been signing Raw Mobility ITRs for years where the "Salaries & Wages” section only reflects the agreed upon wages being part of my remuneration ($60k) with no developer wages evident in these ITRs.
>>  
>> I confirm that the developer works 100% of his time (including after hours & support) on Raw Mobility.
>>  
>> Please confirm again whether you would like the developer to stop work/support on Raw Mobility related software.
>> 
>> ---
>> 
>> I’d just like to point out that we created this company to develop the software and sell Bulk SMS - I partnered with you for your expertise in driving sales just as you partnered with me for my technical skills.
>>  
>> Once the product became viable - you demanded the source code, and eventually decided to resell the software via your own company (Mobivate), own the customers (nearly 13,000 at this point), and divert profits and opportunities from our joint business.
>>  
>> Last month (June 2025) alone YOUR gross profit that is visible on Raw Mobility’s platform exceeded $2.5 million (AUD) whereas Raw Mobility’s stood at $560k (of which the majority, again, goes to you).
>>  
>> Despite your repeated attempts to acquire RMs source code by threats and intimidation, threats to develop a competing product, non-disclosure of Bulk SMS related revenue generated through Raw Mobility's platform, presenting me as a Mobivate employee & consultant to customers without compensation and more - I have tried at every turn to find a compromise and preserve the integrity of Raw Mobility as a business and our relationship.
>>  
>> Now we’re at a point where you renege on past agreements, slander me, and are actively moving existing customers from Raw Mobility’s platform onto your platform - in a direct conflict of interest and duty of loyalty as a director.
>> 
>> Again - I propose we engage in mediation (per my email from 12/June/2025) to resolve this.
>> 
>> Asaf
>> 
>> 
>>> On 30 Jul 2025, at 1:15 am, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Hi Asaf 
>>> Once again, you have failed to respond to my question as to how the amount is calculated
>>> I have never agreed for Raw Mobility to pay for the expenses of a Shamir Holdings employee
>>> There has never been any disclosure by you, that this was being done
>>> I did agree for Raw Mobility to hire a developer in its own capacity 
>>> please send me with immediate effect:
>>> the name of this employee that is being paid for by Raw Mobility
>>> his/her address, email address and mobile phone number
>>> payslips for this employee for the last 18 months
>>> written confirmation that this employee works exclusively and on a full time basis on 
>>> software owned by Raw Mobility 
>>> Should you fail (as I expect) to provide this information, then please do not make a single further
>>> payment out of Raw Mobility, in this regard.  
>>> Yours faithfully
>>> 
>>> Brad Gishen
>>> 
>>> On Tue, Jul 29, 2025 at 8:22 AM Asaf Shamir <asaf@shamir.com.au <mailto:asaf@shamir.com.au>> wrote:
>>>> Brad,
>>>> 
>>>> It seems that for some reason you’re trying to create an artificial dispute between us with false allegations.
>>>> I spoke to the bank again, and I urge you to contact them, and as a director and majority shareholder - they’ll provide you with all needed information and more at your request.
>>>> As was discussed between us many times, and by your request & approval - those expenses are related to a Shamir Holdings employee that is providing software development & support services to Raw Mobility. This has been the case for nearly 7 years, so I’m unsure about the meaning behind your question.
>>>> Your conduct toward me over the past months, which includes numerous false allegations and ongoing attempts to escalate into manufactured conflict between us, raises questions regarding your motivations. I hope this does not include any hidden intentions regarding our longstanding partnership, the company, and its activities.
>>>> 
>>>> Regards,
>>>> Asaf
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>>> On 27 Jul 2025, at 11:16 PM, bradgish <brad@bradgish.com <mailto:brad@bradgish.com>> wrote:
>>>>> 
>>>>> Hi Asaf
>>>>> 
>>>>> I am still waiting for an explanation of the R&D expense - exactly what it is and how it is calculated?
>>>>> 
>>>>> Asaf, despite your ongoing unlawful withholding of information, I can assure you I have and will get every single thing I need.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Please send me an immediate explanation and to reiterate what was said to you previously:
>>>>> 
>>>>> Your continued non-cooperation is both ill-advised and detrimental to your own best interests. 
>>>>> 
>>>>> Brad Gishe

[... truncated ...]

